Book of Heroes

Sword vs Axe

Im confused about something. Why would anyone choose the sword over the axe for a Justicar? It's the same price and has more damage per second and damage.
Because the sword is faster and in certain situations that can be beneficial. I like 2h axes personally but there are options for people that want to play differently.
I am under the illusion that carrying a sword (giving me the ability to carry a shield) will help with my blocking ability...

Any idea if carrying a shield does help or hinder? I wondered about carrying a light versus heavy shield as well. I reasoned (again, in my head, not because of any observation made in the game) that a heavy shield with better armor would reduce my agility and hence my blocking may be greater, but dodging and haste may be reduced. Whereas a light shield would give me greater agility with less blocking ability.

*shrug*
I use the 2-H sword instead of the axe. Faster attack speed is more important to me than damage at high might. The extra 0.1 sec can be the difference between attacking before an enemy or after
Mscdman wrote:Im confused about something. Why would anyone choose the sword over the axe for a Justicar? It's the same price and has more damage per second and damage.


There are both 1-H and 2-H swords and 1-H and 2-H axes available to the Justicar. You appear to be measuring the 1-H axe against the 1-H sword, as they're the same price.

It's a matter of choosing the weapon speed vs. damage combination that works for your skill set and rotation.

With a 1-H sword and 0.75 second on the clock my Justi can get in a Brutal Strike (0.5 seconds ) and still get in the stun (.25 seconds).

1-H axe takes 0.55 seconds for Brutal Strike, and 0.3 seconds for the Stun. 0.1 seconds slower.

2-H sword takes 0.65 for the Brutal strike, and 0.35 for the stun. 0.25 seconds slower.

2-H axe takes 0.7 seconds for Brutal Strike, and 0.35 for the stun, total 1.05 seconds, 0.3 seconds slower than the 1-H sword - so if I can't be sure the strike will kill the foe I have to forego that and just stun (hoping that hits), or take damage. 0.3 seconds additinal time allows me to throw in a Seismic Slash (0.25 seconds) with the sword.

For many hordes the 2-H axe is just overkill anyway, if the fore has 1000 hit points, why do you need a weapon that hits for 5,000 but allows you to get hit first?

The usual horde sequence is - Divine Power - Warcry - Seismic Slash - Cleave. Sometimes you can miss out Warcry, soemtimes seismic Slash does it all, sometimes cleave isn't the end and you need to mop up, but let's look at that seqeunce as a comparison.

1-H Sword - Divine Power 0.25 - Warcry 0.25 - Seismic Slash 0.25 - Cleave 0.75 total 1.5 Seconds

1-H Axe - Divine Power 0.25 - Warcry 0.25 - Seismic Slash 0.30 - Cleave 0.85 total 1.65 Seconds

2-H Sword - Divine Power 0.25 - Warcry 0.25 - Seismic Slash 0.35 - Cleave 1.00 total 1.85 Seconds

2-H Axe - Divine Power 0.25 - Warcry 0.25 - Seismic Slash 0.35 - Cleave 1.05 total 1.9 Seconds


Carrying a shield gives you a block bonus, and adds to your armor. Your dodge ability is unaffected by your weapon/shield combination. Even going empty handed does not increase your dodge. Justicars should always favor heavy over light shields for the extra blocking bonus and armor, but they cost a bit more.
Yes, I don't know of any benefits of using a light shield instead of a heavy one.

As for weapon speed, I originally opted for 1H axe for my Shadow Walker, because I thought the slower speed would mean I'd have to wait less for ability cool-downs. and at the same time get higher DPS.

Then with the new onslaught raid type, I thought I'd probably benefit more from being able to use my abilities faster.

That does serm to help, but also means I more often have to wait for cool-downs. As I predicted.