Book of Heroes

The CK to Vallus might jump is too large...

Ok so our guild has been facing this down for some time now and it finally came to a head with the exodus of several of our key raiders. The main issue we've faced for weeks now is the might jump from CK to Vallus. It is a substantial jump in numbers and those not willing, or unable, to spend cash for the gs needed to purchase gems can become stuck at this level for a very long time. I have 3 characters and I paid for the gems on 2 of them right away but wanted to take the third up without spending so I tried and after several weeks of farming every afternoon during our raiding dead zone I was still unable to get close the the might value needed. The gems that I needed would just not drop. Bad luck or whatever, I finally caved and purchased the gs needed but not everyone can do that.

Our guild has been fairly successful to this point, currently sitting in 5th, we even had a brief time in 4th before falling back. But the problem is we were unable to do much about luck when it comes to gem drops and a good number of our raiders have been unable to progress to Vallus. This resulted in a split between people who could raid Vallus and those that couldn't. Obviously raiding both Vallus and CK enabled the higher might raiders to progress much faster further widening the gap. This split in our guild has resulted in frustrations that led to the recent departure of a good number of our high end raiders. They left to move on to guilds that had progressed to Vallus and beyond. While we are completing Vallus twice a day that is as far as we can progress until more move forward. Unfortunately a good number of our players remain stuck at the CK level waiting for gems to drop from boss farming. We've run Vallus and CK enough that I have full T11 on two of my characters and am working on Level 4 gems already. The lack of progress has taken its toll.

Solutions for this problem could be increasing Level 3 gem drop rates, decreasing the gold required to purchase level 3 gems, or lowering the might requirement for Vallus. For a guild to keep moving forward there needs to be a feeling of progress. Getting stuck like this at a particular level only leads to frustration and every casual guild is going to be facing this. It will cause the same split and the people in the guild willing to spend cash will eventually get fed up and leave for one of the upper guilds. This causes lower guilds to flounder endlessly in place in an attempt to get enough raiders at a high enough level to progress. Since that isn't much fun they will eventually fold and stop playing.

I know some have managed to make the jump without spending cash but there is a great degree of luck involved in this regarding gem drops so consider yourselves lucky if you managed it. I know that is not the norm as we have seen in our guild.

If any of you have a solution for this issue that does not involve luck or money I would love to hear it.

Venan you have a great game here and I've put many hours into it at this point. I hope there is something you can do about this because I hate seeing this happen to our guild. Please do something to help alleviate this problem.

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu Aug 23, 2012 4:53 pm
The Shadow Comes was added to address the Might difference between Cursed Keep and Vale of the Ice Dragon. The rewards are actually the same for both The Shadow Comes and Vale of the Ice Dragon, except The Shadow Comes only has a 7250 Might requirement.

Darkhorse

Site AdminThu Aug 23, 2012 5:24 pm
This is what happens when a guild progresses too fast and focuses on rank instead of bring the overall member's might up. The gap between each member's might can't be too big. If too big it divides the guild between high might and low might players. Then the GM has to make a decission whether to kick the low might players and recruit more high might players or downgrade the raids in order to help low might players to catch up. This is the dilemma for every guild in this game. The ideal is to do the raids base on majority might, you shouldn't rush the raids. In your case, if half the guild are not Vallus ready, then the guild shouldn't do Vallus, it should stick to CK or SC or Helion or Zuur whichever is suitable until majority of the guild are Vallus ready. You can throw in just one vallus per day to motivate high might players but anymore than that will stall the progress of low might players. But if you want to be like KGW, jumped within top 5 in merely 2 weeks by doing power raids without worrying about the gap, as soon as reaching top 5 then kicked all the low might players and recruited high might players, sure you can do it if you don't mind kicking all the low might players even if they are active but cannot reach required might in time just becacuse the guild progresses too fast.
Little_Mike wrote:The Shadow Comes was added to address the Might difference between Cursed Keep and Vale of the Ice Dragon. The rewards are actually the same for both The Shadow Comes and Vale of the Ice Dragon, except The Shadow Comes only has a 7250 Might requirement.

The Shadow Comes is not considered a true raid by most in our guild. It is highly imbalanced per class, hard to run without very high attendance or gs pumping, and is honestly just not fun. Our Justicars mostly refuse to run it because it is so unfair for them. It is far from a good solution to this problem.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Aug 23, 2012 5:32 pm
TCG_Garrison64 wrote:
I have 3 characters and I paid for the gems on 2 of them right away but wanted to take the third up without spending so I tried and after several weeks of farming every afternoon during our raiding dead zone I was still unable to get close the the might value needed. The gems that I needed would just not drop. Bad luck or whatever, I finally caved and purchased the gs needed but not everyone can do that.

Overview:
Soldier Valor. Soldier Valor. Soldier Valor.

Body:
I noticed my v1.2 Level 20 characters with Epic Items were trapped around 2- 4K Might Rating when v1.3 came out because of Dungeon Boss Gem Drop rates. They could not even go into Fellmarsh without being defeated by Triple Groups.

CJ loves to start characters from Level 1 and currently has a Free ($0 IAP) v1.3 Level 25 Justicar with 7,334 Might Rating.

We discovered that Dungeon Boss farming is only effective for starting v1.3+ characters.

I did not want to delete my old characters. We finally figured out how to get my v1.2 characters better without spending real world money, Soldier Valor Raids.

If you Concentrate on Soldier Valor Raids, you can get all Tier 10 Items and Tier 3 Gems. "Risen from the Depths" is Soldier Valor and only a 1800 Might Raid. Either Merc for Soldier Valor or take a Sabbatical and join and Guild currently on Soldier Valor.

If you are very, very patient, CJ even got some Tier 10 & Tier 11 Items by farming for silver and then using Alchemist Lockbox before our Guilds got access to Soldier & Knight Valor.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
In v1.2 Named Weapon,s like Deathwing, and Named Armor Bundles, like Phoenix Plate, gave people with real world money to spend an advantage over getting the Best of the Best. In v1.3+ you cannot buy Tier 11 Items or Tier 4 Gems, you must raid for Knight Valor.

Venan has to make money. High Might Rating characters use up more resources. Raiding encourages people to get together with friends and play. The more people who play, the more money Venan makes. v1.3+ is all about Raids and Valor.

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu Aug 23, 2012 5:36 pm
TCG_Garrison64 wrote:
Little_Mike wrote:The Shadow Comes was added to address the Might difference between Cursed Keep and Vale of the Ice Dragon. The rewards are actually the same for both The Shadow Comes and Vale of the Ice Dragon, except The Shadow Comes only has a 7250 Might requirement.

The Shadow Comes is not considered a true raid by most in our guild. It is highly imbalanced per class, hard to run without very high attendance or gs pumping, and is honestly just not fun. Our Justicars mostly refuse to run it because it is so unfair for them. It is far from a good solution to this problem.

So.. I did a little number crunching. On average, more gold shields are spent on Vallus than The Hunter, and less energy is spent on The Hunter than Vallus on successful completions. But in any case, we understand the issues some people have with Onslaught and we are currently looking at ways to improving it.
Darkhorse wrote:This is what happens when a guild progresses too fast and focuses on rank instead of bring the overall member's might up. The gap between each member's might can't be too big. If too big it divides the guild between high might and low might players. Then the GM has to make a decission whether to kick the low might players and recruit more high might players or downgrade the raids in order to help low might players to catch up. This is the dilemma for every guild in this game. The ideal is to do the raids base on majority might, you shouldn't rush the raids. In your case, if half the guild are not Vallus ready, then the guild shouldn't do Vallus, it should stick to CK or SC or Helion or Zuur whichever is suitable until majority of the guild are Vallus ready. You can throw in just one vallus per day to motivate high might players but anymore than that will stall the progress of low might players. But if you want to be like KGW, jumped within top 5 in merely 2 weeks by doing power raids without worrying about the gap, as soon as reaching top 5 then kicked all the low might players and recruited high might players, sure you can do it if you don't mind kicking all the low might players even if they are active but cannot reach required might in time just becacuse the guild progresses too fast.

Most of us weren't focused on rank when it happened. A few were but it wasn't our guilds goal to reach a high rank. We just happened to have a solid raid schedule and fantastic attendance during that period of growth. Because of our raiding schedule and consistency we moved up the chart pretty fast but that wasn't what caused the issues. Everything was fine until we unlocked Vallus which you can't help but do once you do CK a few times. After that a number of people, enough to run Vallus, wanted to move foward so we set up a schedule that included both Vallus and CK as well as some lower end raiding. Everyone was being taken care of. The issue is the gems. Most already had full T-10 but getting the Level 3 gems for the might jump to Vallus is just luck if you are dependant on farming bosses. Even running CK twice a day you don't get enough KnV to gear up very quickly and T-11 by itself only provides a small jump in might with each piece. The issue is still the gems. Trust me I went through this on 3 characters so I have a pretty good idea where the problem lies.

Darkhorse

Site AdminThu Aug 23, 2012 5:44 pm
MurrayPub wrote:This is what happens when a guild progresses too fast and focuses on rank instead of bring the overall member's might up. The gap between each member's might can't be too big. If too big it divides the guild between high might and low might players. Then the GM has to make a decission whether to kick the low might players and recruit more high might players or downgrade the raids in order to help low might players to catch up. This is the dilemma for every guild in this game. The ideal is to do the raids base on majority might, you shouldn't rush the raids. In your case, if half the guild are not Vallus ready, then the guild shouldn't do Vallus, it should stick to CK or SC or Helion or Zuur whichever is suitable until majority of the guild are Vallus ready. You can throw in just one vallus per day to motivate high might players but anymore than that will stall the progress of low might players. But if you want to be like KGW, jumped within top 5 in merely 2 weeks by doing power raids without worrying about the gap, as soon as reaching top 5 then kicked all the low might players and recruited high might players, sure you can do it if you don't mind kicking all the low might players even if they are active but cannot reach required might in time just becacuse the guild progresses too fast.

Forgot to add, if all the low might players in the guild are very casual, then GM has to make hard decission whether to kick them in order to keep the high might players or keep the casuals and pursuade high might players to stay. GM needs to do something on this matter. Casual players in this game rely on hardcore players in order to get taste of successful raids. Without hardcore players, bunch of casual players will have hard to completing raids without spending money on Gold Shields. It is the hard truth. This game requires players to be committed, to be able to come in burn the energy and leave. If any players can only raid once a day, log in play for an hour then logs off 24 hours, they shouldn't even join the guild. The point of join the guild is to raid and socialize, if they can't do neither, they should do the guild a favor by leaving that guild. That's why I'm guildless right now, because I rarely play this game much as long as no new contents are introduced.
Backing way down to run only SV raids until people catch up is a sure fire way to lose upper end people. It's so hard for people to have patience in games like this. You progress or die. That is the unfortunate fact. Everything up to CK is fine. After Vallus it's fine. It's that jump from CK to Vallus that screws everything up.

Darkhorse

Site AdminThu Aug 23, 2012 5:55 pm
TCG_Garrison64 wrote:
MurrayPub wrote:This is what happens when a guild progresses too fast and focuses on rank instead of bring the overall member's might up. The gap between each member's might can't be too big. If too big it divides the guild between high might and low might players. Then the GM has to make a decission whether to kick the low might players and recruit more high might players or downgrade the raids in order to help low might players to catch up. This is the dilemma for every guild in this game. The ideal is to do the raids base on majority might, you shouldn't rush the raids. In your case, if half the guild are not Vallus ready, then the guild shouldn't do Vallus, it should stick to CK or SC or Helion or Zuur whichever is suitable until majority of the guild are Vallus ready. You can throw in just one vallus per day to motivate high might players but anymore than that will stall the progress of low might players. But if you want to be like KGW, jumped within top 5 in merely 2 weeks by doing power raids without worrying about the gap, as soon as reaching top 5 then kicked all the low might players and recruited high might players, sure you can do it if you don't mind kicking all the low might players even if they are active but cannot reach required might in time just becacuse the guild progresses too fast.

Most of us weren't focused on rank when it happened. A few were but it wasn't our guilds goal to reach a high rank. We just happened to have a solid raid schedule and fantastic attendance during that period of growth. Because of our raiding schedule and consistency we moved up the chart pretty fast but that wasn't what caused the issues. Everything was fine until we unlocked Vallus which you can't help but do once you do CK a few times. After that a number of people, enough to run Vallus, wanted to move foward so we set up a schedule that included both Vallus and CK as well as some lower end raiding. Everyone was being taken care of. The issue is the gems. Most already had full T-10 but getting the Level 3 gems for the might jump to Vallus is just luck if you are dependant on farming bosses. Even running CK twice a day you don't get enough KnV to gear up very quickly and T-11 by itself only provides a small jump in might with each piece. The issue is still the gems. Trust me I went through this on 3 characters so I have a pretty good idea where the problem lies.

I agree it's easy to reach 6250 Might but to get to Vallus might it does require moderate number of L3 gems. It is the exact situation my ex guild Celestial Being faced a long time ago. However, that situation really wasn't much of a situation since we did a month of none stop Helion raids with Zuur in between(I remember CK gave aweful Knight Valor rewards back then), it helped majority a lot in obtaining L3 gems by turning in Soldier's Valor. I guess we just lucky that majority at the time were committed so we never failed any Helions. When 2/3 of the guild were vallus ready, GM finally made new schedule to have steady Vallus. Any none-vallus-ready players farmed for L3 gems when Vallus was on. Eventually all caught up, any active none-Vallus-ready members eventually caught up the might, any casual none-Vallus-ready members were kicked out at the end, it is how we surged the rank back in the days.