Book of Heroes

Raid progression

I've noticed that many raids are tough to complete for small guilds, or inactive guilds. But there are some guilds like mine who are very active but we don't want lots of members. But as a result we don't get to complete many raids, which is kinda unfair as they are timer based. I mean in real life you would have your army attack another army and just at the point of killing the last person your alarm click goes off and you stop fighting cos your dinner is ready.

My suggestion for this issue do that all guilds have the potential to experience all raids and thus stay interested in the game and not getting bored would be to remove the time limited to complete a raid...

Each raid would be worth a set amount of points e.g 1st goblin raid could be worth 10000 points. This score then reduces by 10 each second the raid is active. So the quicker you beat the raid the more points you get, if you take too long you can still beat the raid and get kill exp and cash but no points

Each raid would need a certain amount if total raid points scored before the next raid is unlocked so in our goblin example it could need 20000 points earnt before next raid unlocked . This would mean that the very least time to unlock each raid would be 3 wind but would probably avg out to 5 or 6 victories but could go to 20 tries for small guilds etc.

That way we can have the potential to do all the raids at some point, even if it may take a while.

Show some love to the small guilds!

Thanks
I have thought about a similar idea but had been too lazy to type up the post. I really hate that for the most part raiding is a people scheduling issue and not game play. The more reward for faster completion would encourage GS burning - possibly even more so than the current model.

Hotasfire0Coolasice

Mon Sep 3, 2012 11:01 am
I like the idea, but your example is crazy. That's 3,000 points off every nrg regen. So if your guild doesnt have enough to finish before 3 nrg regens then u get nothing.
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:I like the idea, but your example is crazy. That's 3,000 points off every nrg regen. So if your guild doesnt have enough to finish before 3 nrg regens then u get nothing.

Sorry I might not have made it clear so example:

To unlock raid Z you need to score X points in raid A

Let's say that X = 4000

Complete raid A in 30 mins you get 1000 points;
Complete in 1 hour you get 750 points
Complete in 1 hour 30 you get 500
Anything after that gets 250

So it's no an individual score but one the guild receives, similar to the guild lvls. Amount of nrg spent completing raid is irrelevant

But It would mean that after time (could be a matter of weeks) even small guild could unlock later raids
DarkLondon,

Your suggestion isn't too far off from what happens today.

If you analyze the total Power earned versus the duration of successful raids for a single kind of raid (e.g., all of your Zuur runs), you'll see that all of the data points fit on a straight line. The raid starts off with a set amount of Power that your guild can earn. Each second that goes by, a little bit of Power is taken away. If you finish the raid with more than half of the original Power still on the table, your guild gets to keep what remains. If you take so long that half the original Power has evaporated, you fail the raid.

Each type of raid has a different starting amount of Power. The rate of Power removal is engineered so that exactly half the original Power will be gone by the time you reach the time limit for the raid.
But my suggestion would help with the guild quests of beat this raid X times which can be hard for small guilds unless we have 3 alts each 8)
Just so I understand, is your suggestion something like bypassing the time limit, allowing the Power earned to go below the half-way point, and giving the guild a consolation prize if they reach one fourth of the original Power?

I'm not sure if that's what you meant, but cheating that system would be really easy. You could kick off a ton of raids that you have no intention of completing and collect the consolation prizes on each.
You could counter that with having a min point req for consolation prize before it would be awarded
He isn't talking about power at all. He is talking about raid completion, payout and something similar to guild exp.
Since Power and Prestige are forms of Guild XP, I was trying to make a match between what DarkLondon was talking about and something that already existed. The guild is payed in Power for successfully completed raids. The payout scheme for Power matches a lot of what DarkLondon described, with some modifications.

DarkLondon, now that you know about how it is paid out, does Power match what you were envisioning? Or, are you thinking about a new form of payout? What could the guild do with this payout?