Book of Heroes

Overall Feedback - Length of the Battle - Improving Gameplay

Background:
~7000 Might War Mage - main
roughly $50 spent on shields.
Raided up to Cursed Keep and Crypt of Corruption
Highest raid RPP - 20155 on Cursed Keep in 52 minutes
Did not play any versions other than 1.4

----------------------

I wanted to give feedback on my overall thoughts about the game and its mechanics. Obviously, I am enjoying the game a lot and have played nonstop for a few weeks now. I started on 8/15. I gave my background so that experienced players would know how much of the game I have seen and where my point of view comes from.

Although I have not reached the highest levels of the game, I feel like I've experienced what there is to experience. The game becomes fairly repetitive and trivially easy.

I wanted to bring up a few points of discussion. Some of the topics overlap and can probably be broken into individual topics but I felt that it helps to look more at the game as a whole.

----------------------

1. The length of a battle - the main issue that all others stem from

This is not to be confused with the amount of TIme Committed to the game. See point #7.

Currently, all enemies can be dispatched so quickly, that a lot of the game mechanics become completely hidden. Most enemies, bosses included, can be destroyed before they can even launch a successful attack.

This point alone negates half of the game, defense. No decisions need to be made regarding armor, abilities, gems, etc, that involve anything with defense.

Also, buff durations are generally overlooked, since 5 seconds is more than enough time to kill just about anything and if it is not, characters have enough interrupts/stuns to self sustain.

----------------------

2. Durability of the character.

Partially due to #1, all characters can withstand even tougher enemies through the use of potions and interrupts. I've never actually died in this game and I'm not sure how it is possible to die, as long as you use a potion when you can.

The cost of items is insignificant and give you every ability you can think of. This includes damage at 0 time cost, cleansing of debuffs, interrupting enemy actions, etc.

This all happening at a 0 cost effectively creates invincibility for every character. However, increasing the silver costs of potions doesn't solve the problem, it only makes rich people stronger. Adding a casting time may add to strategic decisions, if the battles are toughened up.

As a war mage, I have a group interrupt, and a single interrupt, that will likely be available everytime that I need them. I am able to fight a boss and never take a hit. If I do take a hit, it will not kill me in one shot. I am able to use a potion and continue on with no decision making.

----------------------

3. RPP accumulation rate

As a side effect to #1, whichever class has the ability to dispatch enemies the quickest, will have the greatest RPP. By 'quickest' I mean in the least amount of commands, as this is a limitation of ability animations.

The situation I am speaking of, includes multiple people competing for 1st place, burning gold shields as needed.

At the moment, this should be the Shadow Walker combination of Vanish + Poison Cloud due to the complete effectiveness of having a 100% crit rate.

If a War Mage needs 3 abilities, for instance, Inner Focus, Fire Fracture, Flaming Pyre, to do the same thing, they will lose time each fight. This is a battle for time efficiency.

Similar to what happens in pretty much every MMO on the planet, offensively geared characters gain more experience, kills, points, etc, than support characters or tanks. I'm not sure if this is avoidable, but it can be addressed somewhat, by correcting the length of the battle thereby decreasing the difference between burst damage characters and non-burst characters.

Also, if the fights are harder, defensively geared characters will eventually spend less time healing/defending than offensive chars, who might possibly need to potion up, heal, stun properly, in order to survive.

----------------------

4. Stuns/interrupts

These spells are so incredibly powerful, it makes the difficulty of the game extremely hard to balance. A player's character can cast a plethora of spells before the enemy is able to respond.

Increasing the cooldowns for these abilities, to something extremely long, would make them require some more decision making before use. This would also have to be combined with increasing the length of the battle anyways, since one use of each interrupt is more than enough to win.

Monster abilities are so slow, that it is so easy to choreograph the entire fight the instant you see the timers at the beginning.

----------------------

5. Onslaught and buffs

This is an interesting concept, which kind of helps with the length of the battle issue but suffers slightly different problems, especially regarding buffs.

In group mob fights, self buffs rule supreme as they will carry over to the next set of mobs to kill and enemy debuffs are painful to use. (Vanish, Inner Focus, Divine Power)

A group fight might last 1 second, but a buff lasts 5 seconds. That is enough for 5 fights for a self buff, but only 1 fight for a debuff.

In boss fights, self buffs and enemy debuffs equal out, in terms of time invested and time rewarded, per cast. Things like fire/ice fracture and war cry become more viable.

----------------------

6. Difficulty

This is chosen by the creators, for their specific audience, that is perfectly fine. I don't mind if the game is easy, as it is meant to be casual, etc.

However, there's a difference between an easy game, if played well, and a game that requires almost no strategy, due to characters pretty much being too strong (or enemies too weak, however you would like to look at it)

I find myself just hitting the same spell combinations regardless of what I am fighting, and it always works. Even if I'm using fire spells against fire resistant enemies. (I believe people have even asked for macros, or presets based on their most used skills. This shows the repetition)

I don't need to make any strategic decisions in my fighting and only in Onslaught do I need to care about my spell order usage, which I like.

----------------------

7. Time Commitment

Right now, if I can complete a Trask run in about 4 minutes (3 minutes if I am really trying to go fast), thats 10 fights, about 24 seconds each. ( in-game seconds would be like 1-1.5 worth of actions per fight)

Do that 4 times with 42 energy max and my time commitment for that bar of energy was 16 minutes, completing 40 fights.


Let's say each battle was increased in length (not necessarily difficulty) and ended up taking 2 minutes real time, would that be bad?

Using the same time commitment, you could turn a trask run into 4 tough battles, regular enemies, small boss, regular enemies, boss fight. 8 minutes total per run. Two runs would be the same 16 minutes. This is similar to a raid setup like Cursed Keep. Increase the energy use to 20 for this dungeon to compensate for the time. Increase rewards proportionally.

Players would need to be mindful of when to buff, when to stun, when to heal, their cooldowns, and hopefully their defenses. You'd also want to make the decision of what monster to kill first, the one casting buffs, debuffs, damaging you, etc.

As a result, battles might be more engaging and less repetitive and come with the possibility of getting killed. I love the fear of death personally, but I'm sure its not for everyone. It makes me want to improve my char more, ie buy shields.

----------------------

Summary

Battles too short, characters too strong. (These two are the same thing really)

I feel like it would be more satisfying as a player, to have to respond to the enemies actions appropriately, in order to MAKE the game easy.

As length of battle increases, the desire for efficiency also increases, thereby the need for power and planning also increases and results in hopefully, more revenue.

You will find i say "hopefully" a million times in this post because of course everything in theoretical.

Great game. Hopefully I will be have enough Might for Vallus next week. hehe.

Aryantes
Brothers of the Twirled Mustache
I, (8750ish might SW), agree with almost everything you said. The only problem I have with it is the dungeon costing 20 energy. Almost everyone has at least 20 max energy by trask, but you'd need a different system for some of the other dungeons.
Pureawesomeness wrote:I, (8750ish might SW), agree with almost everything you said. The only problem I have with it is the dungeon costing 20 energy. Almost everyone has at least 20 max energy by trask, but you'd need a different system for some of the other dungeons.

That was just an example, you could scale all dungeons according to their difficulty and amount of time commitment you wish to have them experience at that level.

For instance, Kraken might not have 4 fights total, maybe just two fights, which by proportion would take the same 10 energy it does now. Some lower dungeons may only have a boss fight, etc. Same as raids right now, just implemented in a similar way for regular dungeon fights.

I'd also suggest adding in some energy recovery on a failed attempt, spend 10 to try, but gain back 5 if you lose. Something like that, in case difficulty is too high or if someone is just trying out a new area. Wasting energy is a rough feeling.

Thanks for reading.
That solves most of the problem, but let's say someone decides to finish all the quests then start raiding, and doesn't have the valor sigils. A way to solve this would be to make it so that if you have full energy you can enter it anyway, and have negative energy.
Pureawesomeness wrote:That solves most of the problem, but let's say someone decides to finish all the quests then start raiding, and doesn't have the valor sigils. A way to solve this would be to make it so that if you have full energy you can enter it anyway, and have negative energy.

That's a good idea. Or, it would just serve as a natural roadblock, to force people to do some raids before they can finish quests, depending on what the eventual goal is.

I think it would be cool to have a dungeon that takes 40 energy, has slightly higher rewards, it would only be accessible by people who have gotten enough KV. Something like that. Maybe it doesn't need to be part of the quest progression.
As long as we're suggesting semi off topic things. I would really like to see a survival area. With stages getting harder, and harder until you lose. Then a boss who can't die, gets harder with every point of damage he takes, and would give you rewards based on how much damage you do.
My suggestion for cost/rewards would be.
Cost: 40 energy, a 24h cd, and 100k silver.
Reward: SqV, and a small amount of GS, (starting at only 1), every once and awhile. Why it's only SqV is because of conversion. P.S. you could decide at the end to quickly convert a write in number of SqV to SoV, or KV.
Oh, and clear your schedule. It may take a while, although you could still pause at any time just like everything else. Thoughts?
That would be fun, as long as it is challenging.

I think if they balanced monsters a bit more, gameplay overall would improve.

Right now, enemies completely waste their time trying to debuff, or heal, its kind of sad.

I'd like to see boss situations that have 3 boss at once, with some that support, do damage, etc.