Book of Heroes

Suggested addition to raids

Hi,

Recently I think the high-end guilds are losing power because of burn-out. I used to love BoH when it was single player, but adding raids has been a blessing and a curse. I love the friendly cooperative nature of guild challenges, but the way raids are geared towards sapping the life out of you... well, the risk of failing raids can completely sap the joy out of playing.

Once you've done all the tasks, all there is left is to farm KV for level 4 gems. It's boring, it's low reward for high commitment, and most people have families and day jobs in real life that they need to attend to. As soon as you get a failed raid, it is massively discouraging - you and your guildmates invest hours of your time to get zero reward. Zero. Why should you make an effort to try again when you could be farming, or killing certain types of beasts for guild challenges, or even - shock horror - dealing with real life? You know, stress-free fun activities. Raiding is great when it works, but as soon as you start to fail (and it's inevitable - it will happen) it can set off a chain of discouragement and make future raids harder to coordinate. After all, you need to coordinate 20-30 people to play for three hours at the same time to do Vallus' raid.

My suggested solution is this. Add a new type of raid.

New Raid - Timing:
Short raids (equivalent to Goblins Gobbins) would be something like 3 hours, and longer raids would be 48 hours. Cooldown would be longer, say 48/72hrs for the long raids so they couldn't be abused. The raids would never end - you cannot 'finish' the raid in the traditional sense, you simply play as much as you want in the allotted time. There would be no goal other than to earn RPP. There would be no chance of failing.

New Raid - Rewards:
Start RPP rewards small, instead of 100 for the first kill make it 50. Each subsequent kill the guild makes during the raid period would increase a bonus multiplier, so if the first kill earns 50 RPP, the second kill would earn 51 (RPPx1.02 or something), the third kill would earn 52.02 RPP, and so on. The more energy is spent on the new type of raid would mean more RPP earned - the longer you play, the higher the reward - that would be the only goal/incentive.

It would also mean that guilds with a scattered global membership don't have to rely on people getting out of bed to help with the scheduled raid, or having to bend over backwards to do a quick energy burn in the small window that a raid is available. You would just pop in, burn, pop out, and jump back in later when it suits you - regardless of your timezone.

The rewards would be lower than doing the current high-risk raids, but the low-risk nature of the raid coupled with the fact that there is no goal other than to pump as much energy in as you can means it's low risk - you get *some* reward regardless of whether you manage a single 42e burn, or whether you pump in 100 shields. In addition to this, another type of raid should be able to run concurrently, if your guild attendance allows.

I think this would compliment the current raids and onslaughts nicely. It would give the high-end players something FUN to do whilst you add new content. It would make raiding have a low-risk FUN alternative. It would be once step closer to killing frustration and boredom. It would be the group-based guild equivalent of farming on your own.

Please consider this - I think the game desperately needs it.

Thanks,

Will_Hazkui
Guild: Chaos Brotherhood
I have been part of high-end raiding since raiding was introduced, and thus I have also experienced the burnout first-hand and among my guildies. I do agree with your characterization of the problem to some extent, and I like your suggestion.

However, I fear that the specific approach of "timing" raids simply lack a goal of some sorts. Your ideas could be implemented in the current raids if guilds were rewarded for completing phases rather than entire raids. To make sure that there is an incentive to complete raids, it could be made so that each completed phase increases the Valor/RPP for everyone. This gives guilds certain milestones along the way, and while giving a shared goal to strive for.

An example could be Forgotten Sentinels:
Completing phase 1 gives 30 valor/1000 RPP
Completing phase 2 gives 35 valor/1000 RPP
Completing phase 3 gives 40 valor/1000 RPP
Completing phase 4 gives 50 valor/1000 RPP

I do not have the current numbers for valor/1000 RPP for each raid right now, but the idea is that phase 2 should be equal to max valor in Cursed Keep, phase 3 should be equal to max valor in Vale of the Ice Dragon, and phase 4 should be equal to current valor from Forgotten Sentinels.

The effect here is that raids are not all-or-nothing, while there still is an incentive to give it all you can to reach the next phase. In addition, with the implementation of onslaught this means that "good" players can have a bigger impact on the performance of a guild.
The experience both of you describe matches what I have seen, too. It's depressing to feel a guild coming apart at the seams after you have invested so much personal energy in it.

New types of raids and rewards for completing Phases are ideas that have merit. I would just add the really simplistic request for new content to drive renewed interest.
I actually just hit the breaking point a few days ago where I decided I no longer have the will to raid.

I started playing on August 15th, so a lot shorter than some others in my guild and at ~8200 might doing Vallus and CK, I don't think I can grind for 2 weeks to get single T4 gem. (or however long, at 3-5 raids a day and minimal GS use and basically no risk of failure)

The reward for time investment now is just not there, especially since you don't need to be strong to accomplish anything.

Sure the RPP rate could be increased, but I think the real problem lies with the lack of real end-game content that requires tons of strong people to complete.

Strong, meaning strong characters, not people willing and financially capable of burning GS.

This would likely be a large development effort to satisfy a small portion of the community that is hardcore enough to even get to that point.
Even when there was nothing else to do in the game after the quests were done but the daily bounties (i.e. before 23rd May) or pointless monster bashing, I logged on with my 3 characters each day to do those bounties.

How about a Guild-based Daily Bounty, that requires a number of Guild members to log on to complete? They wouldn't all have to log on at the same time like a raid, but during the time limit of the task each member would need to expend 10 or so energy to help in a group goal. If more then the required number complete the bounty task (soas not to punich those in a later time zone) then everyone gets a share of whatever the reward is. To qualkify for the bounty you'd have to be a member of the Guild at the time the bounty was offered, so Mercenary characters can't claim several bounties in one day through Guild hopping.

For solo playing I'd like to see a voluntary 'daily bounty' option, where you go and see Daedalus (or soemeone else) and he offers you a bounty, as often as you choose to ask.
This may work for some.. And it seems to fit the existing game mechanics, but..but at the end of the day it is going to be as much fun as daily Trask/Vallus/Hunter farming - a repetitive act with no challenge whatsoever. The game indeed needs some high lvl/might content, but safe comfy raids are unlikely to add much vitality or interest for those close to burnout. In other words, I dont mind such raids being added, but as a nice little extra, such as daily bounties.

Some else major is needed. Like PvP (I kno, I kno) or some other form of joint activities...
How about opening up a totally different dimension, like coining up new raids into some kind of mission/raid quest?

These could be in a quest format, with a storyline of course, to be done by the guild.
I think this solution has a longer term potential so keep interest going as well as for further development, and might be an alternative to creating new raid format. This is because there would then be a goal, a still unknown goal... for the guild. To make it more challenging, there can even be rare guild dungeons, with special items where only certain class may enter.

That might help group people back into the guild concept, and guilds can make a decision whether to embark on the guild mission, or to just focus on raids... and help ease the burnout?
I was part of CB, when we were burning this place up. It was wicked. Then, after a while, it became an effort. For little to no reward. My Mage can destroy with the best of them, my SW, just the same. But to me, I doubt there is much that can be done.

I stopped playing maybe 3 to 4 weeks ago. Just checked in, no new content. But really, would any new content help? I'm not having a go either, I loved this game, just brilliant. But things change. And people move on. It's just the way it is. Looking forward to BoH2 :-)