Book of Heroes

Poaching Guild Members

Sorry if this is in the wrong forum. Mods please move if it is.

I run a guild. It's not great (hovers around the top 50) but it's not too casual. We have a pretty good core of loyal players that raid daily, and we welcome all players and mercs. We have a great time with progressing in raids.

Is it in bad form when people coming in and out of my guild (mercs, or non loyalists) try to poach my officers or veterans?

I say this because I would never consider doing that, and quite honestly it bothers me.

I'm lucky that the top 15-20 players in my guild are quite loyal, and luckier in the fact that all the officers and veterans are people I know personally so they have no intentions of leaving. They DO however, let me know when they are solicited invites to other guilds.

It's one thing to recruit on a board or in global, but to come into a guild that is trying to grow and attempt to talk members into leaving?

Just tryin to get your opinions on this etiquette.

I've never played any other game with online guilds or anything, so I'm unaware if this is normal and accepted, or in bad form.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Sep 13, 2012 3:31 pm
Orangebang wrote:

It's one thing to recruit on a board or in global, but to come into a guild that is trying to grow and attempt to talk members into leaving?

Hai5 and Bojun/Cavalier have been trying to get CJ to join them in Raids [Clarification: Merc] since v1.3 came out.

I consider it a high compliment to her.
BjofCJandBj wrote:
Hai5 and Bojun/Cavalier have been trying to get CJ to join them in Raids since v1.3 came out...

I don't recall I've ever talked to anyone in attempt to persuade him or her to leave his or her guild and join mine. As far as how new recruits join my guild is not of my concern since I have no way of knowing if there is poaching involved. If my members don't tell I don't ask.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorThu Sep 13, 2012 7:04 pm
Celestial_Hai5 wrote:
BjofCJandBj wrote:
Hai5 and Bojun/Cavalier have been trying to get CJ to join them in Raids since v1.3 came out...

I don't recall I've ever talked to anyone in attempt to persuade him or her to leave his or her guild and join mine. As far as how new recruits join my guild is not of my concern since I have no way of knowing if there is poaching involved. If my members don't tell I don't ask.

Same here. I don't recall talking to CJ or in fact to anyone else for the matter.
My personal opinion is that it *is* bad form to go into a guild and ask members to leave there in favor of joining your home guild. It is, however, okay to answer questions from people that are curious about your guild and express an interest. When in doubt, a mature conversation with the GM of the visited guild can resolve the matter very quickly.

We had an incident in my guild where a player from another guild joined ours temporarily and stirred up a hornets nest. He combed our roster and then sent email invitations to join his home guild to characters above a certain Might that were not Officers. Everyone was thoroughly incensed. Loyalty for our guild reached an all-time high that day. The "infiltrator" received a solid tongue lashing and ran back to his original guild.

All of that is to say that I consider poaching attempts not only unethical, but also empirically impractical.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Sep 14, 2012 3:25 am
Orangebang wrote:

It's one thing to recruit on a board or in global, but to come into a guild that is trying to grow and attempt to talk members into leaving?

Just tryin to get your opinions on this etiquette.

I've never played any other game with online guilds or anything, so I'm unaware if this is normal and accepted, or in bad form.

Real World Companies have this problem all the time. Is it Poaching? or is it Recruiting? If the employee is your only Computer Programmer, it may bankrupt the company. If the employee feels slighted by the Owner, or underpaid, everyone may be happier with the employee changing companies. The company I work at is notorious for treating its employees right. In the four years I have been there, many people have left for other companies and come back to work for mine a few months later. On the other hand, many people I was friends with have left to work at charities, after having done company work for the charity, or to start a small business with one of our clients.

When looking for employees in the Real World, first people prefer to hire/ promote people they have worked with, then friends, then people recommended by friends, then people recommended by a Temp Agency, lastly Advertisement.

Recruiting on BoH Forum or Global is like putting a sign up at the Local Food Court. Who knows who will answer?

Several people have Merc'd with Deathwing Raids/ TheFarmTeam and joined our Guild. Did they leave a Guild behind? I never ask.

Raiding with a Merc, or Mercing and raiding with a Guild, lets you see how people act in Raids.
Are they chatty? Silent? Complainers?
Is their Guild Chat PG? R? NC-17?
Is their Guild Chat female friendly?
Is their Guild Chat all about the latest Sons of Anarchy TV Episode? Dr. Who Episode? Katy Perry Album? NFL game?
Do they share Tips? Burn Gold Shields/ Minor Spirit Runes/ Major Spirit Runes?
Do they cancel when the Raid falls behind, to 12 Purple Hearts per minute, thus sparing the low level members with 12 energy and less than 1,000 Silver Coins? Or do they spend Gold Shields like water before going back to their stressful but high paying Software Programmer Job?
Does the Guild Master/ Officers/ Veterans kick people out for arbitrary reasons? Does the Guild follow its posted guidelines? Does the Guild raid when it says it will Raid? and what it says it will Raid?

Just like a Lawyer/ Doctor/ Accountant/ Friends, you should try and find a Guild, or recruit Guild members, that fit with your personal style of play.

Life is too short for bad Raids.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Sep 14, 2012 3:29 am
BjofCJandBj wrote:
Orangebang wrote:

It's one thing to recruit on a board or in global, but to come into a guild that is trying to grow and attempt to talk members into leaving?

Hai5 and Bojun/Cavalier have been trying to get CJ to join them in Raids [Clarification: Merc] since v1.3 came out.

I consider it a high compliment to her.

For Clarification, my wife Mercs. I was told Galadriel, her 10.4K Might Rating Justicar, has been invited to Merc with Hai5 and Bojun/ Cavalier. According to both of them, she has never been invited.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Sep 14, 2012 3:48 am
routters wrote:
We had an incident in my guild where a player from another guild joined ours temporarily and stirred up a hornets nest. He combed our roster and then sent email invitations to join his home guild to characters above a certain Might that were not Officers. Everyone was thoroughly incensed.

Regardless of what you call it, Poaching or Recruiting, this is just tacky. I do not like eSPAM filling up my inbox with cheap Viagra offers. That is really all this player did.

I do not mind if a friend sends me an email about the new David Weber book, but my friends know my taste in books. If there was a Guild in BoH that did mostly Research, I would probably Merc with them or Join them. [ducking CC's thrown yogurt]

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Sep 14, 2012 4:07 am
BjofCJandBj wrote:
When looking for employees in the Real World, first people prefer to hire/ promote people they have worked with, then friends, then people recommended by friends, then people recommended by a Temp Agency, lastly Advertisement.

Recruiting on BoH Forum or Global is like putting a sign up at the Local Food Court. Who knows who will answer?

Several people have Merc'd with Deathwing Raids/ TheFarmTeam and joined our Guild. Did they leave a Guild behind? I never ask.

Raiding with a Merc, or Mercing and raiding with a Guild, lets you see how people act in Raids.

To Clarify, currently BoH has Solo Content and Raiding. Except for Mercing, there is no current mechanic for finding out which of several Guilds you want to join, or who of 60 Guild members fit well with your style of play.