Book of Heroes

Smite reduced damage to tool tip info - WILL NOT FIX

Hi,

This is more of a tooltip bug but here we go:

Smite: A spirit attack that deals 250% weapon damage. The attack cannot be avoided. 912-1027

Attack: Basic Attack that deals 100% weapon damage. 506-552

So following these tool tips smite's basic non-magic boosted damage should be 506 x 2.5 = 1265
552 x 2.5 = 1380

So smite should deal 1265 - 1380 damage (going by the tool tip alone). How ever as the above numbers confirm my smite (magic boosted by hero tokens to 96 +5% magic buff = 100 magic stat) only deals a high of 1027 damage. where have the other 353 damage gone?

From the current numbers Smite's tooltip should really read: A spirit attack that deals 186% weapon damage. The attack cannot be avoided.

Is this a bug or has the tool tip just been written badly?


Attached are images of my stats (the ones that are relevant) the damage of my basic attack and the damage of my smite tool tips. Hopefully this helps. http://imageshack.us/g/824/img0344b.png/

I use an iPod touch iOS 5.1 (or what ever it is now)

Kind regards

Genoshock

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorMon Sep 17, 2012 1:35 am
Hi Genoshock there is nothing wrong with the tooltip rather there is just a difference in your melee and magic ratings. The 250% damage of smite 3 over the basic attack would only be true if your melee and magic ratings are the same.

My current smite 3 damage range is 1555-1855 while basic attack is 624-744 and their quotient is slightly over 249%. My melee damage is 284 and magic damage is 282. I'm very sure your melee damage is much higher than your magic damage. My guess using rough computation is it is around 130 - 135.
tool tip clearly says 250% of weapon damage... unless your basic attack somehow uses magic in it I completely disagree with your analysis. I know that smite grows in damage with bonus magic but that should be on top of the 250% weapons damage bonus ... or then the tool tip's description of how the damage is generated is really wrong ....


i know that smite damage does grow with from bonus magic damage but that should be on top of the 250% weapon damage... so for you it should read 250% of your weapon damage + 250 bonus magic damage giving you a range starting with 1750~ not 1560 ... atleast

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorMon Sep 17, 2012 5:03 am
Please reread the smite 3 description it said spirit damage and nothing about weapon damage. Spirit damage is entirely dependent on your magic rating.
Celestial_Cavalier wrote:Please reread the smite 3 description it said spirit damage and nothing about weapon damage. Spirit damage is entirely dependent on your magic rating.

AHAHAHA sorry that was mean but it's just so funny!!! :lol: phew I haven't laughed like that in a while ... thank you

Please could you go read the smite tool tip from the character profile page. I think its the 3rd tab that looks like a 4 pointed star in a circle then scroll down to smite and read... enjoy, you lovable comedian :D

Please if anyone has any useful information about this i would love to hear what you have to say

for all you non justicars have a look here for the tool tip as it is shown on my iOS 5 ipod touch
http://imageshack.us/a/img440/574/img0349.png

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorMon Sep 17, 2012 6:47 am
Genoshock wrote:
Celestial_Cavalier wrote:Please reread the smite 3 description it said spirit damage and nothing about weapon damage. Spirit damage is entirely dependent on your magic rating.

AHAHAHA sorry that was mean but it's just so funny!!! :lol: phew I haven't laughed like that in a while ... thank you

Please could you go read the smite tool tip from the character profile page. I think its the 3rd tab that looks like a 4 pointed star in a circle then scroll down to smite and read... enjoy, you lovable comedian :D

Please if anyone has any useful information about this i would love to hear what you have to say

I wasn't looking on the abilities tab in the character profile rather in the actual attack buttons during an actual dungeon raid. I agree there was a "weapon" mentioned in the tool tip you were talking about. However you seem to be confusing yourself with the term weapon damage. Basic attack is dependent to your melee damage while smite 3 is dependent to your magic damage because it is a spirit attack. If you still don't believe me you can ask the devs and I assure you they will say the same. And you still havnt given your current melee damage.
notice how all your attacks say weapon damage and work of basic melee attacks. how is it that smite is the only one that has the exact same tool tip wording but uses magic power instead? btw i am asking the dev team as i assumed they would at some point read this.

notice how your basic attack says "deals 100% weapon damage". this attack does not benefit from magic on top of within the 100% of the weapon damage right? so now we look at smite, i know that it gets stronger with magic thats not my question at all. My question is that smites tool tip also says "deals 250% weapon damage". From this we should be able to conclude that smite hits 2.5 times harder than the basic attack before it is boosted by bonus magic. do you see where i am going with this?

say for you for example u have something like 600-700 basic damage that means you should be able to do 1500 - 1750 damage before you are boosted by (in your case by 250 points) bonus magic damage. in this case your real damage should be closer to 1700-1900 not what you have now ... as I cant see what numbers u actually gave me while typing this post: I have to do it from memory so your damage will probably be higher.

how ever for you, you only do 1500 damage after the magic boost ... this is my problem ... justicars are missing 300-400 damage each that translates to an additional 1200 crit damage with 300% crit damage...
Celestial_Cavalier wrote: And you still havnt given your current melee damage.

in my 1st post under Smite there is another line with attack ... have a look there

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorMon Sep 17, 2012 9:39 am
Genoshock wrote:notice how all your attacks say weapon damage and work of basic melee attacks. how is it that smite is the only one that has the exact same tool tip wording but uses magic power instead? btw i am asking the dev team as i assumed they would at some point read this.

notice how your basic attack says "deals 100% weapon damage". this attack does not benefit from magic on top of within the 100% of the weapon damage right? so now we look at smite, i know that it gets stronger with magic thats not my question at all. My question is that smites tool tip also says "deals 250% weapon damage". From this we should be able to conclude that smite hits 2.5 times harder than the basic attack before it is boosted by bonus magic. do you see where i am going with this?

say for you for example u have something like 600-700 basic damage that means you should be able to do 1500 - 1750 damage before you are boosted by (in your case by 250 points) bonus magic damage. in this case your real damage should be closer to 1700-1900 not what you have now ... as I cant see what numbers u actually gave me while typing this post: I have to do it from memory so your damage will probably be higher.

how ever for you, you only do 1500 damage after the magic boost ... this is my problem ... justicars are missing 300-400 damage each that translates to an additional 1200 crit damage with 300% crit damage...

You seem to have made a mistaken assumption regarding smite. Smite's damage comes entirely from magic as it is a magical spirit attack. It is not boosted by your melee weapon as you said above. The 250% mentioned can only be 250% of your basic melee damage if and only if your melee and magic damage (in the character sheet) are the same. In other words 250% is the maximum difference between smite 3 and basic attack. I'm curently at slightly over 249% as my melee is 284 and magic 282. You mentioned you are only at 186% with your magic at 100. Thats why I estimated your melee at around 130.
well then your method is also wrong ... you estimated my melee bonus at 130 when in fact its at 241 (click the link in the 1st post to see that I actually added screen shots with the original post). I still disagree that its the way you are saying it is because then you should have exactly 250% ... and if it is how you say then smite becomes a completely crap skill as brutal strike has a) more damage (my brutal strike crits for 3.6-4k while smite crits for 2.8k at most) b) shorter cool down (1 second instead of like 5) c) its faster (0.75sec vs 0.9 sec) ...


anyway I would really like to get some dev feedback on this topic though ... we could be going back and forth forever without getting anywhere