Marduk, let me make this clear: you weren't silenced because we decided the mercenaries are right, you were silenced because you were ALL told to STOP ARGUING about it and poisoning the mood in global chat and YOU REFUSED, continuing the argument for at least 30 minutes.
The merc you were initially arguing with "kimmy" or something stopped after Lady_Katy warned them. If they commented afterwards we didn't see it and you did not report them for it. As far as I can tell, jamccor22 (whom you did report for abuse), JardyB10 (who is stirring up trouble here) and Omar (who was silenced by Katy) were not among the mercenaries and were only interested in stirring up trouble.
This silence has nothing to do with whether or not you were justified to kick the mercs and everything to do with how you behaved in global.
The mercs that were on that CK raid was kimmy JO romeo kalgen and rexan.. all 3 of them got kicked by me in the raid because for more than one hour they did no HELP no help at all and i kicked them but kimmy jo was the only who did not recived any kick out.. he left the guild and started to spread out lies in the global chat! and those guys i think fired up all the bad things and this silly talking about us.. and At this moment on global they are still mocking us! why is nobody to calm them and STOP screwing up my guild with lies and bad things.. there is nobody to see how they act in global right now at this moment?? why they keep talking like that and still got no silence?? just login to the game and see the global right now and see what is going on there... when we are in trouble nobody help us... when we need help.. i am the one who is silence.. and when is needed somebody to make them stop spreading lies and bad talk about us.. there is nobody on global th make them stop... why?? they deserve to be silenced as well and i MEAN IT!! i don't have anything with anyone but they continue this stupid chatting about us and they deserve the same punishment like i have when 2 are fighting each other saying opposite things it is wise to .. 1 make them stop bouth of them.. or punish tmem all.. why i was punnished and those guys not?? this is not fair... not at all right at this moment they keep talking lies about us and nobody care like usually.. if i go now on global chat and i make a mistake or i write somethiong bag i imidatly get silenced.. and they talk always bag and spreading lies and make us look bad hour 24 gours and this keep continue and there is nobody to shut their mouth off.. still i am the black sheep and they.. are what they are... this is UNFAIR at all and will be as long as nobody punish them also
I continued to argue because that kimmy JO or whatever his name is CONTINUED at least permanently to mock us!! and in the last i was the one who get silenced.. and he didin/t .. why??? why not him also?? after hours later after i`veve been silenced he keepet saying bad things about us.. why did he not recived the same?? he deserved also.!
If they had ANY RPP, they did help. And their rewards would have been prorated to their participation. You made a judgment call, and now they have made one as well.
You used your power to Boot them, which is your right.
They are using their power to prevent Mercs from helping you in the future, which is theirs.
Everyone got what they wanted, so just relax and come back to the game with a smile on your face when your silence is up. People can do whatever they like, but they can't always make people like what they do.
It is not normal to make in one hour just 200 RPP when i was in such a hurry to finish CK.. they occupied the spots and used i think 4 energy... u call that merc help? well i kick players who only spend just 4 dam energy in an hour.. that is not help.. it is lame! and i hate lamers like kimmy.. that is the bigest lame!
I used to kick the last 3 of them.. i dont tjhink spending 4 energy in an hour is a HELP i call that a lame and a non help.. instead of helping they only did bad to us.. other ppl wanted to help and they occupied our spots and spended only 4 energy in 1 hour.. this is not a HELP is a LAME!
How much and How long is irrelevant.
1) Any player that participates is due the rewards of the raid that are prorated based on their participation.
2) You trumped the giving of the rewards due to booting the player prior to the end of the raid.
3) Your action prevented a Merc from receiving their due rewards, regardless of how small.
This is enough to upset the merc community. Period.
You have not taken responsibility for the above actions and that has lead to the damage of your guilds reputation, not the "lies" of a merc. You are arguing about the amount of help and the length of time involved, but both of those arguements are irrelevant to the situation in which you have landed yourself and your guild. Your guild has every right to support your decision, and you have every right to make the decisions for your guild, but you have to also accept the responsibility and consequences to those actions as a GM.
The Merc community is upset because you have violated their trust in the receiving of rewards when participating in your guild raids. You have to build that trust back, and arguing about irrelevant points in public is NOT going to help you at all. You are the GM. You made the decision. You need to accept the responsibility of it and move on to fix the reputation of your guild with the Merc community, because this argument is not helping.
I wish you luck.
If we need room for a raid, we take the following actions:
1) Send a mail to guild stating that we are making room for the raid, if you get booted, just reapply after the raid.
2) Then we boot our OWN members that are not in the raid and preferably those that don't have the might for the raid (sometimes we even get volunteers to make room), but we NEVER boot a player that has spent ANY energy on the raid, because they are due their rewards and you have no idea what has happened in Real Life that might have called them away from the GAME. And judging their absence is arrogant, because you don't know what happened.
3) Room is available, in a fair way that meets everyones needs.
Jetras' posts sum my feelings (as Acting GM of Goats) very well.
An officer at KOTOR once accidentally booted me mid-raid by mistake. Actually, I told them they could boot one alt and they took out the wrong one. He/she felt bad and apologized immediately. I have been back there many times since because of the way it was handled. At this point, I have no desire to go to the Hunters.
As far as Jardy goes, that post is probably just his unusual sense of humor and should be taken as a joke.
Jetras_of_Eld wrote:
1) Any player that participates is due the rewards of the raid that are prorated based on their participation.
I like Venan's RPP system.
I have seen the following reasons for low RPP:
Taken to a Hospital
Baby crying
Falsely arrested and later cleared of all charges.
Picking up a Spouse, returning early, from a Military Base in the Middle East
Personally I have had low RPP because:
WiFi crash (Raid over when fixed)
Subway Tunnel (Stuck in for 120 minutes)
My dear friend.. if you were in my place you had did the same.. a merc responsability is to spend his energy in a raid m i right or not?? i needed urgent help in that moment so i asked merc help.. that`s why i did.. they 4 of them that i mentioned their name earlier did NOT HELPED.. they did wasted precious time during the raid and kept me in a critical time period.. i decied to boot tehm out for spending only 4 energy durin a 2 hour raid.. they had just 200 RPP .. this not helped me at all.. why to keep 4 spots ocupied just for 4 energy spended in a raid when help was iminent.. i decided to boot them out and make others come and spend energy for a win.. the min RPP in that raid was 2000+ they had only 200 RPP .. they only did bad to us not help.. help was far far away... and they started crying and making us look bad... who is not fair?? me because i kicked them out for having a right to select mercs that really help and they did only occupied the spots and no help recived from them.. they wanted us to fail not to make it.. i did the right decision my friend if they do not want to help then why they did joined? to make 4 energy spend in a 2 hour raid?? this is IMPOSSIBLE.. i am very very very upset because of them.. no help at all and after spread only lies about us and mocking us.. maked us look bad.. who are they anyway?? i did showed them respect .. and what i did recived? 200RPP from them in almost 2 hours?? this is a LAME of what they did... i o9nly did what i had done that our guild win that raid.. they are a fault not me...
hours later after i was silenced they keeped mocking us and make us look bad after the watters were chilled fdown.. why? why to talk of us so bad?? this made me very very angry this is not FAIR.. they should also be silenced like i am.. the admin defended them and punished me for defending the guild.. is this loom to you fair?? excuse me my friend but this is UNFAIR!
They were online all the time but they did not helped.. i checked everytime their status.. says online: Now.. and did no help... they were not OFFLINe or internet crash or things like that.. they simply did not CARED!!
I already told you what I would do in an above post, so please do not speak for me.
You continue to hurt your reputation by dictating the responsibilities of a merc to the merc community. Again, you made an assumption as to the situation of their low rpp, and took action. You are continuing to argue the points that you think are strong, but are still, nonetheless irrelevant. I have made an attempt to help you and to get you to see the situation as an outside viewer, of which I have failed. I wish you no ill will, I was simply attempting to provide some insight to you of your situation, however you obviously do not desire my assistance.
I have never said that your decision was WRONG, this is not a judgment call. I have told you numerous times that you had every right to boot the mercs for whatever reason you see fit. You fail to understand that you have no control over the actions of others, only yourself. The merc community has every right to judge this situation as THEY see fit. You cannot make the judgement for BOTH your guild and the merc community. That is what I'm trying to get you to understand. I am not judging you. You had every right to do what you did, and now its done. Now, its out of your hands, and its up to the merc community to decide on whether on not to participate in your guild raids, based on your actions.
You have argued your point. You have given you reasons, numerously, and you stand by your actions. I just hope that you understand that this situation isn't about WHO is right, its about DOING what is right for everyone involved. You have made your decision and taken your action, now its in the hands of the Merc community.