Book of Heroes

More Build Options for Classes

Hachiman_Defender_of_Oda

ModeratorTue Sep 25, 2012 9:25 am
I want to start by saying that I have 6 toons, and part of the fun in a game is coming up with your own unique build or strategy for your character. That is very challenging in BoH as to the fact that with the limited abilities, there are few powerful builds. I am going to list out each build and please, others help if you have a different build, to where we can show the Devs the different builds to help them see some balancing issues.

War Mage (2 Builds)

Frost Mage - Focuses on Slowing Spells and Ice Spells

Fire Mage - Focuses on Haste and Fire Spells

All WM take a crap load of damage so maybe some spells to help offset that (see below)


Shadow Walker (Really only 1 Build)

Poison SW - Is there any other build that's successful? I'd like to see a speed/dual wield build


Justicar (1 Strong Build, 1 Slightly Weaker Build)

Knight - Focuses on Melee Attacks and Gems (Has War Cry buff that makes it a little stronger, and more multi-attacks)

Paladin - Focuses on Magic Gems and Spirit Attacks (Has a nice one shot punch in Smite, but lacks a Spirit Buff equivelant of War Cry, and only has a single Multi-attack, that's also the weakest)


Some game balancing suggestions:

1) War Mage Suggestions
a. Fire Shield Spell (attackers take damage)
b. Flaming Staff (adds Fire Damage to normal Staff Attack for up to 5 seconds)
c. Ice Shield Spell (reduces up to 20% of damage taken over 5 seconds)
2) Shadow Walker Suggestions: Come up with more abilities for a SW that are not Poison Related and would focus on dual wielding
a. Hurricane Slash (Dual Weapon attacks against all enemies at reduced damage, so 2 attacks against each enemy that have to be blocked separately)
3) Justicar Suggestions:
a. Change Seismic Slash to a Spirit based Attack, or add another Multi-Attack that is Spirit Based
b. Divine Judgement Spell (lowers enemies resistance by a % to Spirit Attacks for 5 seconds)

Others are welcome to add their ideas, we can work on this together, my only request is be part of the discussion, meaning, if you have a different opinion, offer up a solution.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorTue Sep 25, 2012 10:57 am
I beg to differ on your evaluation that the justicar using magic is weaker compared to one using pure or almost pure melee. In lower levels this might be the case but once you reach the point of complete tier 11 gear and majority level 4 gems then things change. I'm not saying it is better but rather an alternative way of playing. I've been comparing notes with some melee justicars and there is basically no difference in the average number of turns we can kill bosses. Another thing mobs can only have so much health so if a certain melee bonus damage can already 1 hit crit kill them why add more to melee when you can add it to magic to have additional spirit based magic attacks.

War cry's 50% physical resistance reduction is just about right IMO and why the need to make divine power only boost magic attacks? It is good in its current form. Justicars also have radiant light as a spirit based multi attack. It is as fast as seismic slash and depending on points in magic can have the same or even bigger damage and is enough to 1 hit kill a 3 creature mob. The main issue I don't like much avoid justicars is that they tend to miss/get blocked a lot more compared to SW and WM.

Hachiman_Defender_of_Oda

ModeratorTue Sep 25, 2012 11:30 am
The reason I suggest to boost War Cry and make Divine power only affect Magic is because right now a Melee Justicar can use both and have a bigger advantage over a Magic based Justicar, with the physical resistance lowered and then the melee boost as well, but I do conceed that if the "Divine Judgement" type spell was included for the magic based justicar then it would be fair to keep the Divine Power for both as well.

I will edit my post on that point.

I still believe that Magic based Justicars are slightly weaker then Melee, not much, but slightly. Due to the number of abilities and buffs that would affect each.

I also base this on my own observation of my 4 Justicars, 2 Melee (1 single handed weapon and 1 2handed) and 2 Magic (1 single handed weapon and 1 2handed). And I'm not talking about a maxed out Justicar with full T11 and T4 Gems. Classes should be balanced as much as possible at each level in the game. When they are maxed out nothing is balanced then, they are just all overpowering to the point that little can stand up against them, this isn't balancing...its overpowering.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorTue Sep 25, 2012 12:29 pm
I'm curious with your justicars. If you have time can you give specifics: melee and might ratings for your 4 justicars and their biggest melee and magic crit damages if you remember them. I will compare figures with you later as I'm at work. Thanks.

Hachiman_Defender_of_Oda

ModeratorTue Sep 25, 2012 3:29 pm
The Problem is that they are mostly at different levels right now, but the 2 Magic Builds are feeling more difficult for the tougher raids.

8158 might Melee Axe and Shield Justicar is criting for 5k with Brutal Strike 3, after DP and WC
3820 might Melee 2handed Axe Justicar is criting for 4k with Brutal Strike 3, after DP and WC
2788 might Magic Sword and Shield Justicar is criting for 1.9k with Smite 3, after DP
1790 might Magic 2handed Sword Justicar is criting for 1.5k with Smite 3, after DP

Really the only difference when you look at all the factors of Crit Power, weapons, and such is that Melee Justicars get the extra 50% physical resistance lowering that the Magic Justicars don't, and then the Melee Justicars have 3 Multi Attacks, Sesimic Slash, Circle of Blades, and Cleave; whereas Magic Justicars have only Radiant Light which is the lowest weapon damage % of the multi-attacks. Hence my suggestion to make Sesmic Slash a spirit based attack.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorTue Sep 25, 2012 8:38 pm
Looking at some of the stats of your 4 justicars it would not be easy to determine which is better between melee and magic as their mights are quite far apart from each other. Even if the mights are similar we could still have a problem if the melee and magic are also far apart from each other. Basically we should be comparing similar figures. My current build as per your description is actually somewhere in the middle of knight and paladin as my melee and magic ratings are almost split 50/50 at 2268 melee and 2282 magic. Bonus damage is the same at 272 and rising to 421 with divine power 3.

I would be comparing the strongest melee attack (brutal strike 160% weapon damage) and the strongest magic attack (smite 250% spirit damage). My highest crit using brutal strike 3 is around 6.5k while the highest for smite 3 is 9.9k. Ideally my magic crit should be about 1.56x (250%/160%) compared to my melee crit. It is only 1.52x (9.9/6.5) so you are correct when you said the melee justicar is slightly (in this case very, very slightly) stronger compared to a magic using justicar. However there is a possibility that brutal strike would miss and the smite damage doesn't have any reduce spirit debuff at that. The damage ratio would definitely be in smite's favor if the Divine Judgement Spell you suggested is implemented. Smite might have a longer attack time but it's dps is 11,000 (9900/0.9 secs) compared to 9285 (6500/0.7 secs) so it's worth the extra 0.2 secs. For my multi attacks I have removed cleave and replaced it with radiant light due to cleave's long attack time. Another reason is that using seismic slash and/or radiant light plus divine power is enough for me to kill a 3 creature mob in Fellmarsh if crit activates. Very rarely do I use circle of blades. I would really be very happy if they take your suggestion of making seismic slash a spirit based attack. I have a lot more supporting data but this post is getting lengthy so I'll end it now. So as I said earlier I do not believe that a magic using justicar would end up 2nd best compared to a melee justicar. It's just a matter of playing style and preference.

P.S. I hope a melee justicar would also post here as I would like to know how powerful their brutal strike crit is. So far the highest melee rating I've heard ingame is around 3600 plus.
I had great success as a melee focused shadow walker.I had no poison attacks except for toxic blade and still killed pretty fast.But now I use an even balance between melee and magic.
Jetras_of_Eld wrote:All WM take a crap load of damage
I'm actually surprised by this. From my experience (one of each class), war mages barely ever get hit. Shadow walkers not much either (still a bit more) and justicars seem to be the ones for which potions were created.

My build is balanced between ice and fire: 2 x fractures, 2 x targeted attack (incinerate, frozen shard), 2 x group attack (flaming pyre, ice storm), inner focus and time void all at level 3 + lvl 1 on icy grasp and I'm fine (I have max haste so no need for hasten anymore). What is your build like when you focus on either ice or fire?

Hachiman_Defender_of_Oda

ModeratorWed Sep 26, 2012 9:26 am
Are you at Fellmarsh yet Romain? And if you are balancing fire and Ice, your not maxing out either?

Natural20 could you give some more infomation on your build?

Cavalier, I love the math in your break down, but what did you do to add in the War Cry effect for the Melee Justicar? And they could make Divine Judgement weaker than War Cry to maintain a balance, it doesn't have to be the same, I just think it has a place.

Honestly I think we shouldn't look at might due to the variables, or even the damage for that matter. All things are equal save for the War Cry bonus honestly. If that offset could be adjusted with Diving Judgement, the magic and melee builds of the Justicar would be balanced perfectly. Agreed?

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorWed Sep 26, 2012 12:43 pm
Jetras_of_Eld wrote:Are you at Fellmarsh yet Romain? And if you are balancing fire and Ice, your not maxing out either?

Natural20 could you give some more infomation on your build?

Cavalier, I love the math in your break down, but what did you do to add in the War Cry effect for the Melee Justicar? And they could make Divine Judgement weaker than War Cry to maintain a balance, it doesn't have to be the same, I just think it has a place.

Honestly I think we shouldn't look at might due to the variables, or even the damage for that matter. All things are equal save for the War Cry bonus honestly. If that offset could be adjusted with Diving Judgement, the magic and melee builds of the Justicar would be balanced perfectly. Agreed?

Hi Jetras I also have war cry because you can consider my build a hybrid between the 2 builds you posted. Right now I consider melee and melee/magic build equal because of the fact that except for the bosses enemy health is not really that much. A typical battle for me including bosses last from 2-6 rounds including divine power which should always be the first move for justicars. I admit that at certain situations a predominately melee justicar would be better but such situation doesn't usually happen for me. An example would be if your crits does not activate and the boss is resistant to magic. If Venan makes mobs tougher by substantially increasing health then a melee justicar would be better due to smite's long cooldown (I think 4 or 5 times that off brutal strike).

Btw a final question when you say magic justicar do you mean a justicar having significantly bigger magic rating vs melee rating? We might be having different interpretation on what magic means in this case.