Among the 3 classes the Justicar is probably the one were players cannot agree on what kind of build to use. I also believe a lot of people don't like playing it opting instead for the spell using Warmage and the fast attacking Shadow Walker. I have always liked melee based characters thus I picked Justicar when Book of Heroes first came out December 2011. Before starting the guide proper I would like to acknowledge Jetras of Eld and BjofCJandBJ as I would be using some of their ideas here.
A little bit of background. My using magic for my Justicar was not intentional but rather due to the fact that Hunter kept on dropping magic gems instead of melee. I wanted to fill up my gem slots as quickly as possible to increase my might and be able to do higher end raids. I wasn't paying much attention to my damage then until I noticed that smite was doing quite significant damage compared to my brutal strike despite having a much higher melee rating. That was until update 1.3.3 when they nerfed smite. Turns out smite was using melee as bonus damage modifier instead of magic. Instead of complaining like what a lot of Justicars did I re-arranged my melee and magic gems until I was 60% melee and 40% magic. My damage using smite was more or less back to pre-1.3.3. I shared the idea in global but a lot of people can't accept it and some even scoffed at it. My experimentation didn't end there and this guide is the result.
I would be borrowing some terms from Jetras. He defined a melee Justicar as a knight and a magic Justicar as a paladin. My build is basically between the two thus the term "hybrid". You can even call it a knight-paladin.
Here are my stats with complete guild favors and some explainations:
Melee 2268 (bonus damage 285) - doesnt need to be exactly the same as magic (as per BJ could be plus/minus 10% bonus damage but I would prefer just 5%).
Magic 2282 (bonus damage 285) - as above.
Crit 2700 (52.21%) - try to get this as high as possible. Max is 55% with guild favor.
Crit Power 3052 (300.00%) - try to get as high as possible. Max is 300%.
Physical Resist 1714 (57.76%) - do not add anything to this until you have maxed crit power. Actually you don't need to add anything here if you like as potions and interrupt runes are aplenty.
Magic Resist 1662 (55.92%) - same as physical resist.
Dodge 456 (24.47%) - a useless stat for now.
Haste 1820 (48.02% ability time modifier) - target at least 43%. People are saying you only need 47.75% with guild favor to attain fastest possible attack speed but at my current haste my base and brutal attack is still off by 0.05 secs compared to my fastest time when my haste is at least 48.20%.
My abilities:
Divine Power 3 - an absolute must have ability for any Justicar regardless of build
Seismic Slash 3 - as above
War Cry 3 - as above
Brutal Strike 3 - strongest melee attack
Wound 3 - a fast attack with dot
Circle of Blades 3 - a group killer with dot
Stunning Blow - useful for setting up brutal strike or smite. Can also be used to kill mob leftovers.
Smite 3 - strongest magic attack and cannot be avoided.
Radiant Light 3 - as strong and as fast as seismic slash and also cannot be avoided. Very useful for high dodge mobs.
Cleave - I removed this due to it's long attack time and used radiant light instead.
Stonewall - not really that useful as you can use potions.
Heroic Will - I don't use this as very rarely do I require to use my attack sequence twice to kill mobs or bosses.
I am recommending a player to be at least level 22 if they want to try this build using all the above mentioned abilities except either brutal strike or wound. You can use the basic attack instead. Actually might also be possible for a level 21 by further removing stunning blow but remember lower level Justicars tend to get hit a lot especially if your haste is not yet optimal. It is not going to be easy at the lower levels due to lower damage and inferior gear but believe me you are not going to regret it once your might reaches 5 digits. Also it would only cost 1 gs to try this build and another 1 gs to return to your previous melee build if you don't find it to satisfaction.
Following are a couple of my posts on Jetras' "more build options for classes":
I would be comparing the strongest melee attack (brutal strike 160% weapon damage) and the strongest magic attack (smite 250% spirit damage). My highest crit using brutal strike 3 is around 6.5k while the highest for smite 3 is 9.9k. Ideally my magic crit should be about 1.56x (250%/160%) compared to my melee crit. It is only 1.52x (9.9/6.5) so you are correct when you said the melee justicar is slightly (in this case very, very slightly) stronger compared to a magic using justicar. However there is a possibility that brutal strike would miss and the smite damage doesn't have any reduce spirit debuff at that. The damage ratio would definitely be in smite's favor if the Divine Judgement Spell you suggested is implemented. Smite might have a longer attack time but it's dps is 11,000 (9900/0.9 secs) compared to 9285 (6500/0.7 secs) so it's worth the extra 0.2 secs. For my multi attacks I have removed cleave and replaced it with radiant light due to cleave's long attack time. Another reason is that using seismic slash and/or radiant light plus divine power is enough for me to kill a 3 creature mob in Fellmarsh if crit activates. Very rarely do I use circle of blades. I would really be very happy if they take your suggestion of making seismic slash a spirit based attack. I have a lot more supporting data but this post is getting lengthy so I'll end it now. So as I said earlier I do not believe that a magic using justicar would end up 2nd best compared to a melee justicar. It's just a matter of playing style and preference.
Hi Jetras I also have war cry because you can consider my build a hybrid between the 2 builds you posted. Right now I consider melee and melee/magic build equal because of the fact that except for the bosses enemy health is not really that much. A typical battle for me including bosses last from 2-6 rounds including divine power which should always be the first move for justicars. I admit that at certain situations a predominately melee justicar would be better but such situation doesn't usually happen for me. An example would be if your crits does not activate and the boss is resistant to magic. If Venan makes mobs tougher by substantially increasing health then a melee justicar would be better due to smite's long cooldown (I think 4 or 5 times that off brutal strike).
That about covers everything. Comments and suggestions are very much welcome but no flaming please as this is not a "my stick is bigger than your stick" thread.
Regards
Bojun
Celestial Beings
A little bit of background. My using magic for my Justicar was not intentional but rather due to the fact that Hunter kept on dropping magic gems instead of melee. I wanted to fill up my gem slots as quickly as possible to increase my might and be able to do higher end raids. I wasn't paying much attention to my damage then until I noticed that smite was doing quite significant damage compared to my brutal strike despite having a much higher melee rating. That was until update 1.3.3 when they nerfed smite. Turns out smite was using melee as bonus damage modifier instead of magic. Instead of complaining like what a lot of Justicars did I re-arranged my melee and magic gems until I was 60% melee and 40% magic. My damage using smite was more or less back to pre-1.3.3. I shared the idea in global but a lot of people can't accept it and some even scoffed at it. My experimentation didn't end there and this guide is the result.
I would be borrowing some terms from Jetras. He defined a melee Justicar as a knight and a magic Justicar as a paladin. My build is basically between the two thus the term "hybrid". You can even call it a knight-paladin.
Here are my stats with complete guild favors and some explainations:
Melee 2268 (bonus damage 285) - doesnt need to be exactly the same as magic (as per BJ could be plus/minus 10% bonus damage but I would prefer just 5%).
Magic 2282 (bonus damage 285) - as above.
Crit 2700 (52.21%) - try to get this as high as possible. Max is 55% with guild favor.
Crit Power 3052 (300.00%) - try to get as high as possible. Max is 300%.
Physical Resist 1714 (57.76%) - do not add anything to this until you have maxed crit power. Actually you don't need to add anything here if you like as potions and interrupt runes are aplenty.
Magic Resist 1662 (55.92%) - same as physical resist.
Dodge 456 (24.47%) - a useless stat for now.
Haste 1820 (48.02% ability time modifier) - target at least 43%. People are saying you only need 47.75% with guild favor to attain fastest possible attack speed but at my current haste my base and brutal attack is still off by 0.05 secs compared to my fastest time when my haste is at least 48.20%.
My abilities:
Divine Power 3 - an absolute must have ability for any Justicar regardless of build
Seismic Slash 3 - as above
War Cry 3 - as above
Brutal Strike 3 - strongest melee attack
Wound 3 - a fast attack with dot
Circle of Blades 3 - a group killer with dot
Stunning Blow - useful for setting up brutal strike or smite. Can also be used to kill mob leftovers.
Smite 3 - strongest magic attack and cannot be avoided.
Radiant Light 3 - as strong and as fast as seismic slash and also cannot be avoided. Very useful for high dodge mobs.
Cleave - I removed this due to it's long attack time and used radiant light instead.
Stonewall - not really that useful as you can use potions.
Heroic Will - I don't use this as very rarely do I require to use my attack sequence twice to kill mobs or bosses.
I am recommending a player to be at least level 22 if they want to try this build using all the above mentioned abilities except either brutal strike or wound. You can use the basic attack instead. Actually might also be possible for a level 21 by further removing stunning blow but remember lower level Justicars tend to get hit a lot especially if your haste is not yet optimal. It is not going to be easy at the lower levels due to lower damage and inferior gear but believe me you are not going to regret it once your might reaches 5 digits. Also it would only cost 1 gs to try this build and another 1 gs to return to your previous melee build if you don't find it to satisfaction.
Following are a couple of my posts on Jetras' "more build options for classes":
I would be comparing the strongest melee attack (brutal strike 160% weapon damage) and the strongest magic attack (smite 250% spirit damage). My highest crit using brutal strike 3 is around 6.5k while the highest for smite 3 is 9.9k. Ideally my magic crit should be about 1.56x (250%/160%) compared to my melee crit. It is only 1.52x (9.9/6.5) so you are correct when you said the melee justicar is slightly (in this case very, very slightly) stronger compared to a magic using justicar. However there is a possibility that brutal strike would miss and the smite damage doesn't have any reduce spirit debuff at that. The damage ratio would definitely be in smite's favor if the Divine Judgement Spell you suggested is implemented. Smite might have a longer attack time but it's dps is 11,000 (9900/0.9 secs) compared to 9285 (6500/0.7 secs) so it's worth the extra 0.2 secs. For my multi attacks I have removed cleave and replaced it with radiant light due to cleave's long attack time. Another reason is that using seismic slash and/or radiant light plus divine power is enough for me to kill a 3 creature mob in Fellmarsh if crit activates. Very rarely do I use circle of blades. I would really be very happy if they take your suggestion of making seismic slash a spirit based attack. I have a lot more supporting data but this post is getting lengthy so I'll end it now. So as I said earlier I do not believe that a magic using justicar would end up 2nd best compared to a melee justicar. It's just a matter of playing style and preference.
Hi Jetras I also have war cry because you can consider my build a hybrid between the 2 builds you posted. Right now I consider melee and melee/magic build equal because of the fact that except for the bosses enemy health is not really that much. A typical battle for me including bosses last from 2-6 rounds including divine power which should always be the first move for justicars. I admit that at certain situations a predominately melee justicar would be better but such situation doesn't usually happen for me. An example would be if your crits does not activate and the boss is resistant to magic. If Venan makes mobs tougher by substantially increasing health then a melee justicar would be better due to smite's long cooldown (I think 4 or 5 times that off brutal strike).
That about covers everything. Comments and suggestions are very much welcome but no flaming please as this is not a "my stick is bigger than your stick" thread.
Regards
Bojun
Celestial Beings