An Open Letter to TCG_xAloysius and the rest of the leadership of The Crimson Guards:
Recently you sent an unsolicited invitation via in-game mail to one of our members to join your guild permanently, which was subsequently forwarded to me. On behalf of our Wheel of Time Alliance (consisting of Band of the Red Hand, The Wolfhead Banner, and The Younglings), I'd like to thank you for giving us an opportunity to strengthen our guilds. I took the liberty of forwarding your message to all members of the Band and the Banner. Rest assured your offer was seen by almost 120 toons- what more could you ask?!! Of course, I did decide that it was appropriate to suggest a perspective on the situation. The text of both my message and yours is included below. Best of luck poaching our members now.
Sincerely,
Staples
GM, Band of the Red Hand
From: Staples
To: Band of the Red Hand / The Wolfhead Banner
Hello all.
There's a matter I'd like to bring to everyone's attention. As we go on in this game, you may notice guilds around us in the Rankings struggling to retain membership. To replace losses, some of them might choose to pursue methods that are less than reputable. Specifically you should see the FWD'ed mail below, where the second-in-command of TCG contacted one of our members (not me) unsolicited.
First I want to say that we wholly condemn this practice. It is not easy to build and sustain a guild and, out of respect for other guilds, we have tried very hard to not target current members of other guilds as individuals while recruiting in Global Chat.
Second I want to make sure you all know that you are not caged here. If our guilds are progressing too slowly and you want to permanently leave to go raid two bosses higher somewhere else, you should. There is nothing unhealthier for all parties than trying to tie down someone who wants to leave. (So our attitude is, "if you love something, let it go free.")
But I think there is more to this game than raiding bigger bosses; I would say our three guilds have achieved that "more" in spades; I hope you are all here because you agree; and I thank you all for making it possible. [Darkhorse / GaretJax] put it so well in a message to me a couple weeks ago that I repeat his words here:
"As much as I want to be [running higher raids] the reality is we are just trying to get cooler clothing for our characters and put that way it seems less important than trying to maintain the culture/friendships we have built up."
Carai an Caldazar. Carai an Ellisande.
Peace,
Staples
From: TCG_xAloysius
To: [member]
Hello there! I am writing to you to find out if you like to become a permanent guild member of our guild, The Crimson Guards. We are a number 2 guild in this game with our players mainly in Singapore, Malaysia, American and Canada. Our raid schedule based on EST is 8pm, 12.30am, 5am & 10am. If you are keen, I will like to find out what's your friend code as well as nationality. Thanks a lot!
Aloysius
Recently you sent an unsolicited invitation via in-game mail to one of our members to join your guild permanently, which was subsequently forwarded to me. On behalf of our Wheel of Time Alliance (consisting of Band of the Red Hand, The Wolfhead Banner, and The Younglings), I'd like to thank you for giving us an opportunity to strengthen our guilds. I took the liberty of forwarding your message to all members of the Band and the Banner. Rest assured your offer was seen by almost 120 toons- what more could you ask?!! Of course, I did decide that it was appropriate to suggest a perspective on the situation. The text of both my message and yours is included below. Best of luck poaching our members now.
Sincerely,
Staples
GM, Band of the Red Hand
From: Staples
To: Band of the Red Hand / The Wolfhead Banner
Hello all.
There's a matter I'd like to bring to everyone's attention. As we go on in this game, you may notice guilds around us in the Rankings struggling to retain membership. To replace losses, some of them might choose to pursue methods that are less than reputable. Specifically you should see the FWD'ed mail below, where the second-in-command of TCG contacted one of our members (not me) unsolicited.
First I want to say that we wholly condemn this practice. It is not easy to build and sustain a guild and, out of respect for other guilds, we have tried very hard to not target current members of other guilds as individuals while recruiting in Global Chat.
Second I want to make sure you all know that you are not caged here. If our guilds are progressing too slowly and you want to permanently leave to go raid two bosses higher somewhere else, you should. There is nothing unhealthier for all parties than trying to tie down someone who wants to leave. (So our attitude is, "if you love something, let it go free.")
But I think there is more to this game than raiding bigger bosses; I would say our three guilds have achieved that "more" in spades; I hope you are all here because you agree; and I thank you all for making it possible. [Darkhorse / GaretJax] put it so well in a message to me a couple weeks ago that I repeat his words here:
"As much as I want to be [running higher raids] the reality is we are just trying to get cooler clothing for our characters and put that way it seems less important than trying to maintain the culture/friendships we have built up."
Carai an Caldazar. Carai an Ellisande.
Peace,
Staples
From: TCG_xAloysius
To: [member]
Hello there! I am writing to you to find out if you like to become a permanent guild member of our guild, The Crimson Guards. We are a number 2 guild in this game with our players mainly in Singapore, Malaysia, American and Canada. Our raid schedule based on EST is 8pm, 12.30am, 5am & 10am. If you are keen, I will like to find out what's your friend code as well as nationality. Thanks a lot!
Aloysius