Book of Heroes

Poaching Members (Attn: TCG)

An Open Letter to TCG_xAloysius and the rest of the leadership of The Crimson Guards:

Recently you sent an unsolicited invitation via in-game mail to one of our members to join your guild permanently, which was subsequently forwarded to me. On behalf of our Wheel of Time Alliance (consisting of Band of the Red Hand, The Wolfhead Banner, and The Younglings), I'd like to thank you for giving us an opportunity to strengthen our guilds. I took the liberty of forwarding your message to all members of the Band and the Banner. Rest assured your offer was seen by almost 120 toons- what more could you ask?!! Of course, I did decide that it was appropriate to suggest a perspective on the situation. The text of both my message and yours is included below. Best of luck poaching our members now.

Sincerely,
Staples
GM, Band of the Red Hand



From: Staples
To: Band of the Red Hand / The Wolfhead Banner

Hello all. :)

There's a matter I'd like to bring to everyone's attention. As we go on in this game, you may notice guilds around us in the Rankings struggling to retain membership. To replace losses, some of them might choose to pursue methods that are less than reputable. Specifically you should see the FWD'ed mail below, where the second-in-command of TCG contacted one of our members (not me) unsolicited.

First I want to say that we wholly condemn this practice. It is not easy to build and sustain a guild and, out of respect for other guilds, we have tried very hard to not target current members of other guilds as individuals while recruiting in Global Chat.

Second I want to make sure you all know that you are not caged here. If our guilds are progressing too slowly and you want to permanently leave to go raid two bosses higher somewhere else, you should. There is nothing unhealthier for all parties than trying to tie down someone who wants to leave. (So our attitude is, "if you love something, let it go free.")

But I think there is more to this game than raiding bigger bosses; I would say our three guilds have achieved that "more" in spades; I hope you are all here because you agree; and I thank you all for making it possible. [Darkhorse / GaretJax] put it so well in a message to me a couple weeks ago that I repeat his words here:

"As much as I want to be [running higher raids] the reality is we are just trying to get cooler clothing for our characters and put that way it seems less important than trying to maintain the culture/friendships we have built up."

Carai an Caldazar. Carai an Ellisande.

Peace,
Staples



From: TCG_xAloysius
To: [member]

Hello there! I am writing to you to find out if you like to become a permanent guild member of our guild, The Crimson Guards. We are a number 2 guild in this game with our players mainly in Singapore, Malaysia, American and Canada. Our raid schedule based on EST is 8pm, 12.30am, 5am & 10am. If you are keen, I will like to find out what's your friend code as well as nationality. Thanks a lot!

Aloysius
Lol Aloy! You got condemned for inviting ppl nicely.... That's why i told you never be too nice to ppl or you'll get misunderstood :-D
Aloy poaching?!?!?! LoL!! Staples, you just jumped off a cliff without knowing what's below and unfortunetly it is large steel spikes.
Aloy and TCG have been nothing but honorable and helpful to those around them. You went off half cocked without even asking Aloy about the email or his intentions behind it. You speak of peace yet you bash an honorble player while attempting to make the whole guild look bad. Shame on your guild(s) instead.
TCG once emptied out their guild to help another guild finish a tough raid. Did they poach? No. Did they mention joining TCG in whisper or guild chat? No. They all just said thank you for KV glad we could help and they went back to their guild. I ask you whoever as done that for a rival guild without recieving a payment in return?!?! That's right no one. I suggest you appologize and next time have a chat about the incident before bashing them without having all the facts.

JediKnight :)

japster

ModeratorSat Oct 20, 2012 6:41 am
This is an exact reproduction of TCG's reply to your allegations in our recruitment thread. Since you chose to make a brand new thread as well, the same reply shall follow.

----------------------------------------------------------------
Dear Staples,

I think this has been a misunderstanding from the start and I regret you chose such a confrontational method to approach the issue.

TCG takes a serious stand against such allegations, as we do not endorse poaching (unsolicited offers to players with guilds).

The officers of TCG have conducted a thorough investigation of the matter with Aloysius, and based on whatever evidence we can muster, this is our narration of the events.

----------------------------------------------------------------
1. Aloysius was in the midst of contacting ex-Claymore members 2 days ago, after their unfortunate disbanding.
2. At the same time, he decided to check the active leader boards to seek for free agents (GUILDLESS players).
3. He sent his mass mails to ex-Claymore members who were in guilds, or GUILDLESS members on the leader board.

It is most likely that either,

1. The particular member had been guildless (perhaps due to mercenary work) at that point in time when Aloy checked the leader boards, and thus it was a fair letter to send.

OR

2. It was a genuine mistake by Aloysius, and he could have accidentally mailed a particular member who was actually in a guild by mistake. We do not rule this possibility out and Aloysius has confirmed with us that he was mass mailing and could have made an error.
----------------------------------------------------------------

We want to assure you that TCG does not have any specific agenda regarding you, your guild, your alliance, or its particular members. We do not endorse poaching people as well. Regardless, we sincerely apologize for any inconvenience, personal and mass distress caused to that particular member, you, your guild, and the alliance, due to the mail.

If you could graciously provide us with the name/Venan ID of the member who received the mail from Aloysius, it would further assist us in investigations to fully understand the events. His identity would help verify statistics such as the player's might (whether he even qualifies for TCG) and activity (whether he mercs around frequently).

TCG will consider the matter resolved and that Aloysius did not poach any persons on purpose if you would agree with our response. All-in-all, we look forward to amicable relationships with all players and guilds in BoH, and hope never to grow animosity with any player/s.
The member is question was me. I replied to TCG_xAloysius the below:

******************
you may fwd my message to your guild or the officers who are relevant to the misunderstanding.

hello.

I am the member of band of the red hand that you sent your recruitment email to. I am also the gm of our starter guild, the younglings.

I understand that your guild is trying to resolve the current misunderstanding between our guilds. I appreciate that and hope to help clarify.

of the three scenarios that your guild presented as possible scenarios for the recruitment email: the possibilities are resolved below.

I have never been a member of claymore.

I have never been a merc. and therefore would not have been guild-less at any point since joining the band of the red hand.

I am on the leaderboard, with a might of over 10k. so I can assume that you made a mistake when you were mass emailing "eligible" candidates from there.

so I accept that this was a mistake and hope that I was the only one. you can see how emailing someone who has never interacted with your guild or shown any interest in global or otherwise of leaving their current guild can be interpreted as "poaching."

I would even say that emailing people who have never interacted with your guild (mercs or not) to be spamming but that is a distinction for your guild to determine.

regardless. I wish you and your guild the best of luck. I hope you enjoy your guild and the game as much as I do mine.

as far as I am concerned, I find the issue resolved as an honest mistake.

best of luck,
Theary

japster

ModeratorSun Oct 21, 2012 6:00 am
Thank you Theary for your understanding. All the best in your future BoH endeavors! We're grateful for your prompt reply and good faith in TCG's honest mistake.
Cheese and Rice, people! An invite is an invite! Be flattered you were asked! If you go picking a fight every time someone looks at your girl you'll end up looking like a horses arse.
Japster, thank you for your response on behalf of TCG. Before my own follow-up, I wanted to give Theary a chance to answer your questions herself. Sorry for the delay (also the serve problem today).
TCG_japster wrote:We do not endorse poaching people as well. Regardless, we sincerely apologize for any inconvenience, personal and mass distress caused to that particular member, you, your guild, and the alliance, due to the mail.

We sincerely appreciate this statement, and accept that the mail was an honest mistake. In fact, you haven't even mentioned the best evidence in support of this explanation- no one else has come forward here with the same experience.

Band of the Red Hand in general, and I personally, consider the matter closed. Good luck to TCG. If you think we should take further steps to repair trust between the guilds, maybe we can discuss it privately.

Peace,
Staples
Chon wrote:Cheese and Rice, people! An invite is an invite! Be flattered you were asked! If you go picking a fight every time someone looks at your girl you'll end up looking like a horses arse.

Pork chops and applesauce chon! :)

Seriously though (and this should not be taken as an accusation on tcg at all as this is probably off thread topic, sorry gang)....

I personally do not want my inbox to look like the stream of recruit messages that have taken over global (it's why I haven't even looked at global chat in months).

And to address your point specifically, I don't feel that I should be flattered for unwanted solicitations. I'm a big proponent of the "opt in" approach to things in my inbox.

I get enough of those in my real life emails... But at least my real life inbox come with built in spam filters... Know what I mean?

If I should be flattered, then I should probably write a letter of thanks to that kind Nigerian man who invited me to give him my bank account so that he could deposit obscene amounts of money for us to share... It was after all an invitation to extreme wealth!

Furthermore....

I fully support my GM. If unsolicited emails become a tactic that other guilds use to target high level players... Then it dulls the point of belonging to a guild and is disrespectful to the work of other officers and veterans who try and create pockets of community, collegiality and loyalty based camaraderie in an otherwise low sociability game.

You have to admit that these individuals (regardless of the guild) often devote a lot of personal time and effort to building and sustaining such refuges for those of us who enjoy this aspect of the game... And how easily it is to take it somewhat personally when their efforts are threatened...

Whether or not you agree with "the principle." You should be able to see the perspective enough to perhaps... Be less dismissive of others. A mocking aside from the peanut gallery... Is still just an aside. And I'd venture to say... Wholly unhelpful to the discussion/issue.

Perhaps Staples actions were preemptive. Perhaps this could've been handled privately... But he has every right to act on, what he believes to be in the best interest of his guild's members.

personally, i think it's for the good of the game that declarations of where one stands in these matters get addressed openly. You know what happens behind closed doors? Right, I don't either. :)

My two cents. And the last of my pennies devoted to this topic in the forums.

japster

ModeratorTue Oct 23, 2012 9:02 am
Staples wrote:

We sincerely appreciate this statement, and accept that the mail was an honest mistake. In fact, you haven't even mentioned the best evidence in support of this explanation- no one else has come forward here with the same experience.

Band of the Red Hand in general, and I personally, consider the matter closed. Good luck to TCG. If you think we should take further steps to repair trust between the guilds, maybe we can discuss it privately.

Peace,
Staples

The evidence comes from Aloysius' narration and interrogation. As Venan do not keep sent mails, there is no way to prove besides believing in his words. We did not find Aloysius' explanation to be unreasonable, and clearly neither have you nor Theary. That should at least be satisfactory to put the matter to rest.

Also the fact that no one else has come forward here with the same experience may very well be strong indication that this was the first-time such a mistake had occurred. I see that as even stronger reason to believe in Aloysius' and TCG's integrity.

Regardless, we are glad it is resolved. Peace =)