Book of Heroes

Failed Raid or Consolation Prizes(P1-2)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Oct 26, 2012 11:05 am
Subject:
Failed Raid or Consolation Prizes(Posts 1-2 )

Guilds work hard to finish a Raid, often burning all their Gold Shields as the Raid Timer runs out. Consolation Prizes would help repay some of this currency expenditure.

Mercs will often join a Guild to help a failing Raid. Consolation Prizes would help repay this altruistic effort.

Despite Gold Shields and Mercs, Raids fail. Currently, Venan only awards Guild XP, Prestige, Power, and Valor for completed Raids. But Book of Heroes is a casual/ mobile MMO and even two hours can be a hard commitment for some players. Consolation Prizes would help take the sting out of failing a Raid.

When the Raid Timer reaches its Last 25%, Consolation Prizes would kick in. Ex: In a 120 minute Raid, the Last 30 minutes would have Consolation Prizes.

Consolation Prizes:
A) Triple Silver= Award Triple (*3) Silver Coin Rewards for each completed Encounter. Just like the Blessing of Fortune, this prize would be announced when the loot drop was claimed. Announcement ex: “1,200 Silver Coin (+800 Bonus Silver Coin)”. This extra Silver Coin could be used to upgrade Tier Items and Gems, Unlock Gem Slots, buy Cleanse/ Healing Potions, buy Minor Runes, buy Alchemist Lockbox.

B) Rune Upgrade= Replace Minor Rune Drops with same frequency Major Rune Drops. Just like the Blessing of Fortune, this prize would be announced when the loot drop was claimed. Announcement ex: “Major Blight Rune (Bonus Upgrade from Minor)”. These Major Runes would help the Guild members and Mercs to complete the next failing Raid.

By limiting Consolation Prizes to Encounters in the last 25% of the Raid Timer, as the Guild gets more powerful, and runs the Raid faster, it would stop getting Consolation Prizes.

Guilds could deliberately wait until the last 25% to get Consolation Prizes, but they run several risks. Too few Kills Per Minute (KPM), Real World interruptions, server lag, server disconnect, loss of Internet connection, etc. Any of these could cause greedy Guilds to lose their Valor Rewards.

Fixed Time Option
Instead of the Raid Timer’s last 25%, it could be fixed at the last 30 minutes of the Raid.

Targeted Rune Option
Some Major Runes are better for different Raid Phases. In this version of Consolation Prizes, only the best individual Major Rune would have a chance of dropping.
If the best Rune for Phase 2 of “TestRaid” is a Major Blight Rune, then the only Consolation Prize that could drop would be Major Blight Rune and Triple Silver. While Phase 3 would only drop Consolation Prize Major Fire Rune and Triple Silver.
Ex: 120 minute “TestRaid” is in Phase 2, and the last 30 minutes, Major Blight Runes (upgraded from minor runes) would have a chance of dropping along with Triple Silver Coins. With 5 minutes left, Phase 3 starts. During Phase 3, Major Fire Runes would have a chance to drop, along with Triple Silver Coins.
Targeted Rewards would help Guild members the next time they ran the same Raid since any Major Runes dropped, would be the best for the problem Phase of the Raid.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Oct 26, 2012 11:05 am
As the Raid Timer starts to run down, one tactic is to stop using defenses (ex: Ensare 1) and just use Runes and attack. The player is trusting in their supply of Health Potions to see them to the end of the Raid. Conditional Guild Favors would reflect this "Hurry Up and Die Monster" mentality as the Raid draws to a close. Temporarily rewarding the Guild that keeps trying to finish the Raid even in the face of adversity.

During the last 45 minutes, Conditional Guild Favors would kick in:

Last 45 minutes Max Health
Last 40 minutes Physical Resist + above
Last 35 minutes Magic Resist + above
Last 30 minutes Dodge + above

Last 25 minutes Magic Bonus Damage + above
Last 20 minutes Melee Bonus Damage + above
Last 15 minutes Haste + above
Last 10 minutes Crit Power + above
Last 5 minutes Crit + above (basically all)

Research Note: This is a slight alteration to the order the Guild Favors are earned.

These Conditional Guild Favors would be +5% just like normal Guild Favors. If the Guild already had the normal version, the total would be +10%.

Ex: A Guild has Favors Max Health through Melee Bonus Damage, for the first 75 minutes of Attack at Dawn, these are the only Favors they have. During the last 20 minutes they could have +10% for Max Health through Melee Bonus Damage. During the last 5 minutes they would also have +5% for Haste through Crit.

Ex: A Guild has no Favors, for the first 195 minutes of Wrath of the Overseer, they have no favors. During the last 45 minutes they would have +5% for Max Health. During the last 5 minutes of the Raid, the Guild would have +5% for all Conditional Guild Favors.
I would not encourage a system that would encourage players to delay finishing a raid, seems counter to the spirit of a raid... which is to vanquish your foe as quickly and decisively as possible. I like that guild power rewards quicker raids.

I also understand why Venan might not want to give consolation prizes to failed raids, as the sense of all or nothing urgency can stimulate the spending of gold shields like nothing else, and therefore the purchasing to replenishing supplies. While I would love to see pro-rated valor given for failed attempts, I'm not expecting any such concession.

The idea of increased favors in crunch time is interesting, but could be abused... start a Cursed Keep raid, Vallus raid, and War of Fellmarsh raid at the same time, with only the intent to finish the War of Fellmarsh. As the other raids near their end, increased favors during much of the raid. It would be a logistical nightmare to conditionally award favors depending on which raid the character is in.