Book of Heroes

Ideas

Ability to transfer items/money between your different heros. Also an exchange feature in the tavern to trade silver for shields.
We talked a lot about transferring currency, but because of the way we have things structured it would be very easy to cheat that system. Also all of the time and resources it would take to make it work well would not be worth the small gain in functionality.

As far as an exchange- we don't have one planned, since it will cause problems with our economy, but we added the Silver Lockbox to give people a chance at winning Gold when spending Silver.

Thanks for the suggestions, sorry we can't make them a reality right now. Let us know if you have any more!
I agree with original post. I had purchased some gold, intending to transfer to a new character after the multi-player update. Now that gold is stranded. Whether the gold or silver is purchased or won, it should be ours to transfer as we please. Calling such transfers cheating is ridiculous. But stranding real money is no laughing matter. The game owners are against allowing money transfer, so Please post in favor of gold (and silver) transfers.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Apr 6, 2012 5:46 am
Major Dad wrote:
Calling such transfers cheating is ridiculous.

The response was easy to cheat and time consuming to cheat proof for little gain.

Two biggest problems:
Balancing players with 10 million plus silver versus players who just joined. I had millions of silver when my wife joined and could have bought her anything since there is no limit on number of characters. Instead she's started her own account, then bought Deathwing and Phoenix armor bundle which are balanced for Level 1 characters.

You can also create and delete characters at will. Any time you create a character, and your account has ten friends, you get 26 free gold shields immediately. 10 of which are for your first blessing and starting armor bundle. level 1- 5 can be completed in a few hours since they are basically an in game tutorial, earning another 10 gold. It continues from there. This is also why it is difficult to balance selling items you bought for gold shields. Venan currently solves that with silver pieces for any item Majerio's Shop buys from you.

For $10 USD you can get 120 gold shields for a 77 gold shield rare named armor bundle Level 1-20(X). Through Feats you can double this to 241 gold shields and buy an Epic ancestral 11-20(X) weapon for 120 gold shields, or anything else you want to spend the remaining 164 gold shields. After you pay Venan $10 USD, you can play the game for years and never pay another $0.01 USD

Lord_Venan

Site AdminFri Apr 6, 2012 8:56 am
Major Dad wrote:I agree with original post. I had purchased some gold, intending to transfer to a new character after the multi-player update. Now that gold is stranded. Whether the gold or silver is purchased or won, it should be ours to transfer as we please. Calling such transfers cheating is ridiculous. But stranding real money is no laughing matter. The game owners are against allowing money transfer, so Please post in favor of gold (and silver) transfers.

Hi Major,

We didn't say it was cheating, we said it was "easy to cheat the system." The way the game is set up currently, it's very easy to get gold shields when starting a new character. Cheating the system would be easily accomplished by just creating new characters, transferring their free shields to their main character, and then deleting them. This would allow players an infinite amount of money.

That being said, it's certainly a valid request and something we debated internally when implementing multiple character slots. At that time, we did not see any easy solutions to the problem which is why it's not supported. It is something we'll be looking at in the future though.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Apr 6, 2012 5:17 pm
Lord Venan wrote:
That being said, it's certainly a valid request and something we debated internally when implementing multiple character slots. At that time, we did not see any easy solutions to the problem which is why it's not supported. It is something we'll be looking at in the future though.

Hi,

I do not see any easy solutions, but I did have some brain storms:

Brainstorm Note: This assumes the usual controls in place, such as a character being able to use an item. If the two characters involved are the same class, then any item can be gifted/ traded/ sold. If two characters are different classes than only items useable by both can be gifted/ traded/ sold.

Item Mentor
First, choose a lower level character as your Heir and send a “Mentor Offer”. If they accept, you become their Mentor. They must be at least 3 levels lower than you.
Every time you find an item that fits an item slot, like a Ring, if it is your level -1 or higher, you keep it. If it is your level -2 or lower, your Heir gets it. This prevents you from purchasing items for your Heir, since you cannot buy items your level -2. This idea may, or may not, work with the new item system.

Chaining Item Mentors
Allows an Heir to be a Mentor. To a maximum of 7 characters (Level= 20, 17, 14, 11, 8, 5, 2).

Sole Item Mentor.
If you are an Heir, you cannot be a Mentor.

Sole Silver Mentor
First, choose a lower level character as your Heir and send a “Mentor Offer”. If they accept, you become their Mentor. They must be at least 3 levels lower than you.
Every time you earn 5 silver pieces, you keep 4 and they get 1. This also works well with Silver lock box. If you are an Heir, you cannot be a Mentor.

Going Solo
At anytime, a Mentor or a Heir can cancel this relationship and become a solo adventurer.

Patron
Any character possessing the Amulet of Ironhaven is considered Famous and can give silver pieces to another character. Any character defeating the Ice Lord Vallus becomes a Knight and can give gold shields to another character. Any character completing 80 daily quests becomes a Glenfort Advisor and can give Hero Tokens to another character. Any character possessing the Amulet of Ironhaven, defeating Ice Lord Vallus and completing 80 daily quests becomes a Famous Knight Advisor of Glenfort and can give items to another character. The logic being: If you can give silver pieces, gold shields and Hero Tokens to another character, they could buy any item.

Merchant
Any character possessing 1 million silver pieces, or more, can sell any item to another character for the same price Majerio’s shop would. If your silver pieces drop below 1 million, you cease to be a merchant until you get your silver pieces at 1 million again.

Merchant Patron
Combines Patron and Merchant ideas.
All hail the Famous Merchant Knight Advisor of Glenfort. This brainstorm is starting to sound like a round of Munchkin (from Steve Jackson Games).

Hero Token Transfer Fee Ratio
You could transfer X gold shields or Y silver pieces per Hero Token you spent on the transfer.

Bank Drafts
Guild Characters could get a Bank Draft every time they:
A) Completed a Daily Quest
B) Defeated a Boss Monster

A Bank Draft could be used (sort of like a modern check) and 1 gold shield or X silver pieces could be transferred to a fellow Guild Member. If an item was worth Y gold shields or Y = silver piece worth / X, then Y Bank Drafts could be used to transfer an item.

Zero Sum Transfer
Guild characters could trade items of equal value.
My Shadow Walker could click on an item and click “Offer in Trade” then select My War Mage. My War Mage would select an item worth the same value and click “Tender Offered”. If he did not have an item close in value, he would have to buy or find an item. My Shadow Walker would then accept or decline the “Tender Offered”. The items would be swapped if both parties clicked “Trade Accepted”.
This idea may, or may not, work with the new item system.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Jul 21, 2012 7:12 pm
Sole XP Mentor
First, choose a lower level character as your Heir and send a “Mentor Offer”. If they accept, you become their Mentor. They must be at least 3 levels lower than you.
Every time you earn 4 experience pointed, you keep 3 and they get 1. If you are an Heir, you cannot be a Mentor.

Level 25 Mentor
Same as above, but when you reach Level 25, for each 4 experience points earned, you get 0 (already max level) and Heir gets 1 XP.

Going Solo
At anytime, a Mentor or a Heir can cancel this relationship and become a solo adventurer.
As I understand it, gems at the same level can sell at Majerio's for different amounts, depending on how they were acquired. This is because those gems are really two (or whatever number) different things on the back end that have the same presentation on the front end.

I'm not sure if this is the best idea, but it strikes me that Gold Shields could work the same way. Shields acquired through quests, drops, item sales, and lockboxes would continue to be non-transferable. Shields acquired by spending cash would be transferable among characters that are managed by the same player. Once cash-based Shields are spent on something, any return of those Shields (sell back to Majerio, play golden lockbox) would be paid out in in-game Shields.
Couldn't an easy solution to the new character problem be. You can't give gold shields to another character, and end up with less than 5 gold shields at the end of giving?