Dave wrote:
Regarding guild members retaining their rank when rejoining the guild, there are a few technical problems with that particular feature:
1. It would require us to retain a potentially unlimited amount of data. A guild could have thousands of ex members, and we would have to remember all of their ranks. One of the reasons that we cap the number of members in a guild is that it allows us to put a limit on the amount of data we have to save.
2. If we did restore people's ranks, we would have to have some mechanism by which you could demote people who are no longer in the guild or people would be able to abuse the system. For example, lets say an officer of a guild is causing problems (kicking people randomly, starting and canceling raids, whatever). They could simply leave the guild before the GM has a chance to kick them, wait a few days/weeks, then rejoin the guild. The would immediately get their officer rank back and would have the ability to kick every member who was a veteran or lower, then immediately leave the guild again. This would require a lot of new UI to be created, and again could potentially be a list of thousands of ex members.
That being said, we are aware that the current guild system isn't working very well at the moment. We hope to address some of the concerns raised by you and others, but we can't do it in this particular way for the reasons mentioned above. We don't have anything specific to announce at this time, but we do read all of the suggestions posted here and we are considering other solutions to some of the current issues with guilds.
I (as a developer) see these as rather trivial to solve (except developing the new UI). One easy solution is that if they are gone for a certain time period (say a week), they automatically lose their status. And/Or cap the maximum number of people the guild can have elevated. It can even be 60.
I know that you all didn't expect mercs to appear in the game, but they are here to stay and it is to your credit that the game has handled it so well. My suggestions would work with the current usage patterns where most guilds have 30-50 regular members, some of who badly need this functionality, and the rest are mercs who never go above recruit level.
If you won't do this, how about an alternative that has trivial GUI requirements? It is not as good but it would help a lot. Give the GM a switch that they can optionally turn on to let Officers promote other people to be Officers. The biggest problem right now is that when Officers merc, only the GM can repromote them.
The bigger guild issues like how can guilds survive as players burn out are difficult.