Book of Heroes

Update 1.5 Design Notes - Part 2 · page 3

Dave wrote:

Regarding guild members retaining their rank when rejoining the guild, there are a few technical problems with that particular feature:

1. It would require us to retain a potentially unlimited amount of data. A guild could have thousands of ex members, and we would have to remember all of their ranks. One of the reasons that we cap the number of members in a guild is that it allows us to put a limit on the amount of data we have to save.

2. If we did restore people's ranks, we would have to have some mechanism by which you could demote people who are no longer in the guild or people would be able to abuse the system. For example, lets say an officer of a guild is causing problems (kicking people randomly, starting and canceling raids, whatever). They could simply leave the guild before the GM has a chance to kick them, wait a few days/weeks, then rejoin the guild. The would immediately get their officer rank back and would have the ability to kick every member who was a veteran or lower, then immediately leave the guild again. This would require a lot of new UI to be created, and again could potentially be a list of thousands of ex members.

That being said, we are aware that the current guild system isn't working very well at the moment. We hope to address some of the concerns raised by you and others, but we can't do it in this particular way for the reasons mentioned above. We don't have anything specific to announce at this time, but we do read all of the suggestions posted here and we are considering other solutions to some of the current issues with guilds.

I (as a developer) see these as rather trivial to solve (except developing the new UI). One easy solution is that if they are gone for a certain time period (say a week), they automatically lose their status. And/Or cap the maximum number of people the guild can have elevated. It can even be 60.

I know that you all didn't expect mercs to appear in the game, but they are here to stay and it is to your credit that the game has handled it so well. My suggestions would work with the current usage patterns where most guilds have 30-50 regular members, some of who badly need this functionality, and the rest are mercs who never go above recruit level.

If you won't do this, how about an alternative that has trivial GUI requirements? It is not as good but it would help a lot. Give the GM a switch that they can optionally turn on to let Officers promote other people to be Officers. The biggest problem right now is that when Officers merc, only the GM can repromote them.

The bigger guild issues like how can guilds survive as players burn out are difficult.
Lord_Venan wrote:

Why do you hate crafting? Hopefully we don't do whatever that is.

Upon further thought, there are extremes involved. The worse crafting systems are those that:

1. You have to discover recipes and there may be hundreds of them.
2. You have to farm the components which are random drops in different locations which are usually poorly documented if at all.
3. Then you use them to form a consumable. Some games have spells that are consumables which you have to go through this process all the time!

The above is what has left the bad taste in my mouth. You spend more time farming components than you do actually questing or raiding.

To your credit, you have #1 starting with 18 which isn't too enormous. I am unsure about #2. You are NOT doing #3.

I will give your system a chance. I just have yet to see the fun of this in any RPG I have played. Maybe you will have figured out something everybody else has missed.

Please note I have no issue with the consumable part of your post. Making blessings consumables instead of taking effect immediately is great! I know I haven't collected some of my award emails because I don't want the blessings to kick in yet. Please (and I don't think you are) go down the path where spells require consumables.

Let me give you compliments which is that your battle system is wonderful. It takes the core features of my favorite RPG battle system of all times (Grandia II) but boils it down so it works on a phone.
Enchantments look like a nice addition. I hope we can get them with a mix of solo and raid content and not only with valor like gems.
It would be cool if the enchantment was changing the aspect of the equipment (maybe a logo or a color). So, as mentioned by Japster, we finally stop looking all the same (assuming we get different enchantments).
TCG_japster wrote:Another peeve I have is about the weakness of one handed weapons and shields. Pretty much every Justicar and Mage is going to tell you 2h is the way to go except for perhaps in onslaught (which really isn't a prevalent raid style right now). There has to be more balancing done to make one hand weapons and shields more attractive. I would have thought allowing enchantments to go on an offhand or shield would be a good way to tempt people to give up the raw damage of 2h weapons but alas you guys seem to disagree.
I agree with Bbbb. I admit the shield is currently useless but I tried both 1H and 2H level 11 on my mage and could not find a single situation, against mobs, bosses or onslaught, were the added damage was worth the loss in speed. I can go through any WoF boss phase without taking a single hit with 1H, but I do get some with 2H, for instance. I did end up using a 2H sword on my justicar though (much lower might), maybe 2h works better at low levels?
Ideas:

1. Raid schedules: Create another option to start guild raids by predetermined preferences. Example: Host selects number of players required to start raid, once the required members are "checked in" - the raid automatically starts... Status could be displayed on entering raid menu....

2. Create another tier of spells for 25+ level characters...

3. Create option for global raids. A raid schedule for all only requiring might to participate. Once in a guild, a character can advance on the option of earning treasure, money, etc. The only benefit for the guild rep is self character development... Basically this option gives players from all guilds to play together and earn character rewards and the option to message active participants... This feather would add another dimension to the game...

japster

ModeratorSat Dec 1, 2012 7:24 am
Romain wrote:
I agree with Bbbb. I admit the shield is currently useless but I tried both 1H and 2H level 11 on my mage and could not find a single situation, against mobs, bosses or onslaught, were the added damage was worth the loss in speed. I can go through any WoF boss phase without taking a single hit with 1H, but I do get some with 2H, for instance. I did end up using a 2H sword on my justicar though (much lower might), maybe 2h works better at low levels?
Bbbb wrote:

That's funny because most knowledgable Justicar/Mage I know will tell you to avoid 2h except for the gem cost savings (which sucks BTW). The speed penalty outweighs any damage you gain. Yes, the shield is basically useless though. I almost deleted my mage because I was taking way too much damage until someone convinced me to give a sword a try. Made tons of difference.

The changes for 1.5 I have heard so far will tilt things ever more towards 1h because it has been hinted that defense will have more value.

Hmmm I can swear most of the knowledegable Justicar and Mages I know are using 2-hand weapons. Even on the might leaderboard, the top 25 are almost exclusively using 2hand weapons.

What are you haste ratings? Right now with max haste the difference in speed isn't much for most skills, and due to the way haste is calculated, many low-timered skills like buffs, and interrupts (stunning blow, icy grasp, time void) becoming extremely fast to cast with 2hands, and have almost same timing as 1hand. Buffs definitely are cast at 0.25s even for 2handers, while icy grasp/stunning blow are 0.1s slower only.

Speaking for mages at least, I do not get hit on WoF boss phases at all with my 2hander. All that is required is careful observation of enemy timers...and my massive damage from crits takes them out in 2-3 hits max. You just need to buff up quickly and interrupt, both types of spells, which like I said, do not have significantly longer cast times when comparing between 2hand and 1hands. All that is necessary after that is to take your time and cast a damaging spell and wipe out the waves almost instantly. For mages, you get two interrupts, making the task even easier (to avoid damage, that is). Admittedly Justicars may miss their Seismic Slash or Stunning Blow, and thus may take more damage than mages. But there really isn't any excuse for a mage to take much damage, even with a 2hand, if he's careful and has max haste.

That is why I do not see how 1handers can ever be more efficient, bar onslaught (since that raid is really is about critting as current mechanics would not allow a 2hander to wipe out a wave even at max magic if you do not crit; thus the "more' attacks you can make in the limited time, the higher your chances of crit occur). The game right now is too slanted to damage, and the speed efficiencies 1handers give are not sufficiently noticeable to offset the damage from 2handers.

But yes I agree 1.5 hints are greater diversity and possibly a slant to improve defensive stats. Thus shields may be more relevant. Also timers are going to be portioned to the hundredth, and thus every % of haste will make an appreciable difference and hopefully make the speed differences between 2hand and 1hand more marked.

Anyways I hope to get a developer response on their view of 1hand versus 2hands.
Hi, i would like to have question. What happen with blessing, which will be active, while will be patch implemented?

Thanks you for your work.

Lord_Venan

Site AdminSat Dec 1, 2012 2:49 pm
Regarding 1 vs. 2 handers

The dynamics here are going to change. While I'd like to say I know exactly how it will play out, to be honest I'm not entirely sure. It's a hard problem with a ton of variables. Some things to consider though (a number of these are things I was going to mention next week, but hey, while we're discussing it...)

1. We are changing how block works. Block will now work more often, but will only block partial damage. It will also partially block spell damage. This can be increased via enchantments.
2. Monsters are getting harder. You will get hit. Whether speed is still your friend or something else remains to be seen. But more damage mitigation is definitely something to consider.
3. Cooldowns are now tied to the haste timer. So where you might have scenarios where the superior speed of the sword was negated because your rotation was hitting cooldown bumps, that will no longer be the case.
4. Combat timer is now in hundredths of a second, so you'll see differences across the board when you have a 1h or 2h weapon equipped.
5. Staves are now the "preferred" Mage weapon. When equipped it will give you a default spell attack instead of a melee attack, and they will also be faster than before. I think a lot of Mages will be switching to them in 1.5, except for those who perhaps want to try more obscure builds.

At the end of the day, a dead monster is the best damage mitigation, but I think there are enough new dynamics here that there is no best answer and will be subject to player's play style.

Regarding Blessings

Any blessings that are active should still be active if they have time remaining on them. The new consumables will still grant the same buffs, but the name may change that you see on them.

Regarding Guilds and Mercs

Well, I don't have a definite answer here yet, other than that we want to see less mercing, so making mercing easier is not necessarily going to be something we allocate a lot of resources to. We see mercing as a user solution to some design problems with raids and guilds, and the best way to fix this is through some design/rule changes so that people who want to merc are definitely making a tradeoff of some sort versus those who want to stay in one guild. Currently it is just the defacto best way to get valor, and that is a bit broken.

That being said we are up against the wire right now so how much we actually do will highly depend on how the next few days go, so I'm not being vague on purpose, it really is just up in the air still.
Hi, one more questio. Do you thinking about chance concept of loading data from internet when you are in dungeon, like hunter, trask....?

Now game load data each one, two battles. I think, that will be great, when game load whole date at the start.

Thanks
Lord_Venan wrote:
5. Staves are now the "preferred" Mage weapon. When equipped it will give you a default spell attack instead of a melee attack, and they will also be faster than before. I think a lot of Mages will be switching to them in 1.5, except for those who perhaps want to try more obscure builds.

This should be interesting.

Well, I don't have a definite answer here yet, other than that we want to see less mercing, so making mercing easier is not necessarily going to be something we allocate a lot of resources to. We see mercing as a user solution to some design problems with raids and guilds, and the best way to fix this is through some design/rule changes so that people who want to merc are definitely making a tradeoff of some sort versus those who want to stay in one guild. Currently it is just the defacto best way to get valor, and that is a bit broken.

I know we are way beyond 1.5 here, but I want to make sure you understand all the reasons people are mercing now. Yes, it is the defacto best way to get valor and that plays a huge factor in the people trying to beef up their character. However, I would say that most high might (9K and above) people merc for socialization reasons not valor. My BoH friends are spread across more than 10 different guilds. By reducing the socialization, there will be less interest in the game and quicker burnout. Raiding with different people is one of the things that keep us going. Also, sometimes you just want to play and your guild isn't doing anything. Since the single player content was finished long ago (by a lot of us), what else can we do?

Personally, I think the guild/raid problems need to be fixed on the demand side not by penalizing the supply side (like it sounds like you are suggesting). If guilds were not having problems with losing members, not being able to replace them and then having problems completing raids, they wouldn't need mercs. When demand is reduced, then the supply side will have to adjust. Right now, the demand is virtually unlimited. Part of this is that the number of guilds is way out of control. And no, I don't have a solution to suggest - it is a difficult problem.

Thanks