Well this became much longer and more detailed than a suggestion ideally should be so i summarized the first two longer texts and put the summary before the main texts to make it a little easier to plow thru. So here i go ...
I have given some thought into how to improve the existing defenses of boh. The problems imo is unreliability (dodge), ineffectiveness (physical/magic resist) and health at a certain level is just redundant as health potions can easily cover all ur needs in that department.
Summary of the basic concept:
Block and dodge (defense abilities) that always trigger causing a universal cooldown period of all def abilities. All def abilities controled by a singel toggle button.
Summary of abilities & stat concept:
Adding new ability, resist, to complement block and dodge while also tying all def abilities to stats. Dodge to dodge, resist to magic resist and block to physical resist. Stats govern the cooldown of def abilities.
What i propose is to change the way block and dodge are implemented. In boh today these abilities trigger randomly with the player in charge of the frecuency of this. Instead the def abilities could be redesigned to trigger then have a cooldown period before they could be used again. The cooldown could be universal, all def abilities on the same cooldown, or singel ability (i have used the universal option). But to avoid another menu and excessive clicking all def abilities could be controled with a singel button. This button would simply be a toggle, defend or don't, while the choice of def ability would be automatic triggering the first viable ability in a list (more on that later).
These changes would give players both oversight and some control over their defense opening up for npc abilities that exploit this like the wraiths impale that do 2x critical damage should u try to block it or the spiderweb that stuns u briefly should u try to dodge it.
Moving on to the structure of the def abilities and how to tie them into the stat system which leads to an introduction. Resist, an ability meant to complement block and dodge by associate each of them with an existing stat. Quite obviously it would be dodge to dodge, resist to magic resist and block to physical resist. There would be a new benefit to these stats in the form of the stat governing the cooldown of the associated def ability. Resist and dodge could progress in an identical fashion but block due to incorporating the strength of both the other abilities would require a counter. This penalty could be that block only removes 80-90% of the incoming damage, an increased cooldown period or something i havent thought of. By then tying shields into the block mechanic as a means to alliviate the penalty should work to balance it but it's precarious as block must be kept a viable defense for all classes but not overpowering Justicars.
The cooldown would also be the games way to decide which def ability to trigger with the fastest being the first choice if viable. And in order to give players even more control over this system the training hall could contain both info on the abilities and an enable/disable option to allow even more customization.
So finally the health issue. Imo this could easiest be adressed by changing the way potions work. Today the potions give a fixed amount of health but if redesigned to also give a percentual health recovery based upon the damage to the character when using the potion rather than max health. And increase this percentual heal far more per potionlevel than the fixed amount. Then that together with a drastic reduction in max number of potions a character can carry, around 5 perhaps, would definantly favor health gems.
Another idea is to give each health gem a chance to give an extra energy recovery with every tick. These extra energy could be saved by giving them out as energy pill items. Of course there would have to be a limit as to how many of these pills that could be stored to avoid overpowering the gems. This i believe would bring life to the dead red gems.
So are there any useful ideas above. I appreciate any thoughts on the matter.
I have given some thought into how to improve the existing defenses of boh. The problems imo is unreliability (dodge), ineffectiveness (physical/magic resist) and health at a certain level is just redundant as health potions can easily cover all ur needs in that department.
Summary of the basic concept:
Block and dodge (defense abilities) that always trigger causing a universal cooldown period of all def abilities. All def abilities controled by a singel toggle button.
Summary of abilities & stat concept:
Adding new ability, resist, to complement block and dodge while also tying all def abilities to stats. Dodge to dodge, resist to magic resist and block to physical resist. Stats govern the cooldown of def abilities.
What i propose is to change the way block and dodge are implemented. In boh today these abilities trigger randomly with the player in charge of the frecuency of this. Instead the def abilities could be redesigned to trigger then have a cooldown period before they could be used again. The cooldown could be universal, all def abilities on the same cooldown, or singel ability (i have used the universal option). But to avoid another menu and excessive clicking all def abilities could be controled with a singel button. This button would simply be a toggle, defend or don't, while the choice of def ability would be automatic triggering the first viable ability in a list (more on that later).
These changes would give players both oversight and some control over their defense opening up for npc abilities that exploit this like the wraiths impale that do 2x critical damage should u try to block it or the spiderweb that stuns u briefly should u try to dodge it.
Moving on to the structure of the def abilities and how to tie them into the stat system which leads to an introduction. Resist, an ability meant to complement block and dodge by associate each of them with an existing stat. Quite obviously it would be dodge to dodge, resist to magic resist and block to physical resist. There would be a new benefit to these stats in the form of the stat governing the cooldown of the associated def ability. Resist and dodge could progress in an identical fashion but block due to incorporating the strength of both the other abilities would require a counter. This penalty could be that block only removes 80-90% of the incoming damage, an increased cooldown period or something i havent thought of. By then tying shields into the block mechanic as a means to alliviate the penalty should work to balance it but it's precarious as block must be kept a viable defense for all classes but not overpowering Justicars.
The cooldown would also be the games way to decide which def ability to trigger with the fastest being the first choice if viable. And in order to give players even more control over this system the training hall could contain both info on the abilities and an enable/disable option to allow even more customization.
So finally the health issue. Imo this could easiest be adressed by changing the way potions work. Today the potions give a fixed amount of health but if redesigned to also give a percentual health recovery based upon the damage to the character when using the potion rather than max health. And increase this percentual heal far more per potionlevel than the fixed amount. Then that together with a drastic reduction in max number of potions a character can carry, around 5 perhaps, would definantly favor health gems.
Another idea is to give each health gem a chance to give an extra energy recovery with every tick. These extra energy could be saved by giving them out as energy pill items. Of course there would have to be a limit as to how many of these pills that could be stored to avoid overpowering the gems. This i believe would bring life to the dead red gems.
So are there any useful ideas above. I appreciate any thoughts on the matter.