Book of Heroes

BUIŁD : A Physical Stalker · page 4

Yeah, I suppose you guys are right. I mean, I keep caltrops around for that very purpose, but I find myself rarely using it except it the highest might raids, and rare mobs. Day to day grinding and dungeon fighting doesn't see much caltrops used - although that could be because I've been focusing on trask and not really anything higher.
Asandir wrote:So has anyone actually compared a high end magic sw to a high end melee sw??


What do you define as high end?
Oda_tennischamp5 wrote:
Asandir wrote:So has anyone actually compared a high end magic sw to a high end melee sw??


What do you define as high end?

I would say tier 13ish
why T13 lol? not T12 or T14? weird spot to have the cutoff.

I have 7 T12s, 1 T13, 2 T14s lol... am i high end? :p
Oda_tennischamp5 wrote:why T13 lol? not T12 or T14? weird spot to have the cutoff.

I have 7 T12s, 1 T13, 2 T14s lol... am i high end? :p

Yes you are. Now give us your builds and comparison pls. :)

kkthxbye
Lappi
Okay... Let's see... I'm a Melee SW w/ 13,486 might

Hero Training
110 to 130 in Melee, Magic, P. Resist, M. Resist, Dodge, Crit
150 in Crit Power
235 in Haste

My Ability Points:
Tier 1
Lv. 0 Toxic Blade
Lv. 3 Caltrops (I only use these for portals now - no need during raids)
Lv. 0 Ensnare
Lv. 3 Dual Wield

Tier 2
Lv. 3 Piercing Strike
Lv. 0 Poison Cloud
Lv. 3 Maneuver
Lv. 3 Assassinate

Tier 3
Lv. 3 Reflexive Strike
Lv. 0 Acid Spray
Lv. 3 Critical Eye
Lv. 3 Riposte

Tier 4
Lv. 0 Smoke Bomb
Lv. 3 Neurotoxin
Lv. 0 Urgency
Lv. 3 Corrosive Blades

Caltrops, Riposte, Maneuver - High end, they tend not to be as useful in my opinion. They're somewhat the weak links in my build. I'd potentially trade them but the only things worth trading for are Smoke Bomb and Urgency.

3 T14s (Main Hand [Lv. 2 Armor Penetration], Offhand, Ring)
1 T13 (Vday Bracers w/ Lv. 6 Armor Penetration)
Rest T12.

3 T5 Gems, 21 T4s, 16 T3s [Red = Melee, Blue = Crit Power, Yellow = 3 way split]

Stats (without added bonuses)
Melee - 3437 [+876 damage]
Magic - 640 [+244 damage]
Crit - 1900 [+30.94%]
Crit Power - 3080 [+183.37%]
Defense - 1561 [-17.48%]
P. Resist - 193 [-1.53%]
M. Resist - 193 [-1.53%]
Dodge - 2076 [+30.87%]
Haste - 2358 [+34.10%]
Armor P - 6.4%

I think that's everything you could need to know about me.

My build is somewhat more optimized for CoC at the moment, else ~10% haste is sacrificed for +3.5% crit and dodge.
A few comments:

BJ, I don't think Toxic Blade is necessary for the Lord of Blades. I find the best strategy is to Ensnare or Break rune him before he gets it off. If you can't, you can try to Purge it but he frequently resists that. Mostly you can just power through it. I think Toxic Blade is unnecessary as a backup. Also, unless you have it up to Toxic Blade 3 and you've got 2 or 3 Poisons on him, it's not going to hit as hard as Piercing Strike or Dual-Wield unless you also dump a lot into Magic. Not worth it.

Also, you'll usually get him Poisoned with something else before he throws his first Vile Ward anyway.

Second, I find the combination of Maneuver and Riposte to be a valuable combination, but it makes Dual Wield very important. If you have Dual Wield 3 and you double-crit, you do almost as much damage as Piercing Strike 3 crits. So my rotation features a lot of Piercing Strike / Regular attacks, with Reflexive Strikes and Ensnares thrown in opportunistically. And of course, Caltrops. What this means is that I'll often have Piercing Strike, Ensnare, and Caltrops all on timer when I get a Dodge-Riposte. It's best to be able to follow that with a strong attack if necessary - Reflexive Strike doesn't always do the trick, and maybe won't get your timers all the way reset anyway.

I find the SW Dual-strike attack to be VERY useful.

I'm now going to remove Toxic Blade from my build and replace it with Smoke Bomb and probably another level in either Reflexive Strike or Smoke Bomb.

(L30, about 12000 might).