Book of Heroes

Opportunity cost - the numbers

So I finally got my first indigo flux after 386 vile kills. Venan and beekeo has continuously mentioned that higher portal levels can drop more fluxes.

Fine.

However, im more concerned about the opportunity cost of my spent energy and decided to run some numbers.

386 vile kills. Averages to 2 kills per encounter.
This is 193 encounters for 1 indigo flux or 386 energy.

Venan has stated that portal are and game content, so out I will equate energy spent to raids.

I do not always get a chance to finish a raid during my commute to work in the morning. However i do get to dump my e.

At 32e, i get around 100kv per in ck or vallus (i think its around 2k RPP).

Now for the opportunity cost: what would I have gained if I had spent 386e in raids instead of portals?

386/32 = ~12.0625 raids where I emptied my energy
12 raids = ~1200kv. Not quite enough to get any of the big champion slots.

However, if you follow the quest line, you will in fact have to find 6 indigos. 1 for the first quest, spend 1 to enchant and use a catalyst, then 5 more for the next quest.

Assuming my luck on fluxes holds out at 1 indigo per 386 kills, i would need to spend 5 times more energy or (5*386e) or 1930e to complete the quest. If i dumped that into a vallus/ck raid and get 100kv per 32e, that equals 6000kv. Enough to get 2 t4gems (big visual gains) or 3 pieces of the champ set (big visual gains).

Its been a fun update but looking at these numbers really makes me question your direction on the game. Grind in itself is not bad. But when you force a grind in a restrictive gameplay environment (energy) by implementing low drop rates, that grind is further transparent.
You are having bad luck as I was with the goblin. Several of us months ago discussed how whatever RNG (Random Number Generation) algorithm Venan uses seems to make unlikely run happen far more frequently than they should. They have never given us any details of how this is implemented (nor am I saying they should).

My proposed solution would be to have a known floor (and ceiling). Let's say the flux odds are 1% (I made this number up). Make it such that an individual toon can't go more than say 200 straight encounters with no flux drops. To counter balance it, if they are above 10 in those 200, cap them.

FYI: I do think your KV numbers are 30-40% too high and you have to subtract some off for failed raids, but it doesn't change your basic point. I am not a big fan of rare drops that are critical to game progress. I think this is Venan trying to make the content last longer but just not a particularly enjoyable way of doing it.