Book of Heroes

The 1.5 damage formula (Justicars)

I have now gone through the testing of the damage formula, and there are some very big and important changes in 1.5.
The main conclusion is that the damage bonus from melee (and magic) is now multiplied by the attack speed of the weapon, meaning that the 1-handed sword has a bonus multiplier of 1.0, and the 2-handed axe has a multiplier of 1.4. The result is that the way to max DPS no longer goes through the 1-hander, but rather goes through the 2-hander which in all my simulations is able to do 10-15% more DPS.

Another important issue for Justicars specifically is the Frenzy talent. In the description it says that the (15%) bonus damage only applies to enemies that are wounded, but currently it seems to be bugged, adding the 15% bonus damage to all physical abilities.
The result from this is that the spirit attacks currently are getting considerably lower damage output than the physical attacks, for an increase in bonus damage, and it is only at Smite 3 that smite becomes comparable to Brutal Strike in terms of damage output, which is a lot of talent points for an attack with a 3-second cooldown that only works properly if you put a lot of gems into magic, that could be used more efficiently to improve that already very good physical abilities.

The new damage formula for Justicars is as follows:
(((WPN MIN + WPN MAX) / 2) + (Bonus DMG * WPN Multiplier)) * Skill Multiplier * Frenzy Multiplier

WPN MIN is the minimum weapon damage (1339 for T14 axe)
WPN MAX is the maximum weapon damage (1812 for T14 axe)
Bonus DMG is the your physical (or magic) damage bonus (I currently have 900)
WPN Multiplier is the damage multiplier based on your weapon speed (1.4 for 2-handed axe)
Skill Multiplier is the damage multiplier from the specific ability you are looking at (1.6 for Brutal Strike 3)
Frenzy Multiplier is the increase to physical abilities if you have the frenzy talent (as described above, 1.15 for Frenzy 3)

The above only calculates the actual direct damage shown, but if you divide it by your attack speed you get the base dps, and if you again multiply by the crit chance and crit damage multiplier you will get the actual DPS from each ability.
I am currently working on a template you can use to calculate your own DPS as well as the marginal benefit from increasing the various stats, but that requires a bit more testing of the diminishing return formulas. I hope to have it done in about a week or so :)

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Fri Dec 28, 2012 4:14 am
Wow, great job Arror. Just confirms my decision to switch back from a 1h sword to the 2h axe. Thanks for proving this for me :)
THANKS! Great info confirming much of my less- than-scientific approach to new specs. Still contemplating your suggestion to drop smite.
The sure hit coupled with diminishing returns loading up everything on melee (vs. getting more overall bang for the ability buck by having a 2 to 1ish melee to magic score) still has me on the fence.

Looking forward to your additional work!
Philc wrote:Thanks for these great infos.

Is that a bug to be corrected in 1.5.2?

I think Venan should fix this. People only use 2-handed weapons and 1-handed weapons will become trash.
TrungYaphets wrote:
Philc wrote:Thanks for these great infos.

Is that a bug to be corrected in 1.5.2?

I think Venan should fix this. People only use 2-handed weapons and 1-handed weapons will become trash.

I am not sure what each of you refer to.

The frenzy bug seems to be fixed in 1.5.2, so enjoy it while it lasts. I know I will ;)

However, there are other bugs (procs interfering with each other, brutality not giving any crit damage bonus) that currently limit the damage of Justicars, and I hope they are also fixed.

The damage formula as stated above actually has the effect of making the choice between a 1-hander and 2-hander a real choice. You trade speed and defense for damage.
And 1-handers still have an important role to play. I believe that my primary choice for onslaught raids will be a 1-hander, because the speed provides more 'utility'. And the extra damage of a 2-hander is useless in onslaughts if the damage done is considerably higher than the health of the mobs.

So the result is that once the last bugs have been sorted, Justicars have a talent tree with a lot of choices between very useful abilities, each of them catering different playing styles and gear setups. I am still respeccing to figure out which setup works best for me, and I will also end up testing 1-hand setups when I get enough valor for another T14 weapon :)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed Jan 2, 2013 2:12 pm
Arror wrote:
The new damage formula for Justicars is as follows:
(((WPN MIN + WPN MAX) / 2) + (Bonus DMG * WPN Multiplier)) * Skill Multiplier * Frenzy Multiplier

WPN Multiplier is the damage multiplier based on your weapon speed (1.4 for 2-handed axe)
The above only calculates the actual direct damage shown, but if you divide it by your attack speed you get the base dps

You say *WPN Multipler based on your weapon speed, but then divide it by your attack speed. These two factors cancel each other.

To compare v1.5 weapons, examine the DPS listed in Majerio’s Shop. Note: Remember Shadow Walkers get daggers.

Research Note: v1.5 weapons are significantly different than v1.4. I have been running WoF for months using a v1.4 Tier 8 Sword 1.0s instead of my v1.4 Tier 11 Sword & v1.4 Tier 11 Axe.