Book of Heroes

1.5 balance and grinding issues

Hi Everyone,

I would like to set the scene here .. I am a longstanding player of BoH with 11 characters of all 3 different types, most of which are either lvl 25 or lvl 21.

I have noted several things since 1.5 came out and have had a chance to look at things before rushing to post. A quick warning .. this will be a fairly lengthy post.

Firstly .. Character types ...

Justicar ... pre 1.5 used to be annoying because opponents would dodge attacks. Post 1.5 they suck even more. I have just done Bloodfang as my daily quest with my lvl 25, 6000+ might justicar and had to burn 8 health potions and several runes, including 2 break runes to find I was still defeated. And possibly even worse than that was the fact it took 24 of my 36 energy to get there, leaving me enough energy for nothing really as my only active quest is for the west portal requiring 16 energy to get in. No energy left for anything else like raiding.

My Justicars really miss the crowd control of Seismic Slash and the power of Magic based attacks .. Smite may as well be renamed as Slap now ...

Shadow Walker ... Poison Shadow Walkers used to rock .. now they have been nerfed big style in favour of Physical attacks. And giving us 3 respec tokens for free was no where near enough for me to figure that out ..

Delaying Smoke Bomb has a huge impact on Shadow Walkers and we are now left really needing to max dodge and crit to benefit from the new passive skills instead ..

Mages ... My best advice right now is just to forget even trying a Fire Mage .. just dont go there. Ice Mages now rock ... the ability to Freeze is what they have always been missing .. My Ice Mage forgoes huge damage for speed with a sword and shield in a way I find to be a good balance between offence and defence.

So .. Justicars just suck, as do Fire Mages. Shadow Walkers need to learn new life skills and Ice Mages are playable straight out of the box ... Why does it appear Venan got the balance so wrong?

I think the answer for most players will be similar to what I found ... I spent a long while crafting characters with skills, hero training and gems to support their style of play. This included me spending my hard earned on Gold Shields.

Since 1.5 not only do the Abilities for each character need changing, the gems and sometimes equipment need changing too. This requires either a lot of silver or a further investment of gold shields ... or in extreme cases just starting over with new characters.

I hope Venan realise how much that will impact players .. some will just wonder why their character suddenly sucks and give up .. others will be frustrated at the cost in both time and money that retraining and equiping characters requires.

New Content .. Portals, Incursions, Shards, Crafting and Enchanting

Wow .. a big update was promised and a lot has been introduced .. but is it all for the better?

The ability to earn shards for defeating bosses .. great for new characters who haven't flattened the Hunter 200 times already. For characters above level 25 this means either covering ground you did already or facing Trask, the Goblin or the Vile ... but boy is it a grind to get there.

Crafting and Enchanting ... sound great but takes forever to gather ingredients and actually achieve anything with it all.

Portals .. likewise .. a huge grind to achieve what? with time limits on incursions too.

Questing ... takes a lot longer to finish quests at the higher levels and the new content, even daily quests.

And whats with the double energy entry cost for a world area and the double energy cost for battles in portals ... my energy disappears long before I feel I have advanced the plot or gathered ingredients ... and forget raiding as I dont have the time or energy anymore.

And there is the biggest change and possible the biggest frustration of all with the changes that 1.5 has brought to BoH. The TIME required to play the game now, let alone the cost.

Players now effectively have to choose between three types of game play ... questing to advance the plot line ... questing for ingredients to craft and enchant .. or raiding. You cant do all three because of the limitations of energy and the TIME you have to be able to play in. Most of us balance work, family and gaming.

My guild is based on being somewhere my family could come together to raid together .. what we found was raids were ridiculously long things that we would not all be available for at the same time .. now we have less time for raiding as we all have too many other things to do ..

Guilds will be seriously impacted by players needing time to play in the other facets of the game as they develop their characters.

Players will face the choice of concentrating on one or two characters and leaving the others behind or taking a very long time to grind out gathering ingredients for each character.

Summary

The scope of the changes is absolutely huge and possibly because of that loses it's way slightly.

Players will have to choose how they play (questing, gathering ingredients or raiding) and that fragments the game and has no clear goals. This means players lose their way and give up because they don't know where they are going with the game.

I mentioned the word 'grind' several times and that is what this game is now .. a grind. That makes is far less enjoyable to play and much more frustrating. The drop rates and/or recipe requirements need to be seriously looked at to address the balance of achieving things against players just plain getting bored before they get there.

Guilds need to be smaller and raids need to be much shorter. Gathering a few like minded players together for an hour or two is possible .. trying to gather a larger number for longer times is just not going to happen .. and since 1.5 it is even harder for guild masters .. this introduces even more frustration and reasons for people to give up.

As always I wait to see what others think .. after all others may or may not be finding the same issues I am ...
MrNibbles wrote:Hi Everyone,

I would like to set the scene here .. I am a longstanding player of BoH with 11 characters of all 3 different types, most of which are either lvl 25 or lvl 21.

I have noted several things since 1.5 came out and have had a chance to look at things before rushing to post. A quick warning .. this will be a fairly lengthy post.

Firstly .. Character types ...

Justicar ... pre 1.5 used to be annoying because opponents would dodge attacks. Post 1.5 they suck even more. I have just done Bloodfang as my daily quest with my lvl 25, 6000+ might justicar and had to burn 8 health potions and several runes, including 2 break runes to find I was still defeated. And possibly even worse than that was the fact it took 24 of my 36 energy to get there, leaving me enough energy for nothing really as my only active quest is for the west portal requiring 16 energy to get in. No energy left for anything else like raiding.

My Justicars really miss the crowd control of Seismic Slash and the power of Magic based attacks .. Smite may as well be renamed as Slap now ...

Shadow Walker ... Poison Shadow Walkers used to rock .. now they have been nerfed big style in favour of Physical attacks. And giving us 3 respec tokens for free was no where near enough for me to figure that out ..

Delaying Smoke Bomb has a huge impact on Shadow Walkers and we are now left really needing to max dodge and crit to benefit from the new passive skills instead ..

Mages ... My best advice right now is just to forget even trying a Fire Mage .. just dont go there. Ice Mages now rock ... the ability to Freeze is what they have always been missing .. My Ice Mage forgoes huge damage for speed with a sword and shield in a way I find to be a good balance between offence and defence.

So .. Justicars just suck, as do Fire Mages. Shadow Walkers need to learn new life skills and Ice Mages are playable straight out of the box ... Why does it appear Venan got the balance so wrong?

I think the answer for most players will be similar to what I found ... I spent a long while crafting characters with skills, hero training and gems to support their style of play. This included me spending my hard earned on Gold Shields.

Since 1.5 not only do the Abilities for each character need changing, the gems and sometimes equipment need changing too. This requires either a lot of silver or a further investment of gold shields ... or in extreme cases just starting over with new characters.

I hope Venan realise how much that will impact players .. some will just wonder why their character suddenly sucks and give up .. others will be frustrated at the cost in both time and money that retraining and equiping characters requires.

New Content .. Portals, Incursions, Shards, Crafting and Enchanting

Wow .. a big update was promised and a lot has been introduced .. but is it all for the better?

The ability to earn shards for defeating bosses .. great for new characters who haven't flattened the Hunter 200 times already. For characters above level 25 this means either covering ground you did already or facing Trask, the Goblin or the Vile ... but boy is it a grind to get there.

Crafting and Enchanting ... sound great but takes forever to gather ingredients and actually achieve anything with it all.

Portals .. likewise .. a huge grind to achieve what? with time limits on incursions too.

Questing ... takes a lot longer to finish quests at the higher levels and the new content, even daily quests.

And whats with the double energy entry cost for a world area and the double energy cost for battles in portals ... my energy disappears long before I feel I have advanced the plot or gathered ingredients ... and forget raiding as I dont have the time or energy anymore.

And there is the biggest change and possible the biggest frustration of all with the changes that 1.5 has brought to BoH. The TIME required to play the game now, let alone the cost.

Players now effectively have to choose between three types of game play ... questing to advance the plot line ... questing for ingredients to craft and enchant .. or raiding. You cant do all three because of the limitations of energy and the TIME you have to be able to play in. Most of us balance work, family and gaming.

My guild is based on being somewhere my family could come together to raid together .. what we found was raids were ridiculously long things that we would not all be available for at the same time .. now we have less time for raiding as we all have too many other things to do ..

Guilds will be seriously impacted by players needing time to play in the other facets of the game as they develop their characters.

Players will face the choice of concentrating on one or two characters and leaving the others behind or taking a very long time to grind out gathering ingredients for each character.

Summary

The scope of the changes is absolutely huge and possibly because of that loses it's way slightly.

Players will have to choose how they play (questing, gathering ingredients or raiding) and that fragments the game and has no clear goals. This means players lose their way and give up because they don't know where they are going with the game.

I mentioned the word 'grind' several times and that is what this game is now .. a grind. That makes is far less enjoyable to play and much more frustrating. The drop rates and/or recipe requirements need to be seriously looked at to address the balance of achieving things against players just plain getting bored before they get there.

Guilds need to be smaller and raids need to be much shorter. Gathering a few like minded players together for an hour or two is possible .. trying to gather a larger number for longer times is just not going to happen .. and since 1.5 it is even harder for guild masters .. this introduces even more frustration and reasons for people to give up.

As always I wait to see what others think .. after all others may or may not be finding the same issues I am ...


+1 on the grinding
It's become very time consuming to play this game.
I love the new quests monsters portals and hgod.
But come on. The grind is just silly. And frankly, returning to the same quest fourth and fift day, that kinda takes the fun out of questing for me.
Especially since i'm really not making any progress.

For me this means I'm more and more thinking about giving up on this.
The one thing that keeps me in is my guildmates.

Regards Rhimfir
The Choice between raiding or questing is actually an easy one. It boils down to money. If you shell out huge numbers of gold shields, you can stay in the portals and quests long enough to get needed materials to enable you to get to the big raids. Several players I know have spent hundreds of dollars to drive their alts to enable them to get to GK or VG. Personally, I can't take that much money from my budget and the time it will take to progress to where the money can take you has fallen out of my available time. Unless things change fast, BOH has become to me DOA.
Marney wrote:
MrNibbles wrote:player of BoH with 11 characters
...what.

Yep ... I play on my htc phone using two logins with 5 characters each and since 1.5 started an 11th when not logged in to see what progression was like for a new character.
11 .... Wow

I only have 3, one of each type, but won't play the justicar, never liked it even pre 1.5. My SW is now level 29 with might about 12.5k and the wm level 30 with might about 15.5k. Both have gained about 3k might in the past week or so since 1.5.

I was a little flustered to start but that's to be expected if you haven't played a game for 5 months or so.

I've seen a lot of commentary about drop rates for flux, particularly indigo, and appearance rates of the special monsters like steelclaw, bloodfang et al. Now I'm 80%+ and 56% done with essence of the vile gate 1 so I feel like I have some thoughts on this as well:

Firstly, this is end game questing. It SHOULD take a while, why rush to the end game? It just leads to putting the game down after a while. I think the appearance rates, while occasionally frustrating, are not too bad. The quests are a bit long winded but I can live with it.

Flux and enchanting. Personally I haven't really hit a great deal of enchanting, partly cause I've only got a few recipes and partly cause most if my en is going on questing and raiding, but I have done What the Flux on both characters and have luck 2 and luck 1 on my wm's t14 amulet and ring. So I have some experience with drop rates. Personally I think they are a little low, but not terribly so. I have a suggestion here that I'll highlight below.

I'm confused as to why the boss area costs 20 en though. That's a mistake IMO. If it was 12 or 14 en I could live with that, but 20en is silly.

The rest of the content and work Venan have done is excellent IMO.

So, to my suggestion. Make incursion portal the same en requirements as unlimited areas - 2 to enter, then 1 for each subsequent continue. Consider doing the same for the new level 25-30 areas with steelclaw, bloodfang et al. Leave all drop rates as they are. This allows players to get to the higher incursion levels and hopefully get more flux without reinventing the wheel.

It's a relatively simple coding fix I imagine and I think it would do a LOT to ease the disquiet.
MrNibbles wrote:
Marney wrote:
MrNibbles wrote:player of BoH with 11 characters
...what.

Yep ... I play on my htc phone using two logins with 5 characters each and since 1.5 started an 11th when not logged in to see what progression was like for a new character.

One thing you have to realise Nibbles, is that 1.5 is new content for the end-game character. Being Level 25 is good and all, but only having 6000~ might by then? When I was level 25, I had 10k~ might, so I was able to dive into the new content with my justicar quite easily. Seismic slash is also still available, and you can use it very quickly into battle with a single application of Heroic Will :). 1.5 may be different, but it's not unbalanced. We as players just need to find our sweet spots before kicking butt once more! <3.

With much BoH love~~

~~Katt
MrNibbles wrote:
Marney wrote:
MrNibbles wrote:player of BoH with 11 characters
...what.

Yep ... I play on my htc phone using two logins with 5 characters each and since 1.5 started an 11th when not logged in to see what progression was like for a new character.
Well, as Katt noted, and rather unsurprisingly, you're very underpowered for your levels. Try not spreading yourself quite so thin before judging difficulty. C'mon, 4-digit might at 25, really?
Grinding is not bad per se, but it *becomes* bad when, instead of steady progress, largely predictable progress, quest advancement becomes *hugely* dependent on rare drops and on rare encounters.

Also the whole Portal thing may look good on paper, but in practice, it means that Venan is dictating to me what times of day I can play the solo - non-guild - component of the game. The two Flux-gathering Quests were particularly painful.
Agreed on that score. Dailies potentially costing 40+ energy (hunt Steelclaw/Gate Warden/Black Wyvern) are a bit much, too.