Book of Heroes

Tangible Guild Rewards- Leaderboards

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sun Jan 6, 2013 5:41 am
First of all, let me start by saying I am a big fan of mercing and the friendly bonds it creates amongst many guilds in the game. However, I know you guys want to move this game more towards a guild focus and further away from the mercing idea. Back when there were guild races on raids, there was a big reason to not merc as you were working for your guild and had to be home when rewards were issued.

The suggestion came up recently in chat that while the prestige and guild xp is great and gives us bragging rights, it does nothing to further the improvement of individual guild members. The idea was to give some sort of tangible reward to all members of a guild that ranks in the top 3 of the leaderboards. Valor would be a great idea as it has the most benefit to players, but hero tokens would also be nice, and I doubt you would give out gs but of course, that would be good too. Personally, I would prefer valor.

I think a reward system like this will help to discourage mercing by most players in the top guilds anyway so they make sure they are home to get their rewards. Again, I am not against mercing because I think it is a great benefit in the game but if you must push us away from regular mercing, this may be a good solution. Many times mercs are the only reason why raids succeed and if a guild fails a raid, that can be extremely demoralizing and can make people not want to play anymore which I know you don't want. I think we need to find a happy medium with the mercing issue and I think adding some individual rewards for top performing guilds can help with this issue.
I have to agree.
After surviving the death of 2 guilds, I considered merc'ing as well since there is little to no benefit to being in a steady guild. Guilds rise and fall, but mercs can just hang out and join the raids of whichever guilds soot them at that time. And they gain all the same rewards as members who have remained loyal to just one guild.
If Venan is serious about trying to make guilds and guild loyalty a significant part of this game, there needs to be some kind of tangible rewards that only the loyal members can receive. And it needs to be substantial enough that it becomes the obvious choice for most players.
I agree with Wyt as well. Many of us have seen, or worse experienced, dying guilds. As winter vacation comes to a close, we may see more guilds struggle. There are a VERY small number of consistently successful guilds. I have 2 guild toons & a merc toon. The guild toons enjoy chat, friendship and/or reliable raid schedules. The merc toon enjoys making new friends & helping out old ones. Mercs rely on guilds & vice versa. There must be some concrete changes that can benefit both.

Venan is great in that they really do listen to user feedback (although I'm sure there are times when they regret giving us a "voice" ;) Let's do some brainstorming on ideas to help deal with this problem. Some ideas are for Venan but some may be things we can implement as users. Here are a few that I've heard mentioned or come up with myself...feel free to add to the list:
* Wyt's & others great ideas on guild loyalty rewards (doesn't punish Mercs but gives positive incentives to members - I don't think this would be too hard to do since we already get rewards through a system)

*MUCH stricter requirements for starting a guild so newer players join an existing guild more often (new users benefit from old users experience, create friendships that encourage them to keep playing, this is win-win for everyone including Venan as it encourages retention. Guilds should only be created when someone can't find their niche in a current guild AND they have the experience to develop a new one...or better yet, when there is actual DEMAND for new guilds)

*Raising the 60 member limit or creating a special merc status that doesn't add to the 60 member limit.

*Rotating GMs or GM partnerships (helps with burn out)

*Better guild description pages with accurate schedules, details on member personalities & chat so people can more easily find a guild that suits them.

*Collaborative feeder guilds: many guilds have less active feeder guilds floating around but no one really running them. If a few guilds got together to focus on one feeder guild, helping younger might toons grow, this would take less effort.
Biomom wrote:*Raising the 60 member limit or creating a special merc status that doesn't add to the 60 member limit.
Adding a special raid quota for how many can raid in one guild at one time would keep "merc status" from unbalancing the current difficulty of the raids, if the quota is set to 60 of course.
I am suggeting to have a new prizes for players ( in guild power sqValor
SValor. KValor. CValor.

For example: ( guild a ) gets 1st in C valor ( guild a members get for example 4000 C valor

And maybe random C valor gear maybe some hero tokens maybe some gold shields

And maybe a transfer plate or enchantment that can be sold if i have similar one

Or maybe fluxes / essene. / refined essene ( gems maybe t5 gems you guys can think of something

Becuase of what i see is a guild takes all effort and dumps gold shield to make it top1

And reward is lame stuff atm like whats the use of having more power or having lvl 10+

Since guild favors stop at lvl 10 only 10 favors

So u guys can have like the top 3 or top 5. --- top 10 or even top 25 and u guys select a reward

Im just sharing my thoughts i hope rewards for weekly leaderboards become that nice

And even hero score more rewards :) thx guys thats just for the next pve update maybe this one i hope

Becuase im waiting for it soo long haha anyways thx agian :)
I really hope we can have in the guild tiers leaderboards gift for members like maybe valor random weapon / enchant
Maybe gold shields :) in this next update :)