First of all, let me start by saying I am a big fan of mercing and the friendly bonds it creates amongst many guilds in the game. However, I know you guys want to move this game more towards a guild focus and further away from the mercing idea. Back when there were guild races on raids, there was a big reason to not merc as you were working for your guild and had to be home when rewards were issued.
The suggestion came up recently in chat that while the prestige and guild xp is great and gives us bragging rights, it does nothing to further the improvement of individual guild members. The idea was to give some sort of tangible reward to all members of a guild that ranks in the top 3 of the leaderboards. Valor would be a great idea as it has the most benefit to players, but hero tokens would also be nice, and I doubt you would give out gs but of course, that would be good too. Personally, I would prefer valor.
I think a reward system like this will help to discourage mercing by most players in the top guilds anyway so they make sure they are home to get their rewards. Again, I am not against mercing because I think it is a great benefit in the game but if you must push us away from regular mercing, this may be a good solution. Many times mercs are the only reason why raids succeed and if a guild fails a raid, that can be extremely demoralizing and can make people not want to play anymore which I know you don't want. I think we need to find a happy medium with the mercing issue and I think adding some individual rewards for top performing guilds can help with this issue.
The suggestion came up recently in chat that while the prestige and guild xp is great and gives us bragging rights, it does nothing to further the improvement of individual guild members. The idea was to give some sort of tangible reward to all members of a guild that ranks in the top 3 of the leaderboards. Valor would be a great idea as it has the most benefit to players, but hero tokens would also be nice, and I doubt you would give out gs but of course, that would be good too. Personally, I would prefer valor.
I think a reward system like this will help to discourage mercing by most players in the top guilds anyway so they make sure they are home to get their rewards. Again, I am not against mercing because I think it is a great benefit in the game but if you must push us away from regular mercing, this may be a good solution. Many times mercs are the only reason why raids succeed and if a guild fails a raid, that can be extremely demoralizing and can make people not want to play anymore which I know you don't want. I think we need to find a happy medium with the mercing issue and I think adding some individual rewards for top performing guilds can help with this issue.