Book of Heroes

Justicar: the return of Stonewall

Vengeance and Frenzy are too similar. Get rid of one, and make the other work only with two-handed weapons, like Brutality. The deleted talent should be replaced with...

Stonewall [passive]
Your Dodge chance is reduced by 33%/66%/100% and added directly to your Block chance. You gain 1%/3%/5% Critical Resist and Knockback Resist.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Jan 12, 2013 12:20 pm
Marney wrote:Vengeance and Frenzy are too similar. Get rid of one, and make the other work only with two-handed weapons, like Brutality. The deleted talent should be replaced with...

I am still experimenting with Builds, but Venan's PvP philosophy appears to be "Everything Stacks". Examples of this are Potion of Crit, Piercing Strike, Critical Eye, Neurotoxin OR Potion of Power, Frenzy, Vengence. This appears to be translated into smaller values for each buff, but characters getting deadlier the longer the combat lasts.
I'm sure they stack - why wouldn't they? - but that's not the point, and I have no idea what PvP has to do with anything. I'd like a successful dodge to not penalize me by lowering my DPS (lost Stagger chance). Besides, how well could you dodge holding a heavy shield?
After further consideration and more playtesting, it's my opinion that Vengeance must be the skill to get the axe (figuratively speaking). There's just no getting around the fact that it's a bad skill. Against normal monsters, +15% damage doesn't even matter, and against bosses and elites, if you let them hit you three times you'll have a heck of a lot more problems to deal with than can be even slightly ameliorated by doing a little more damage. Exchanging blows with an elite Vile Behemoth simply isn't the best idea in the world.

And I'd really like to be able to get more out of my shield.
I have just gone through some of your previous post and I must say kudos to you. I especially liked the the elite and boss resistance to ensnare tough that should probably include icy grasp and stun to both for gameplay and logically, following your reasoning.

I would love to see a truly defensive passive ability in the Justicars tree as there are none today. I like the thought of transfering dodge to block and the synergies this would cause from enchantments so as you can see I'm pretty much onboard.
Marney wrote:There's just no getting around the fact that it's a bad skill. Against normal monsters, +15% damage doesn't even matter, and against bosses and elites, if you let them hit you three times you'll have a heck of a lot more problems to deal with than can be even slightly ameliorated by doing a little more damage.
Just like to point out that this applies to stagger as well. Since the best possible block rate is 31.2%, with heavy shield and maxed enchantments, means you will still be struck by 2.5 full damage attacks, taking in consideration one block at 50% reduction, for every 30% of extra damage. This doesn't sound like a very good deal to me but I must admit that I have no real experience since I have avoided it for this very reason.
Thanks for the compliments! :) I brought up elite/boss resistance/immunity to stuns in guildchat one night and it was roundly loathed, but the Diablo2 precedent remains a strong argument for it in my mind.
High_Auger wrote:Just like to point out that this applies to stagger as well. Since the best possible block rate is 31.2%, with heavy shield and maxed enchantments, means you will still be struck by 2.5 full damage attacks, taking in consideration one block at 50% reduction, for every 30% of extra damage.
A very good point. Possibly this new Stonewall should also include 1%/3%/5% Status Resist, and the Block chance and Block mitigation enchantments should be merged.

It's so easy to avoid ever being hit in this game as it is, abilities which proc on hit need to offer significant advantages to offset the damage and debuffs that will result.
Marney wrote:Stonewall [passive]
Your Dodge chance is reduced by 33%/66%/100% and added directly to your Block chance. You gain 1%/3%/5% Critical Resist and Knockback Resist.
Just occurred to me that this description is a bit unclear. I mean, of course, that the percentage by which Dodge is decreased should be the same percentage by which Block is increased.

Oh dear, that's muddled too. Okay, a simple example: your Dodge is 33% and you put two points in Stonewall. Your Dodge would now be 11% and your Block chance would get a +22% bonus. If you added another point, your Dodge chance would be 0% and your Block chance would get a bonus of +33%.

Another thought - some translation of the Melee rating, representing brute strength, could increase Block damage mitigation. The percentage of your Melee that would be considered would also increase with ranks in Stonewall.