Book of Heroes

Riposte Messes up skill rotation

I'm guessing riposte is part of the replacement for getting rid of the SW's haste buff in patch 1.5. While it is a nice skill, it messes up the typical skill rotation a player has because it completes the current action without decreasing ability cooldowns. I found a quote on another post and I hope it applies in this case...
Little_Mike wrote:
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:Does haste decrease the cooldown on abilities by the haste %, or is it half of the haste % to keep you from using spells more repeatedly than usual?

It will decrease the cooldowns on abilities by the haste %. The intent of this change is so that players do not have to keep changing their rotations due to haste changes. However, haste does NOT affect some abilities like Smoke Bomb and Seismic Slash.

To improve the current design, maybe a secondary effect similar to the following would help:
Riposte (Passive): Grants a 20%/35%/50% chance to decrease ability cooldown by the remaining cast time and immediately complete your current action after dodging an enemy attack.
Snapcast does the same thing. It may have been designed this way intentionally but it would be good for the ability descriptions to mention this if it was.

japster

ModeratorSun Jan 13, 2013 12:23 am
To reduce cooldowns and make it instant cast would severely make the skill overpowered.

How does it screw up rotations? You already unloaded maximum damage within a short time whenever snapcast or riposte activates. If it comes to a point where every single skill is on cooldown, just use a normal attack. It's never a bad thing if all your abilities are on cooldown due to frequent riposte/snapcast procs. It means you unloaded insane dps!
Just a quick example on how Riposte can actually hurt your damage output:

Lets say Player has skill A, skill B, and Normal attack

Skill A: 150 dmg, 1 second cast time, 1 second cooldown
Skill B: 150 dmg, 1 second cast time, 1 second cooldown
Autoattack: 100% dmg , 1 second cast time

Normally Player would rotate between Skill A and Skill B so you get a combat log like the following:
Hit with Skill A - 150 dmg; Total 150 dmg @ end of 1st second
Hit with Skill B - 150 dmg; Total 300 dmg @ end of 2nd second
Hit with Skill A - 150 dmg; Total 450 dmg @ end of 3rd second

Summary: 450dmg divided by 3 second = 150dmg/second with normal rotation

But when riposte proc at a "bad time":

Hit with Skill A - 150 dmg; Total 150 dmg @ end of 1st second
Hit with Skill B - 150 dmg (Riposte @ 0.9 scond); Total 300 dmg @ 1.9 second
Hit with Normal attack - 100 dmg; Total 400 dmg @ 2.9 second

Summary: 400dmg divided by 2.9 second = 138dmg/second with when a bad riposte proc.

TLDR: I have no doubt that having riposte increases the damage output on average. But there should be no reason why a player has to pray for a skill to proc; yet to not proc at a bad time. As for if it's overpowered, the developer can easily change the skill proc % (50% currently); they can play around with it until they find balance.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Jan 17, 2013 11:55 pm
Heat wrote:
TLDR: I have no doubt that having riposte increases the damage output on average. But there should be no reason why a player has to pray for a skill to proc; yet to not proc at a bad time.

You do not have to take Riposte. My current Shadow Walker does not have Riposte.

The new cool down on Reflexive Strike (25% combat speed of Basic Attack) and Acid Spray (50% combat speed of Basic Attack) make them a good compliment to Riposte.

Based on my analysis, Shadow Walkers appear to be based around quick, short Damage Over Time
Bj_DWR wrote:During a the last ten minutes of a Raid / Incursion, I start with a Minor Fire Rune (first action before anything else) for a total of 100% DPS in DOTs and a good chance at Poison Stack 1- 2 before Poison Cloud. With an Onslaught Boss you can even fire a second Minor Fire Rune after 3 seconds of combat for 120% DPS in DOTs. Major Fire Runes up this to 110% and 120% DPS in DOTs.DOTs and Shadow Walkers