I've played a Shadow Warrior since Book of Heroes first came out, and added the other classes since. I now have 4 toons, all of 14,300 might or higher, so they're all capable of accessing the highest current raid.
It feels like the Shadow Warrior is now the weakest of my toons for several reasons. First, my SW was built under pre-1.5 conditions, so he doesn't have much dodge. With no shield, he has the weakest armor of my toons, and thus takes the hardest hits. With the other classes, a dodge feels like a bonus. With the SW, failing to dodge feels like a failure (and boy does it hurt).
With all the classes you are trying to avoid taking too much damage while putting out enough to kill your opponents. This means killing as quickly as possible, either with a 2-h big basher, or 1-h with shield for faster but weaker hits. The Justicar's big shield can even work to his advantage with a nice stagger effect. If the SW goes for a light shield they must give up their class speciality, the second weapon, and still only block 12% of the time.
The surest way of not taking damage is delaying your opponent, either with a freeze/stun option (single foe only) or pushing back their timer so you can get another hit or two in and kill them before their blow lands. The mage has so many stun and pushback possibilities it's a glory of riches, and their single stun also does damage. OK, they're going to cut back on the ice-based delays a bit in the coming update, but they'll still be there. Time Void can be almost instantaneous (if you buy to level 3) and used from the get go, without the annoying 1 second delay that has been added to Seismic Slash and Smoke Bomb.
Both the Justicar's delays (Stunning Blow and Seismic Slash) do damage as well as delay, so they are doing double duty. Neither the SW's entangle nor smoke bomb have any damage attached, nd smoke bomb has such a long cooldown that it's a one shot per battle skill. With luck you can get a second entangle after smoke bombing, otherwise that's also a one hit skill.
So the SW has weaker delays than the other classes, but they hit faster to make up for it, right?
Wrong, most attacks are the same speed as the equivalents for other classes. Only Reflexive Strike is faster, but it's also very weak at 40/50/60% of normal damage, hits only one enemy, and has no bonus effects. Justicar's Radiant Light is a far better all round skill. It's slightly slower but still a fast attack, for more damage, hits multiple enemies, and clears out those annoying buffs. The top three bosses in the game all like to put up buffs, so Radiant Light is especially useful at this top level, though the Lord of Blades usually resists it - but he resists purge runes too, so the other classes are no better off against his defense buffs.
But the SW has the option of magic (poison) or physical attacks! Surely that's good?
They kind of have to. Some people build a physical only SW, but to my mind that's like buying a 4WD car and keeping it in 2WD mode all the time. You're ignoring 5 of the SW skills, including their only two group attacks. Maybe you can clear mobs with single hits, but group attacks are quicker. Maybe I need to build a melee-based SW to judge properly, but that means replacing a ton of gems first. If you want a physical skilled character, choose a Justicar. Having to cover both options of magic and melee does however can leave the SW caught between two stools, jack of all trades but master of none. The mage has no need of melee gems at all, while the Justicar can get away with a few to boost Radiant Light and Smite, while still concentrating on Melee for the bulk of his attacks.
The SW group attacks (Poison Cloud and Acid Spray) are both dependant on a good magic stat, and poison cloud does DOT (damage over time). That means that to have the full benefit of the attack you have to let your opponents live another 3 seconds. I don't want to hang around that long waiting to be hit again. I dislike DOT effect so much I've eliminated them from my other classes (only Wound has a built in DOT effect now). Apart from waiting for the DOT to take effect, they tend to hit the opponent at the most annoying times, breaking a carefully set up stun. Also for the SW group attacks you really have to use them both to get the proper benfit, and by the time you've done that, after throwing down a handful of caltrops, the enemy are right on you if they're not taken down. Higher level SWs may be able to clear swathes of enemies this way and not risk taking a couple of blows, but it's not working for me yet.
There are a couple of nice skills the SW has. Assassinate is a great mob clearer but useless against bosses, which reduces its appeal. Manoeuvre should make the SW very hard to hit, but for my poor old build it barely gets me to a tolerable level of dodge.
So to sum up, my SW is suffering from being built to suit a different set of conditions under 1.2 and then 1.4, and 1.5 is enough of a radical change that he is suffering. If I persevere I may eventually sort him out, but it's an uphill struggle. The other classes, at the same might, are doing well and only going to get better as I steadily replace t12 equipment with t14, and then start loading on those lvl 5 gems, and adding enchantments. My SW needs those higher level items just to catch up.
Do I have a suggested fix?
The SW skills could be adjusted. The SW could be just a little faster at everything than the other classes. There could be physical group attack. Poison could actually do damage again, not just reduce resistance to nature damage from other attacks. DOTs for all classes should not break a stun.
It feels like the Shadow Warrior is now the weakest of my toons for several reasons. First, my SW was built under pre-1.5 conditions, so he doesn't have much dodge. With no shield, he has the weakest armor of my toons, and thus takes the hardest hits. With the other classes, a dodge feels like a bonus. With the SW, failing to dodge feels like a failure (and boy does it hurt).
With all the classes you are trying to avoid taking too much damage while putting out enough to kill your opponents. This means killing as quickly as possible, either with a 2-h big basher, or 1-h with shield for faster but weaker hits. The Justicar's big shield can even work to his advantage with a nice stagger effect. If the SW goes for a light shield they must give up their class speciality, the second weapon, and still only block 12% of the time.
The surest way of not taking damage is delaying your opponent, either with a freeze/stun option (single foe only) or pushing back their timer so you can get another hit or two in and kill them before their blow lands. The mage has so many stun and pushback possibilities it's a glory of riches, and their single stun also does damage. OK, they're going to cut back on the ice-based delays a bit in the coming update, but they'll still be there. Time Void can be almost instantaneous (if you buy to level 3) and used from the get go, without the annoying 1 second delay that has been added to Seismic Slash and Smoke Bomb.
Both the Justicar's delays (Stunning Blow and Seismic Slash) do damage as well as delay, so they are doing double duty. Neither the SW's entangle nor smoke bomb have any damage attached, nd smoke bomb has such a long cooldown that it's a one shot per battle skill. With luck you can get a second entangle after smoke bombing, otherwise that's also a one hit skill.
So the SW has weaker delays than the other classes, but they hit faster to make up for it, right?
Wrong, most attacks are the same speed as the equivalents for other classes. Only Reflexive Strike is faster, but it's also very weak at 40/50/60% of normal damage, hits only one enemy, and has no bonus effects. Justicar's Radiant Light is a far better all round skill. It's slightly slower but still a fast attack, for more damage, hits multiple enemies, and clears out those annoying buffs. The top three bosses in the game all like to put up buffs, so Radiant Light is especially useful at this top level, though the Lord of Blades usually resists it - but he resists purge runes too, so the other classes are no better off against his defense buffs.
But the SW has the option of magic (poison) or physical attacks! Surely that's good?
They kind of have to. Some people build a physical only SW, but to my mind that's like buying a 4WD car and keeping it in 2WD mode all the time. You're ignoring 5 of the SW skills, including their only two group attacks. Maybe you can clear mobs with single hits, but group attacks are quicker. Maybe I need to build a melee-based SW to judge properly, but that means replacing a ton of gems first. If you want a physical skilled character, choose a Justicar. Having to cover both options of magic and melee does however can leave the SW caught between two stools, jack of all trades but master of none. The mage has no need of melee gems at all, while the Justicar can get away with a few to boost Radiant Light and Smite, while still concentrating on Melee for the bulk of his attacks.
The SW group attacks (Poison Cloud and Acid Spray) are both dependant on a good magic stat, and poison cloud does DOT (damage over time). That means that to have the full benefit of the attack you have to let your opponents live another 3 seconds. I don't want to hang around that long waiting to be hit again. I dislike DOT effect so much I've eliminated them from my other classes (only Wound has a built in DOT effect now). Apart from waiting for the DOT to take effect, they tend to hit the opponent at the most annoying times, breaking a carefully set up stun. Also for the SW group attacks you really have to use them both to get the proper benfit, and by the time you've done that, after throwing down a handful of caltrops, the enemy are right on you if they're not taken down. Higher level SWs may be able to clear swathes of enemies this way and not risk taking a couple of blows, but it's not working for me yet.
There are a couple of nice skills the SW has. Assassinate is a great mob clearer but useless against bosses, which reduces its appeal. Manoeuvre should make the SW very hard to hit, but for my poor old build it barely gets me to a tolerable level of dodge.
So to sum up, my SW is suffering from being built to suit a different set of conditions under 1.2 and then 1.4, and 1.5 is enough of a radical change that he is suffering. If I persevere I may eventually sort him out, but it's an uphill struggle. The other classes, at the same might, are doing well and only going to get better as I steadily replace t12 equipment with t14, and then start loading on those lvl 5 gems, and adding enchantments. My SW needs those higher level items just to catch up.
Do I have a suggested fix?
The SW skills could be adjusted. The SW could be just a little faster at everything than the other classes. There could be physical group attack. Poison could actually do damage again, not just reduce resistance to nature damage from other attacks. DOTs for all classes should not break a stun.