Book of Heroes

Black Market problems

Please reconsider the items sold in the Black Market. I don't object to flux and essence, or energy potions; the first two are obtained through solo play and their availability in the Black Market is merely a time saver. Energy potions offer a better rate of shield to energy conversion and are also acceptable in limited quantities. Transfer plates are actually a good starter item for people who have just started to experiment with enchantments. The energy enchantment recipe is such a long-term investment, and requires such a specialized style of play to make it worthwhile in the first place, that it almost makes sense to offer it only in the Black Market. All these are fine.

However, I must take strong exception to t5 gems and PvP-relevant enchantments being made available through the Black Market. This is a clear-cut case of a pay-to-win mechanic, and it's unfair to those of us who have been earning valor to buy t5 gems over many raids, often saving up CV before taking a good run at the leaderboard over the course of a week, winning a commerce elixir, and buying a few t5 gems together for a discount. That sort of thing takes a significant investment of time and effort, but now you're offering t5 gems directly for about $10.

That cheapens what people have only recently earned. The option to flat-out purchase top-of-the-line gems should not exist at all, no matter how limited the quantity, selection, or availability.

Moreover, +damage enchantments will obviously be the most advantageous magic enchantment in PvP. That they have been made available (thus far) exclusively through the Black Market is also distasteful, as this will inevitably create a clear separation between the haves and the have-nots when PvP is implemented. Given the time it takes to empower enchantments, this is a problem now.

I won't indulge in baseless speculation about profit margins or accuse Venan of trying to gouge people, as others have done in previous threads, and I'd appreciate it if any replies in this thread also observe some decorum. But this is a seriously flawed gameplay mechanic, and it needs to be addressed.
The haves are going to have two sets of armor - one for PvP and one for normal use. The mage will have ice or fire damage on the PvP and the normal use set will have Luck (most likely). Heck, they may even go to a third set with energy that they put on when recharging.

They can offer top of the line gems as long as they are only health gems. :lol:
OK, Im still thinking about +damage enchantments, but strongly disagree about gems.

T5 gems: I feel your pain, seriously, but.. We got t4 gems on sale for GS. And oh boy, it is quite unfair to those of us who have been earning valor to buy t4 gems over many raids, often saving up KV before taking a good run at the leaderboard over the course of a week, winning a commerce elixir, and buying a few t4 gems together for a discount.
I am not kidding. It took me ages to gather my t4 gem collection, but so what?
t4 gems became available for gold shields after many months and two major updates. t5 gems were just introduced. t4 gems are also not the best anymore; t5 gems are. t4 gems were not available for anything but valor when they were the best.

The comparison is invalid.
Bbbb wrote:They can offer top of the line gems as long as they are only health gems. :lol:
Heh. That would be perfect.
I had not thought of PvP when considering the black market, but the points are valid in that PvP will now be more strongly correlated with GS spent than hours played. Before the market came along, playing 4 hrs per day was more efficient for building powerful toons than playing 30 mins per day plus $10 of GS per day. With t5 gems in the market, this may tilt the balance (especially at the mid level range, 15 to 20).

Since I do not intend to partake in PvP (I enjoy the cooperative play) my complaint is the price point of recipes. At 100-ish GS, I was interested in the magic damage-boosting recipes. But now that I see them at 250 GS, I will let them go. I understand that overpricing to get the big-spenders, then reducing to get the mid-spenders maximizes revenue in the short term, you may annoy your most loyal fans if you do this too much.

I like how Venan got feedback on the price-point for barbershop name changes (and reduced the price before the patch). Something similar on recipe prices may have netted more GS spending for Venan, without the need for a price change later.

Again, since I am not planning to play PvP, the price-point might be right for that crowd, just not for me as a non-PvP-er.
GS always allowed you to speed up your progress and I don't see how this is a new problem.
First, at this point of time, you can reach 20k might without a single level 5 gem, which already puts you in the top 50. So buying level 5 gems (which are not cheap!) won't make a big difference.
Second, for the price of one gem, you can already get a major elixir (haste, power, whatever) which will give you a much bigger advantage in PvP.

So I wouldn't worry too much. We don't know what will be allowed in PvP, and by the time it arrives, level 5 gems may not be that novel.
Bbbb wrote:I realized something. Health gems may not be completely useless in PvP.... :o
lol :D
Romain wrote:GS always allowed you to speed up your progress and I don't see how this is a new problem.
Speeding up your progress would still require you to play. Buying the rewards that are earned through play with a simple in-app purchase does not require you to play. Spending gold shields for extra energy in a raid is entirely different.
Romain wrote:First, at this point of time, you can reach 20k might without a single level 5 gem, which already puts you in the top 50.
The people in the top 50 have actually played the game, so I'm not sure what point you're making.
Romain wrote:So buying level 5 gems (which are not cheap!) won't make a big difference.
$10 is cheap, compared to what it costs in terms of time spent earning 2400-3000 CV in raids.
Romain wrote:Second, for the price of one gem, you can already get a major elixir (haste, power, whatever) which will give you a much bigger advantage in PvP.
My complaint about the t5 gems being in the Black Market is separate from my complaint about the implications of Black Market exclusive enchantments for PvP. That said, it's sort of absurd to imagine that people playing with elixirs in effect will ever compete in PvP with people who don't have elixirs in effect; the advantages they give are just too enormous. There would be have to be separate divisions, or elixirs might simply be temporarily nullified in PvP.
Romain wrote:We don't know what will be allowed in PvP, and by the time it arrives, level 5 gems may not be that novel.
That part is true enough.

However, by the time PvP does get here, some people will have an insuperable advantage if +damage enchantments remain exclusive to the Black Market.

Little_Mike

Site AdminWed Feb 6, 2013 9:22 pm
Thanks for the feedback. Actually one thing we are going to change in the Black Market is we are going to limit it to 1 Tier 5 gem per instance instead of a possible 3. At the current rate, it would take at best 20 weeks for someone to fully deck themselves out with full Tier 5 gems. You also have to consider that the gem itself is random, so it will take a lot longer to pay to get the exact gems you want. During that time period, most likely that player would have done raids in the meantime, so I highly doubt someone will buy themselves up all the way with the best Tier 5 gems. We want to offer players some exclusive items that are only obtainable through the Black Market, and we believe that only having 1 Tier 5 Gem at the Black Market at a given time will allow players to power up if they choose to do so while also making it so you can't necessarily pay to win in the game.

As for the Damage Bonus enchantments, for now they are going to be a Black Market only exclusive, however this may change in the future, no guarantees. We offer many ways to receive Gold Shields for free either through offers or drops in the game. We feel that if a player wants the enchantments, there are plenty of different opportunities to allow them to purchase it.