And as anticipated, we missed Gold completion by 1 minute, 52 seconds after nearly an hour of downtime. Almost as bad as the last raid we missed gold by only 32 seconds. And still Venan has not made us whole. Why should it take a GM to initiate the request on behalf of the guild? Anyone should be able to initiate the report and have the issue addressed. How can they expect the GM to be the one to write up the report about the incident when the GM wasn't present for the raid?
I'm sorry for the downtime, we worked on bringing the servers back online as fast as we could. We are currently investigating what caused this downtime. Various issues were fixed earlier this week but apparently there are some more things we need to work out. I can say a whole bunch of other things but they would only be excuses. All I can say is we we are working our hardest on resolving the issues.
And I know this will be brought up, so I'll just be blunt about this. We cannot offer compensation for any raids due to these outages. We don't have the resources to do this. What we can do is compensate individual players who have spent Gold Shields or Energy Potions in a raid that was affected by the downtime.
Please send us an in-game customer support email with the following information:
1) What raid did you run?
2) What guild did you run it with?
3) What time did the raid start in GMT?
We will work on compensating your character as soon as we can. I'm sorry for the inconvenience.
Technical problems happen. But what are we supposed to do if proper compensation cannot be made for the ill effects of them occurring? I don't feel confident running raids at the moment knowing that we could lose access to the game without warning.
I am unsure I want to play as I normally would right now.
Mike, I know you have always provided excellent customer service and that is a major reason why so many people are happy with this game. I have even heard stories from people who would have quit the game if you did not provide 100% satisfaction to thier issues, and people have even made their first and only GS purcahses after a satisfactory customer service experience with you.
That being said, not being able to compensate the many guilds who had failed raids, or lost gold rewards due to the hour long server crash tonight (not to mention the fails earlier in the week), is just not acceptable. Now, I know from past experience dealing with you on similar issues, there are a lot of reasons why across the board compensation of missed bonus rewards or rewards lost due to failed raids just cannot be automatically awarded by the system. There is no magic button to fix this problem and push out a bunch of valor and HT and the man hours required to manually calculate this would probably bankrupt the company.
But at the same time, hundreds if not thousands of players will be affected by this, many on multiple toons. Some players shielded during raids, and some shielded heavily. Refunding them is just common sense. But what about the vast majority of us who only invested our time and effort and not something tangible for you to refund? Not to mention the extreme frustration we are ALL feeling right now. There has to be some kind of gesture extended to make this right for everyone else. You do NOT want to leave a bad taste in everyone's mouth over this without sweetening the pot afterwards, so to speak. I know from personal experience that failed raids can TREMENDOUSLY demoralize a guild, and players have actually quit playing this game after suffering a failed raid.
Since giving back valor and HT is not very easy to do, I propose that there be a blanket reward issued to everyone who was playing at the time of the crash. Hopefully these logs can be pulled easily. Send everyone via mail a stack of energy pots to compensate for the energy lost in failed raids, or to make up for missed gold rewards, etc. A 5 hour raid plus 42 energy at the beginning is the equivalent of about 8 energy pots worth of energy. Now while this may sound like a lot, it is not GS that can be used to buy other gear/items and it can only be used to play the game longer which is obviously what you guys want. If at all possible, don't make this dependent on players sending a support mail because not everyone will take the time (or even know how to do it) and you do not want to be inundated by thousands of emails.
The most important thing to take away from this post is that Venan MUST do something to make the thousands of upset players happy again. Make a good show of effort in respose to this, and the several other unfortunate incidents this week and you will win over the hearts of the people who will in turn become even more dedicated to playing your game. You have a golden opportunity to turn a major fail into a major win.
What will you do??
The problem is that it's a slippery slope. My guild failed to start their scheduled raid because the server crashed 5mins before time. I would wish for compensation for that too, because my members were all willing and ready to raid! I mean if you pull the logs...you can see that we've always raided at that time for the last month successfully at gold...
Bottom line is...the intangible frustration is a tricky thing to deal with, and demanding for the specific losses is extremely speculative. IMO, it would be good if Venan sends out an apology to the entire server with a large energy pot or two, at the very least, as a sign of goodwill to all gamers. Surely with an hour of downtime (and not counting the previous few outages), everybody deserves to be compensated for that.
And whatever you do, you need to post your message of response in the game news feed for everyone to see. I guarantee the vast majority of players will never see the forums, let alone this post. You especially need to post the info there about what information people should submit to you to claim a refund of their wasted shields/pots. And tell them where to find the tech support option as well. The noobs need help

TCG_japster wrote:The problem is that it's a slippery slope. My guild failed to start their scheduled raid because the server crashed 5mins before time. I would wish for compensation for that too, because my members were all willing and ready to raid! I mean if you pull the logs...you can see that we've always raided at that time for the last month successfully at gold...
Bottom line is...the intangible frustration is a tricky thing to deal with, and demanding for the specific losses is extremely speculative. IMO, it would be good if Venan sends out an apology to the entire server with a large energy pot or two, at the very least, as a sign of goodwill to all gamers. Surely with an hour of downtime (and not counting the previous few outages), everybody deserves to be compensated for that.
A pot or two would just be the bare minimum for the frustration we all feel each time the servers crash. Like I mentioned above, I feel 8 pots would be fair as teh equivalent of what would be spent in a full 5 hour raid.
But as a matter of course going forward, I propose that everytime there is a hiccup in the server, or full blown crash, every player and every toon in the entire game should be awarded with 1 energy pot for every 15 minute increment of time the servers are down. Not only is this incentive to minimize downtime even further (though I have no doubt you do not need ANY incentive to minimize this), but you also will be faced with potential revenue reduction down the road due to all the new energy you are awarding to the player base. If you set a policy that will hit you in the wallet if performance is sub-par, maybe that additional motivation will drive Venan to ensure this never happens again. But at the very least, you will show the entire player base that you feel their pain and are willing to make amends in any way you can, even if it is just through energy pots. I can't emphasize enough the importance of keeping your players happy.
We will think about doing something special for you guys after we get our server kinks out of the way, but I will need to talk to the rest of the team about it. No promises, but I understand where you guys are coming from, and believe me, if I could, I would just push a button and give people stuff, because that would be an easy way of resolving these issues.
Thanks Mike! I know you always have our best interests in mind and you have always excelled at providing awesome customer service! We shall eagerly await Lord Venan's response on the issue. In the meantime, get those programmers working on a fancy new "+8 e pot" button! That way you can be ready to respond immediately the next time this happens and instantly quash the frustrations of the players before they fester into fury!
By the way, I am one of the programmers. That's how small of a company we are lol. Most likely I will be the one implementing this.