Book of Heroes

SW - magic or melee damage?

Was thinking of making a poison SW, but I don't know if poison damage is based on melee dps or magic dps. The damage type is poison but the ability text all says weapon damage so I can't tell which would boost the damage. Does anyone know?
Attack damage is based on both the weapon damage + either the melee or magic bonus.

Weapon damage is determined by the type and tier of weapon.

Poison attacks (e.g. poison cloud) use the magic bonus and physical attacks (e.g. piercing strike) use the melee bonus.

This applies to justicars aswell with the spirit attacks (smite and radiant light) also using the magic bonus.

People have varying opinions on this but for my sw and justic I use a mix of both physical and magical attacks in my kill routines.
In 1.4, I had better balance between magic and melee on both classes. However, in 1.5, I have found that the melee is much more important for the Justicar than it used to be. One reason is that Smite doubles the weapon damage so the bonus is less important and radiant light is just a weak attack.

The 1.4 SW had the problem that you just couldn't screw it up it was so powerful. In 1.5, you need to pump the poison/magic for mob fighting since you have no melee group attacks. You can do the melee SW build - I haven't done it but I assume mob killing is slow.
Actually, a physical 1.5 SW has a forgotten crowd control tool - the regular attack, which passes on the 2nd target provided the first one is dispatched (I know, few of us ever touched this button outside onslaught before). Also, no matter how laughable Dual Wield looks at first, it may work wonders for predominantly physical builds. Add Assassinate to that and you get your SW who deals with mobs easily..

I am slowly switching from a 2/3 magic / 1/3 melee to a 50/50 arrangement...
I have an all physical build and it's not bad at all. Caltrops 3 and Assassinate 3 and Dual Wield 3 are actually pretty good for groups and you don't have to increase magic at all.
Seems like poison SW should take magic, assassinate SW should take melee, hybrid should mix.

My main abilities will be toxic blade, PC, and Acid Spray. Going caltrops as well but using that or slow :)
You want the assassinate skill no matter which way you go.

Caltrops is essential at low mights. I've reached the point with hybrid slighted towards poison build where I only use it if I have stunned a boss. Not worthless but if it went away, I wouldn't miss it.
Caltrops is also useful for a high-level physical SW. Area attack with decent damage over time but most important, half enemy dodge chance. (Who needs Accuracy enchantment?)
I would think assassinate would be worthless on a dot build. Not like you kill things with abilities. That said, can't wait for the tier 3 abilities :)