Book of Heroes

SW Urgency scales negatively

I don't really understand why Urgency procs on hit. Shouldn't it proc on Dodge? Thing is, the better your dodge gets, the worse Urgency becomes. This is backwards. Your abilities shouldn't become useless as your stats improve. I think Urgency should instead proc on Dodge so it scales with the dodge stat and goes well with Maneuver. Like Riposte. That would even make a high dodge build more viable and it fits in better with the SW theme I think. And if it procs on dodge, increase chance to proc as well so it doesn't happen so seldom it isn't worth it.
You get hit and you get scared and move faster. That's the idea. We already have riposte for dodge.

There are three separate SW builds:

1. Magic/Poison
2. Melee
3. Dodge

Urgency is a useful skill for the first two builds.

Venan, please leave it the way it is.
The conceptual justification for Urgency and its mechanical separation from Riposte are both perfectly sound, but I can see the problem Mcluvin has with it as well.

Dodge isn't a separate build for 'walkers; it and its associated skills (Riposte and Maneuver) function perfectly in conjunction with the stat focus and skills of melee, magic, and hybrid 'walkers, and no 'walker has the natural armor of a justicar. A proc on hit skill is indeed an oddity in the class.

I'm not saying it should be changed, necessarily, but it does make me pause. I'd probably buff it if anything.
Bbbb wrote:You get hit and you get scared and move faster. That's the idea. We already have riposte for dodge.

There are three separate SW builds:

1. Magic/Poison
2. Melee
3. Dodge

Urgency is a useful skill for the first two builds.

Venan, please leave it the way it is.

You don't need a Dodge build to want Maneuver. What SW wouldn't want more dodge? Oh yeah, ones with Urgency.

I understand that my suggestion would basically make it a second Riposte and that's a good point. Instead, maybe change the nature of the mechanic entirely.

Since we already have a proc off Dodge, and making something proc off something we try to avoid with our stats is just silly, just make a stacking haste buff proc off dots. Call it Impatience or something and every dot tick has a chance to increase haste by 5% per stack. That way it works well with our two dots and all builds would want it since it scales positively. In fact it scales exponentially because of the way haste works.
I like the proc off of DoTs idea. That would be interesting.

Another fun way to go would be proc off of Crits. that just feels more shadow walkery then getting hit.

my idea for an interesting redesign to the skill would be something like: 50% chance on critical attack to increase Dodge chance for the next attack by 25%.

It would play nicely with all the dodge and crit abilities
I can see that getting a little overpowered though.

My crit rate when fully beefed up is virtually 100% (20% from Critical Eye 3 + 25% from Piercing Strike + 40-55% from everything else like guild bonuses, training, gems, and something else I'm forgetting)

Meaning since I attack twice each turn (Main hand, off hand), there's a good shot my dodge will get that +25% boost... and my dodge already is pushing 60-65% with its bonuses... we're talking upwards of 90% dodge rate, which will set off the whole riposte/assassinate chain. Kinda makes it a little weird if I always crit and almost never get hit... I feel like dodge and crit bonuses are as high as they need to be.


But I definitely agree that Urgency could use a little tune up. Maybe something haste-based?
Overpowered - hardly. In 1.5, almost everybody agrees that SW is the weakest class (not saying bad) at the higher levels. In 1.4, there was a 100% crit and crit power had an extra 100% applied to it - that was overpowered. In that version, you just needed to pump haste and you were set.

You are overestimating in several ways. Your crit numbers only apply to one attack (Piercing Strike) that is a single attack. Then you switch to talking about the basic attack when you talk about dodge.