Book of Heroes

Justicar - heavy vs light shield · page 2

GioRGiO wrote:Pre 1.5: use shield. Post 1.5: get a 2h ASAP

Yup, sad but true. I finally gave up on 1H Justicar and it made all the difference in the world.
Bbbb wrote:
GioRGiO wrote:Pre 1.5: use shield. Post 1.5: get a 2h ASAP

Yup, sad but true. I finally gave up on 1H Justicar and it made all the difference in the world.


Could you expand on the wonderfulness of the 2-h approach 4b and GioRGiO?

I'm still using 1-H & large shield, but one of my Justis has no enchants invested in 1-h bonus so I could switch him to 2-h without major loss, and intend to eventually.

I get that 2-hand kills quicker, at the expense of taking more damage. Is there more to it? My Justicars already take more hits than my Mage or Shadow Warrior, and even if those hits do less damage on average (due to blocks) they drink potions faster.

I don't need to kill quickly (in real time), I'm never going to top the rpp tables with 25k+ because I don't have the real life cash to invest in all the necessary shields or energy potions. I'm happy to chug along in the middle of the pack getting 3-6k per raid, just attending more raids.

It's the curse of the Justicar that you have to build your 1-h or 2-h choice into your skills, so you can't switch frequently. With my Mage I will eventually have a staff for mobs and my usual sword & board for bosses, and won't need to adjust my skill set in between.
Your Justicar sounds exactly like mine was a few weeks ago. It would kill slow, take quite a bit of damage. The mob rotation was usually:

Heroic Will, Seismic, Radiant Light, Cleave, Radiant Light again - sometimes they wouldn't even kill the whole mob

With 2H, I do:

Heroic Will, Seismic, Cleave - it usually goes down at this point. If it doesn't, Radiant Light will almost always finish it.

Don't really notice any difference on mobs causing me damage.

The hardest thing about bosses are adjusting to the new action times. The trade off is that I sometimes 2 hit kill bosses (if crits hit). If I don't crit, it is harder to get the stuns in so I use break runes more often than before (though I usually only do them for Behemoth Bash and Decapitate). I don't know that I get hit any more often since I kill them quicker though the hits do more damage. I'm still a net potion seller.

The most important point is that I had the highest might 1H sword Justicar in BoH and have always been a 1H over 2H fan, but after trying 2H in 1.5, there is just no comparison. The only time I prefer 1H is against the Behemoth but since they are intermixed with mobs that are easier to kill with 2H, you can't prepare for it.

Now, my Justicar (as is my Mage) is at the point that I don't think investing in them will make major noticeable improvements (kinda like where we all were with 1.4) so I can focusing my development on my SW though it already has the highest might.

Final Note: I have played my mage both ways in 1.5 and the difference there is marginal.
Yep totally agree with Bbbb, I was always a 1h+shield pre1.5 and resisted the swap to a 2h for ages.

Since swapping to a 2h i can easily kill mobs in less than half the moves it took with a 1h (Killing faster reduces damage taken because they can't hit you back).

The main thing you need to watch out for is your haste. After switching to a 2h I added several more haste gems into my build and now I hardly take any damage while killing all enemies in 1-4 moves.

Bosses take alittle longer but can still kill in 2-5 moves and with stun, seismic and break runes you can almost always avoid taking any damage.
2 handed weapon all the way, as mentioned earlier you only need 4 gems to boost your stats the same as 8 would do with a weapon/shield combo. Once your Jusicar has the combination of Level 3 Stagger/Backswing and the bleed stacking one then why would you need a shield?!!? :D
Thanks for the replies and ideas guys. It's gonna take a little while to earn the captain's valor, but I'll switch one of my Justis (Porthos if you see him around) over to 2-h when I can and respec, and see for myself.

The other (dArtagnan) already has 7 points of 1-h damage bonus enchants, and it'll take some personal experience of the wonderfulness of 2-h to convince me to throw that away.

The big difference right now is that I immediately respecced both Justis to include a spot of Heroic Will. I had thrown that out in disgust when 1.5 zapped the old skill system, because I felt I no longer needed it. I use to use it in long boss fights, and that was it. Now I see the real purpose is to 'fix' Seismic Slash after they nixed it with that annoying 1 second delay. I took the point from Vengeance, which only gave me 5% bonus 20% of the time... less than the enchants I have all the time, and usually against a damaged opponent anyway when the extra 5% might be overkill.


Also Bbbb, thanks for your tip on WM 1-h vs 2-h. My 1-h sword WM works so well now I wasn't convinced the build could be improved with a staff, and if you say it doesn't make much difference I'll be putting my earned valor into gems for a good long time.
Musketeer wrote:
Also Bbbb, thanks for your tip on WM 1-h vs 2-h. My 1-h sword WM works so well now I wasn't convinced the build could be improved with a staff, and if you say it doesn't make much difference I'll be putting my earned valor into gems for a good long time.

I did switch, but it was for a pretty lame reason. First, I tried the 2H Mage after the huge difference it made on the Justie. Didn't see much of a difference on the Mage, but I had the 2H recipe and not the 1H so that made up my mind to stay 2H. I've enchanted my butt off (3 x level 4) now.
They should really do something to make shield bearers more effective.. at least a Shield bash skill or something.. you should also be able to increase your blocking ability through gems rather than the enchant you have to farm for and then take lots of mats to increase.. I have been too stubborn to switch to a 2 hander.. I want my KNIGHT to be a sword and shield tank type.. can take lots of damage and kill effectively as well..
Even at 9k might, my Justi junior can often defeat the dungeon LoB taking 0 or 1 hit, using a t10 2-hand sword. The combo of brutal strike with knockback and heroic will halving the time of the next attack makes the justi superior.

Brutal 3, Stun 1, Cleave 3, Seismic 3, Brutal 3, Heroic 2, Brutal 3, (Smite 1 or Rad Light 3 if time permits,) Stun 1, Cleave 3, (Brutal 3 or Rad Light if Seismic on CD,) Seismic 3, Brutal 3, Wound 2.