Book of Heroes

New BoH Icon

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed May 23, 2012 10:06 am
From CJ, my wife, who holds a MBA degree:
"-
While the new icon gets across the idea of the game better (good), it doesn't have the grab-your-eye appeal of the old one (bad) - it takes a second to figure out it's a guy with a sword (one hopes), and a second is all you have. Plus, he looks scary. Again, good for the game, but not inviting.

My 2 cents.
-"

Note: I still see the old icon in the Apple App Store (currently Version 1.2). I have only seen the new icon on Facebook and Game Center.

Lord_Venan

Site AdminWed May 23, 2012 11:51 am
Thanks for the feedback!

There is no turning back once it hits Apple, but we'll keep that in mind for our next client update. Coming up with icons is definitely a tough call since it is so subjective but the feedback is welcome. Our plan is to keep updating these over time so we'll look to lighten it up in the future should this prove too off-putting.
I admit, I kind of like the new icon. I haven't played BoH for two months because of the limited quests after The Frozen Vale. After installing the update and viewing the icon of Daedalus, I gave the game another chance and was not disappointed.

I don't know if it was the icon itself or the fact the icon changed from its predecessor but the new icon encouraged me to play again.
The old one was more eye catching, which did cause some negative reaction from the ladies I knew who saw it.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Jul 16, 2012 1:50 pm
Lord_Venan wrote:
Coming up with icons is definitely a tough call since it is so subjective but the feedback is welcome.

My wife, the marketing maven, opined that the Basilisk from Dragonmoor would be a good BoH Icon. (Typist's Note: It's a warm eye-catching color, non-BoH players would think "ooo, dragon!", and it's a fantastic piece of art.)

I suggest my favorite art Vallus (Typsist's Note: doesn't look like a dragon at first glance, cool color - still awesome art, though) and my favorite equipment Tier 10 Justicar armor (Typists's Note: Who would wear it? Just the helm or waist up? BoH icons have too few pixels; would read as a neutral color).

-BjofCJandBj (with help from She-who-wants-Armored-Bunny-Slippers)
I admit I hated the bosomy lady icon. The golden star was OK, but didn't really say much about the game content.

It took me quite a while to realise who buxom gal was, and that it was an actual game character, as I'd done all her quests ages ago and hadn't seen her since.

Daedalus is a central character to the whole game storyline, and is the guy who gives the daily bounties that were all I was playing for a long time. He's a great improvement over the buxom lady in terms of recognizability.

On the subject of icons, I find it confusing that the same icon is used for different effects such as Mage's Time Void and Justicar's Heroic Will, while different icons are used for the same effect (e.g. Mage's Hasten spell is two feet in a puddle, Shadow Walker has a blue running man for Dark Lunge which is in effect another hasten spell, while the effect icon for both is a golden wing). Could these anomalies be addressed in a future patch, and at least have the active effect icon match the spell icon? For those of us running multiple characters it causes confusion in the heat of battle.
I don't have an opinion on the buxom lady icon. In fact I barely noticed her (maybe that says something about the graphical style, or just about my lack of inclination to pay attention to game art).

But I think some kind of dragon-based icon might work well, because it's always cool to be able to slay dragons. I mean, Skyrim! There's a lot done right in Bethesda's Skyrim trailer, and I was a fan of the Elder Scrolls since Daggerfall, but there's just a special fascination with being able to slay actual dragons.

Even if a card-based game like BoH isn't the same as a 3D computer game like Skyrim or an MMO like World of Warcraft.

As for dragon colours, I think a warm red colour will probably "sell" better than a colder ice-based colour.
I agree with all of Pfaff's points, especially his request regarding a normalization of the spell icons/buff/debuff indicators, though personally, I don't like Daedalus. He just rubs me the wrong way. I'm not a fan of the spinny sun thing either, though that may just be an associative dislike due to lag, rather than an aesthetic one. :)