Book of Heroes

Some SW talk · page 2

Bbbb wrote:I would dump Manuever. Reduce Caltrops or Smoke Bomb. Then use the points of PS and/or Urgency.

I'm with you Bbbb. I just recently got to thinking that while dodge and riposte seemed like a great idea, really it just wasn't. Speed and damage output are key for me. So I dumped maneuver and riposte. Picked up 1 point in corrosive blades. Upped piercing to 3 I think, 1 for reflexive, 3 for poising cloud and acid spray. 3 to neurotoxin and urgency. 3 for toxic blade. 1 to ensnare and caltrops and 1 in critical eye, 1 to smoke bomb and dual wield (wish I'd put 2 in smoke bomb instead) and 3 to assassinate - best skill!

For me this works really well. Urgency is at its best when you don't dodge so that allows you to regain 6 ability points which allows me to be pretty effective with magic and melee and gets back a couple if gem slots (from dodge gems) as a bonus.
mirnes wrote:Hi, wanted to take this thread up again and see if we can get some discussion regarding gems.

I was looking at some possible builds and was wondering what yellow gem would be best for a SW?

Considering that SW get allot of crit through dots and abilities, maybe Dodge would be best Gem?

Anyone thing different and why?

Primarily I'd say Haste only until you reach the 40% soft cap. Then 40% cap on dodge or crit, depending on your play style.
I wonder if AoE poison is really more useful.. My current build is

Dual Wield 3
Assassinate 3
Critical Eye 3
Maneuver 3
Ensnare 1
Caltrops 1

Will add later,

Piercing Strike 3
Caltrops 3
Riposte 3
Smoke Screen 3
Reflexive Strike 3

Well as a newcomer, this is my current build, and so far quite good. Is there something wrong with my build? Or poison AoE is just have the highest dmg output for SW so almost everyone choose it?
Everyone seem to say go with red magic gems as nature sw. But why is that? All our attacks are based on weapon dmg. So if 10 magic modifier equals the same dmg as 10 melee modifier why choose magic. It would give less options if you want to try physical sw.
I'm no expert in the theory craft of bof but I guess dmg output is based on melee main hand dmg + magic modifier? So if you up the melee dmg you still output the same dmg in the end as with magic gems?

Would be really nice to hear from someone with more experience than me on this subject.

Also t12 vs t10 main weapon worth the upgrade only bc of dmg? I have rubbish gems in main hand so ill get more might from upgrading other pieces.


Sincerely
Lappi
heres my current build at the moment and i dont have any problems dealing with any mobs or bosses at present.

Toxic Blade 3 (kills of individuals quickly)
Caltrops 3 (slows the enemy and cuts dodge chance, also a chance of applying poisoned before i attack with TB/PC)
Ensnare 1 (just to break up attacks)
Dual Wield 0 (i never use basic attack)

Piercing Strike 0 (no point getting high melee stats as using mostly magic so toxic blade is more damaging)
Poison Cloud 3 (takes care of mobs easily)
Maneuver 0 (hardly get hit anyway and if i do i have plenty of found potions)
Assassinate 3 (basically get a free attack here and there)

Reflexive Strike 2 (mainly to use up points and incase i need a cheeky quick hit)
Acid Spray 3 (mainly use on mobs if for some reason i can't use poison cloud ie i have been slowed down)
Critical Eye 0 (i dont use melee, bar caltrops or reflexive so no major benefit having it)
Reposte 0 (i have a low dodge % see maneuver)

Smoke Bomb 3 (lets me get some extra time if needed and also allows me to use toxic blade/poison cloud a 2nd time)
Neurotoxin 3 (my targets are always poisoned see corrosive blades, so higher chance of getting a crit)
Urgency 3 (helps get the job done quicker)
Corrosive Blades 3 (gives all my attacks the chance of applying poisoned, always a good thing)
I keep seeing people say to reduce caltrops, especially for magic builds. I'm just not getting it. Caltrops delivers (at L3) 120% DOT over 3 seconds. It throws fast enough that it's almost like a free hit. (I know, TANSTAFL). In addition it slows enemies by 25%, and halves their dodge chance. I agree that for magic the dodge reduction doesn't buy me much, but slowing them down to me seems like a good thing. Especially since my haste is still below 30%.

Where is my thinking flawed?

Denrael
Denrael wrote:I keep seeing people say to reduce caltrops, especially for magic builds. I'm just not getting it. Caltrops delivers (at L3) 120% DOT over 3 seconds. It throws fast enough that it's almost like a free hit. (I know, TANSTAFL). In addition it slows enemies by 25%, and halves their dodge chance. I agree that for magic the dodge reduction doesn't buy me much, but slowing them down to me seems like a good thing. Especially since my haste is still below 30%.

Where is my thinking flawed?

Denrael

3 seconds is extremely slow for a nature shadow warrior to the point where it'll nearly never proc at high might.

GK i one hit (@ 22k might) and VG i'm two hitting. Both are under a second. The time spent tossing out caltrops and then waiting for the dot just doesn't end up helping. Only place I've used caltrops is karnak... and even there... its more of a... meh... it has it's uses, but its not great.
So it's useful perhaps for the quick poison, but not for the DOT. Ok, that makes sense. That's always why others like Tiffy have said to drop it to 1 or 2. I SO need to work out and get faster. Less donuts too probably at the Glenfort Cafe.
Denrael wrote:So it's useful perhaps for the quick poison, but not for the DOT. Ok, that makes sense. That's always why others like Tiffy have said to drop it to 1 or 2. I SO need to work out and get faster. Less donuts too probably at the Glenfort Cafe.

Poison is its only real use. So use the rest of your points elsewhere. And not in maneuver or riposte either.