I've finally had to choke down the big bile biscuit and buy myself a 2-h axe for my Justicar. Despite 20,700 might and +12% 1-h enchant he is underperforming against his 19,400k +10% 2-h enchant stablemate, to the point that I can't bear it any longer.
There are two paths for a Justicar to choose - hold off your enemy while you chip away at them until they die (1-h sword or axe + shield), or try to knock them dead quickly (2-h sword or axe). Until now I've been trying to stick with the 1-h sword and shield, and convince myself it's worth the extra effort and it'll all come good in the end. No more.
First off, Stagger. This ability requires you to block a hit before it works, and only works against the foe that you blocked. I try NOT to get hit at all if possible, and block is at best only going to work 24% of the time, and over which you have no control. Thus you have an ability which 24% of the time gives 50% extra damage to a foe, or overall adds 12% damage, to a foe that has already hit you, and you hacve probably already hit too. That extra damage may often be unnecessary to finish off a weakened enemy.
Compare that with the 2-h alternative, Brutal ity. This adds (at level 3) 45% extra damage to a critical hit. You don't need to have been hit first, and you control the frequency of your criticals, and how much extra damage they already do via gems and hero training. I'm critting about 1/3 of the time with 180% damage (I haven't worked on this gem set yet). 1/3 x 45% means an extra 15% damage, all of which will be on critical hits.
15% beats 12%, and I can increase my crit frequency with gems and training, so my numbers are onyl going to get better as I progress. There's no way to increase your block %age this way.
Then there's the enchants. the 2-h enchant is, per level, 1%, same as 1-h, but it's 1% of a bigger number, so it's worth more.
I'm sacrificing two things for all this extra damage, speed of blows and defence. Speed isn't helping me if all my faster but weaker blows still can't take down the mobs and bosses before the blows start raining down on me, and often they don't.
Defence doesn't help me if I do take down the enemy quickly. I can dance around naked if I can kill the foe before they get a chance to hit me. So I'm stuck with actually wanting to get hit for my extra things (stagger and hiugher defence) to have an effect.
In real time, 2-h weapons take fewer button mashes to get the job done. These button mashes stack up, so in raids the 1-h player you can't keep up with the 2-h players when the race is on to grab those RPP. It's even worse right now for the poison-based SW, with multiple combat messages popping up to slow the battle.
In Portal farming the best results come from choosing your portal, entering with full energy the moment it opens, then burning 20e pots from the black market every time you run out of energy, until the portal closes. The longer it takes to burn through your energy, the less time left for more pots and more essence/flux drops.
So, at least at level 30 and around 15k plus might, there really is no point in using 1-h plus shield. It's just too slow and frustrating.
Is there a fix? Can 1-h be made more attractive at the high levels?
Stagger could be made more effective - how about having it proc on dodges as well as blocks, for a start.
Block %age could be increased, and/or amount of damage blocked. How about 33% instead of 24%, and 18% for light shields.
The need to put gems on shields (and open the slots to start with) to match up to 2-h could be eliminated. Just have all weapons the same bonu, and ignore slots on shields. The 12,000 CV extra cost to match up 1-h & shield to 2-h is a major problem, and you can't even put an enchant on a shield to make it worth carrying for that purpose.
There are two paths for a Justicar to choose - hold off your enemy while you chip away at them until they die (1-h sword or axe + shield), or try to knock them dead quickly (2-h sword or axe). Until now I've been trying to stick with the 1-h sword and shield, and convince myself it's worth the extra effort and it'll all come good in the end. No more.
First off, Stagger. This ability requires you to block a hit before it works, and only works against the foe that you blocked. I try NOT to get hit at all if possible, and block is at best only going to work 24% of the time, and over which you have no control. Thus you have an ability which 24% of the time gives 50% extra damage to a foe, or overall adds 12% damage, to a foe that has already hit you, and you hacve probably already hit too. That extra damage may often be unnecessary to finish off a weakened enemy.
Compare that with the 2-h alternative, Brutal ity. This adds (at level 3) 45% extra damage to a critical hit. You don't need to have been hit first, and you control the frequency of your criticals, and how much extra damage they already do via gems and hero training. I'm critting about 1/3 of the time with 180% damage (I haven't worked on this gem set yet). 1/3 x 45% means an extra 15% damage, all of which will be on critical hits.
15% beats 12%, and I can increase my crit frequency with gems and training, so my numbers are onyl going to get better as I progress. There's no way to increase your block %age this way.
Then there's the enchants. the 2-h enchant is, per level, 1%, same as 1-h, but it's 1% of a bigger number, so it's worth more.
I'm sacrificing two things for all this extra damage, speed of blows and defence. Speed isn't helping me if all my faster but weaker blows still can't take down the mobs and bosses before the blows start raining down on me, and often they don't.
Defence doesn't help me if I do take down the enemy quickly. I can dance around naked if I can kill the foe before they get a chance to hit me. So I'm stuck with actually wanting to get hit for my extra things (stagger and hiugher defence) to have an effect.
In real time, 2-h weapons take fewer button mashes to get the job done. These button mashes stack up, so in raids the 1-h player you can't keep up with the 2-h players when the race is on to grab those RPP. It's even worse right now for the poison-based SW, with multiple combat messages popping up to slow the battle.
In Portal farming the best results come from choosing your portal, entering with full energy the moment it opens, then burning 20e pots from the black market every time you run out of energy, until the portal closes. The longer it takes to burn through your energy, the less time left for more pots and more essence/flux drops.
So, at least at level 30 and around 15k plus might, there really is no point in using 1-h plus shield. It's just too slow and frustrating.
Is there a fix? Can 1-h be made more attractive at the high levels?
Stagger could be made more effective - how about having it proc on dodges as well as blocks, for a start.
Block %age could be increased, and/or amount of damage blocked. How about 33% instead of 24%, and 18% for light shields.
The need to put gems on shields (and open the slots to start with) to match up to 2-h could be eliminated. Just have all weapons the same bonu, and ignore slots on shields. The 12,000 CV extra cost to match up 1-h & shield to 2-h is a major problem, and you can't even put an enchant on a shield to make it worth carrying for that purpose.