Pros and cons of each build? Do they do comparable dps or does one have an advantage?
Thanks for any input
I jut switched from physical to nature and I like it a lot. Physical hits hard and there are a lot of buffs for crit, but nature has more area of effect damage. Plus with the nature debuffs I end up hitting harder than I would have with physical. I would recommend it. The only downsides I assume would be nature resistance enemies which even in fell marsh dungeon I blow through the boss with high nature resist. And and maybe slightly less crit chance but it doesn't even matter I kill so fast.
Physical is a great 1-2 mob killer and (with 40% crit) actually has 100% crit on piercing strike. Great for bosses.
Poison has more AOE, but there is little point since the damage is so low. My physical SW ends up killing 1-3 monsters with my normal attack (at level 17).
Poison was better than physical before 1.5, but now physical is equal and or better.
I definitely prefer melee SW. Only 13.5k might so that might change when I get higher, but so far, it's incredible.
The big problem with nature-based SW is the constant pop-ups telling you the enemy is poisoned, stunned etc. This really slows down play, and the SW is now the slowest class to play (since 1.5). One hit of Toxic Blade (or Acid Cloud) can generate one damage and two poisoned messages - so you have to wait three times as long to get the next hit in.
Venan are aware of this issue, and are hopefully planning to fix it soon, by allowing players to turn off the excess messages. I see this working throughthe options menu, like the hide helmet option. I would lerave them main damage/criticval message, but remove the status change messages such as poisoned, stun or bleeding, as you can see those occurring without them message. Experienced players don't need the messages, the status effects are shown in the little boxes in the corner of each enemy so you still have the information at your fingertips.
That said a nature SW can kill both single foes and mobs very effectively, and when you have DoT effects kicking in from both poison cloud and caltrops enemies drop health fast. The big problem with DoT is the T part, it always takes time, and many players like to get a big hit of damage and move on to the next round.
I'd like to see a Physical SW stacked up against a Justicar of equal might, because I can't help thinking the Justicar would have the advantage.