Instead of add tag to user ID manually. I propose add an auto tag feature. All members of a guild will have a specific tag(gm made) attached in front of their user id. The tag cannot be removed unless players become guildless. This feature should be incorporated with 1.6
For example: [Spoon] JC or [LH] JC or [KotOR] JC , etc etc
This messes with mercing though. I think it's better how it currently is. I don't want to lose my guild tag every time I go out to do a raid elsewhere.
Venan already said they are in favor of guild loyalty. I'm sure they are adding features to make raid easier so one does not have to go out and merc. If you had been around before merc existed, you would've known it's more fun to compete among guilds. With mercs, guild leaderboard is useless, whichever guild can get more mercs get to stay on top. It is a pointless feature. Back in the old days, competition among each guild actually exist. Not so much these days
They are, but as of now, they also support mercing, don't they? I mean, if they did indeed find a suitable replacement for mercing, I'm all for it -> provided it isn't a fix that prevents me from raiding because my guild only runs particular raids.
It's just that I do enjoy visiting multiple guilds a day and helping out with raids, and it would be a little more of an irritation to flip tags every time I joined and rejoined guilds. I suppose I'm just having trouble seeing how this function would help or where it would fit in? It isn't necessarily solving a problem that exists (mercing), nor is it making anything simpler (since it's simple enough to add a tag manually), and if anything, one could arguing its creating a problem of its' own (guild members are now no longer differentiated from guild guests).
Last point, if only to play devil's advocate, by keeping my tag on, its a good way to passively advertise and get my guild's name out when I visit other guilds. Honestly, that's how I found oda in the first place. Some member came to help my guild out when I was low might, I remembered the Oda name, and when my might got high enough, I joined an odan guild.
JCPenny wrote:Venan already said they are in favor of guild loyalty.
And then Katy turned around recently and said almost the opposite. I asked for a clarification and never saw one.
If you had been around before merc existed, you would've known it's more fun to compete among guilds.
I was and those days were MUCH worse than what we have now. Also, the window of no mercs was actually only 2-3 weeks. I was mercing in June - it was more difficult without auto-accept but it was happening.
My PERSONAL OPINION is that Mercing was an interesting solution to a problem that we had. I like the merc community, but I was expecting more cohesion in guilds. So, while mercs were an unintended consequence of some flaws in the guild system, I don't think that it's an invalid way to play the game. People like it, so I wouldn't want to punish people who like playing that way. However, it would be nice if guilds were more desirable.
//End PERSONAL OPINION THAT DOES NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT VENAN POLICY.
Thanks for the clarification.
Or another idea is to allow players to choose which guild is their home guild and have guild tag attached without having to modify their user name. Of course to qualify as a member of a home guild, one must spend majority of the time in the home guild or the guild tag would be meaningless. If merc wants a tag then they can choose [Mercenary] as their guild tag.
I guess my big question is a resounding why?
What need is there for a change? What's broken or doesn't work the necessitates a feature change?
As things stand currently, manual guild tags work fine. We choose how we want our name to look, no confusion, no issues. By implementing mandatory anything, there's potential for issues to arise. Changing a username takes all of like ten seconds. If it was a complicated procedure, then maybe auto-tags would be necessary...