Book of Heroes

Guild Improvements

So I was doing a little thinking about guilds in general. Provided the idea of a home guild was instituted (where your home guild bonuses stay with you even if you merc), a general overhaul of the guild system would be nice.Currently, power/prestige don't serve any purpose other than leader board/activity status. Additionally, all guilds are virtually identical.

What if there existed a skill tree for guilds as well?

I know a couple games that institute similar things (can't remember any of the top of my head), but basically it would be a menu, somewhat like the ability point allocating menu where each guild has a host of varying things to invest in. Every guild level would provide an ability point to invest in a variety of guild abilities. We could do away altogether with current guild bonuses and leave it up what the guilds wish to focus in. There could be a variety of class bonuses, skill bonuses, valor/gold bonuses, etc. Enough variety and balance that no two guilds would focus on the same things per se.

We have 10 skills (Melee, Magic, Crit, Crit Power, Defense, P/M Resist, Dodge, Haste, HP), 3 classes, valor, silver, 10-15 so enchants.... we're talking potentially close to 30 different bonuses available. Each could go to level 3 or w/e (I'll leave the logistics up to you guys), but this would provide an incentive to continue leveling up a guild, as well as an incentive to join guilds that fit your interests.

We could end up with guilds that provide bonuses to SW attacks, leading to SW guilds, etc. I don't know... it may even improve guild cohesion, since everyone is focusing on similar activities.

It's a very rough idea that could be fleshed out however Venan feels necessary if they like it, but what do you guys think? Any future or suggested and failed?
Oda_tennischamp5 wrote:Currently, power/prestige serve any purpose other than leader board/activity status. Additionally, all guilds are virtually identical.

I think you meant 'Currently, power/prestige don't serve any purpose other than leader board/activity status'

I don't agree that all Guilds are identical. My main reason for choosing a Guild was finding one that ran the raids I wanted at a time I could do them. That limited my choice considerably.

Having found a Guild that fit the above criteria, I have stayed because it is well organised, run jointly by two Guild Masters who share the chores with humour and consideration, and without having to top the RPP table every raid. They have achieved what my old Guild tried and failed to achieve - merging two Guilds' membership, and not bruising too many egos.

I'm kind of looking forward to more restricted mercing so I can get a better RPP return each raid, and not see the top 3 slots grabbed by one-time visitors who burn like crazy and then leave to do the same elsewhere.