One of the two new seasonal feats tied to Lucky the Leprechaun requires getting the Sham Rock from Lucky's Lockbox. Unlike all previous feats, whether a player gets the Sham Rock is not a factor of whether they play hard and devote the effort to getting the feat, but determined by their luck at the Lockbox. As I and many other players have experienced, it is far too easy to have bad luck with the lockboxes (as noted by my 7 Magic Resist T4 gems, vs 1 Phys Resist and a couple of Crit Powers). Ever if you go all out, spend GS like water, and kill Lucky hundreds of times, it's possible to miss out on getting a Sham Rock, while other players have gotten several.
Every other feat is simply influenced by how much time and effort the players put into achieving it. Kills, Raids, Dungeons, Quests, Progression, even the other Seasonals, all require persistence. "What a Sham!" requires luck. If my luck is bad this weekend, then I'll be staring at a 4/5 in that feat category for at least the next year, if not forever, which is frustrating to someone who wants to complete everything.
The simple solution? Make the Sham Rock available in Majerio's Shop, for 20 or 30 Lucky Clovers. Then if I want to complete the feat, I CAN get it done, although at a higher cost than if I'd gotten it from the Lockbox. And this needs to go in before the event closes on Tuesday morning.
If I have a feat sitting undone that I cannot make progress on, that is the usually the beginning of the end for a game in my rotation (other games like Dragonvale drove me away on feats like this).I have no objection to having a rare sham rock or 500 gs prize to shoot for, but don't make it a feat.
I 100% agree. We need to get this fixed. I personally have spent all my energy and a lot of energy pots this weekend all on Lucky and still no Sham Rock.
Another irritating point about the sham rock is whether to sell it or not when you finally get it (got it after 3 days of chasing).
Since it it absolutely useless atm (exactly as its description says) and sells for 5 clovers, it looks like the best use for it is indeed to sell it.
It would be however nice to learn from Venan whether the rock will have any other uses after the event ends.
Also since BOH has almost no unique items or artefacts (actually, three - the Glenfort amulet, the Val bracers and the Goblin hat, the rest is generic) I feel somehow reluctant to part with it...
PS: I am not actually complaining, just very curious. I do not mind luck based feats, events, achievement and such.
As someone who did get it and sold it, I don't know if my opinion here will make a difference, but, part of the whole leprechaun mythology and indeed a lot of the folklore surrounding gifts of gold or any other 'parting of valuables' from leprechauns involves just how difficult it was to get any of these little people to give any 'quarter' and how much they went about deceiving people with their tricks, shams, and other misdeeds. One unique thing about them was how they were always giving away what seemed to be valuable things in exchange for services or help from and would lie and deceive a nd promise riches and pots of gold to be let go, and upon payment, the leprechaun would vanish, and the mark would be left with a bag of clover leaves, or some other sham, instead of the riches they had thought they were getting.
So although we may not like it, it seems in keeping with this particular creatures mythology.
-M
Also, not all of my 'feats' have been able to be filled because of various circumstances, but I am not going to complain to the game maker because I couldn't accomplish them... I was 'unlucky' in that I had company on the last night of the 'Valentine' contest, so I was not able to kill him 100 times, I was shy about 19 kills because of my luck, but it is not something one complains to the Game Maker about...
This game contains a huge element of luck with its random number generators, all games based on dice RPGs do.
: )
Relax, have fun, it is only a game. It is all ones and zeros in the end. : )
When I started this game (over a year ago), I enjoyed the nature of feats in that I could work on any feat on any day if I chose. In the weeks leading up to 1.5, I was spending most of my energy in the shores of dragonmoor chasing my 5000 pirates (I got 'em).
Perhaps players like me who have invested energy and time into feats are a minority, but when I get frustrated by a game, that it usually an indicator it is time to move on and find a different game to play.
Venan has made a great game that has held my interest for so long, but I'm starting to dread holiday events, indicating that I should consider getting out... I don't want a game that isn't fun. Had I not spent so much energy in the early months chasing feats, I probably wouldn't care, but I do care, and so I might be stopping this game sooner than I thought.
The mechanics of contests and rare artifacts do not bother me, but changing the nature of feats to include these may chase me out.
I acknowledge that 99% of players don't care about this issue, and satisfying the feat chasers may not be a high priority for Venan, but the simple act of keeping seasonal feats accessible would probably keep the game fun for me for another 12 months. Keep the big seasonal rewards (TVal T6 enchant plate and sham rock) but keep the seasonal feats simple to hold onto the feat chasers like me.
So, obviously this afternoon Venan addressed this issue by changing the drop rate for the Sham Rock to 50% if you had not yet gotten the achievement. With the help from this, I was able to get all three of my characters to complete the Feat, which probably would not have happened without the change. It wasn't the exact fix I suggested, but it got the job done. I wanted to say thank you to Venan for listening to the players and helping out all us completionists.
Aside from the kerfuffle with the feat, the Lucky event has been my favorite seasonal event so far. The Lucky enemy had great character design, with a wide variety of fun and inventive moves. The "always there" aspect made it easier than before to pick up the game and try to find Lucky when I had time, instead of waiting for the Holiday Goblin or Tragick Valentine to appear for a brief window, which is more in line with the play-as-you-go nature of Book of Heroed as a smartphone game anyway. Five minutes waiting in line? Go spend 20 energy hunting Lucky. And, the location for level 30s especially was one that I appreciated; I haven't finished my 5K Bandit feat yet, and before the event opened I was speculating that if Lucky was somewhere I could kill Bandits, it would be an extra bit of gravy.
So, take the lesson to heart: make Feats a reward for hard work, not luck (or at least don't make the luck super difficult to achieve), and keep making a great game. Thanks for what you've done so far.