Book of Heroes

Guild Feature Requests & Suggestions · page 4

Do away with the "Power Ranking" and replace it with a time stamped guild level ranking. There's a reason I am requesting this and it's not to mess with the top 2 (I could care less what they do to be honest). Currently my concern is that "Power Decay" is canceling out power gains for the lvl6 guilds at the moment so it looks like we're treading water when we're successfully raiding Vallus and everything else we can. It makes the members of those guilds feel like they aren't progressing when they are and if too many of us quit then Celestial Beings won't have anyone to stea^H^H^H^Hpoac^H^H^H^Hrecruit new members from. Amongst other concerns.
Meian wrote:Do away with the "Power Ranking" and replace it with a time stamped guild level ranking. There's a reason I am requesting this and it's not to mess with the top 2 (I could care less what they do to be honest). Currently my concern is that "Power Decay" is canceling out power gains for the lvl6 guilds at the moment so it looks like we're treading water when we're successfully raiding Vallus and everything else we can. It makes the members of those guilds feel like they aren't progressing when they are and if too many of us quit then Celestial Beings won't have anyone to stea^H^H^H^Hpoac^H^H^H^Hrecruit new members from. Amongst other concerns.

Can you clarify on "stea^H^H^H^Hpoac^H^H^H^" that part?
easy enough to understand I guess:
right now, a top guild cannot grow new players because of might requirement. No raid would be accessible for low might members when the whole guild is doing high level raids. It means that the only way for a top guild to find new members is to find players that already have 8000+ might. Did they get the 8000+ might solo? No. This is the reason of the "stealing" comment.
Because of course a 8000+ might player is a top player of a ranked 5/10 guild, it produces bitterness to see this kind of strong player leave for a guild with a better ranking.
Ariane wrote:easy enough to understand I guess:
right now, a top guild cannot grow new players because of might requirement. No raid would be accessible for low might members when the whole guild is doing high level raids. It means that the only way for a top guild to find new members is to find players that already have 8000+ might. Did they get the 8000+ might solo? No. This is the reason of the "stealing" comment.
Because of course a 8000+ might player is a top player of a ranked 5/10 guild, it produces bitterness to see this kind of strong player leave for a guild with a better ranking.

The reason why I want clarification is not because I don't understand but because he didn't completely spell out the word and if I make my assumption then he may just deny using that word. But now you've mentioned it. "Steal" is inappropriate don't you think? Definition of steal is to take something without permission and authority. I don't steal people from other guilds, I provide opportunity. Whether they want leave your guild and join ours are completely their own free will. I don't force that will. I certainly don't need your permission to recruit a member of yours if he chooses to leave your guild. If I purposely talk to members of your guild and ask them to join us, ok that may be stealing depend on how you define steal. But all I did was send out the message, like a job opening flyer. You may call it poaching but even in real life employee poaching is quite common.
See, and that's why I would rather quit than join your guild. I wouldn't deny my statement anyways. I actually have integrity thank you very much.

That aside, the current system punishes guilds for building up their own players and that's what I have a problem with. There is a massive gap between what you can do on your own to be "raid ready" and where raids end up. I hope this is something that can be addressed in 1.4 but right now the number of guilds needing a higher geared player base that is simply not there will only continue to grow. Higher tier raiding is simply not sustainable in it's current state. Growth is outstripping resources.
Meian wrote:See, and that's why I would rather quit than join your guild. I wouldn't deny my statement anyways. I actually have integrity thank you very much.

That aside, the current system punishes guilds for building up their own players and that's what I have a problem with. There is a massive gap between what you can do on your own to be "raid ready" and where raids end up. I hope this is something that can be addressed in 1.4 but right now the number of guilds needing a higher geared player base that is simply not there will only continue to grow. Higher tier raiding is simply not sustainable in it's current state. Growth is outstripping resources.

If it's your choice for not joining us, then I respect that. But calling us of without integrity is very hostile. You can't control players come and go the same way we can't control either. Certainly I won't reject players if they are interested in joining us just because they are already in another guild. If it's something that they feel missing in your guild but find suitable in ours, then it is their choices not mine. The same reason few high might players in my guild left ours just because the schedule didn't work for them. If they ever joined your guild, should I call you of without integrity as well? I meant no disrespect in any form but if you continue calling us something we are not, then the conversation on this matter is over, I believe I explained clearly.

Btw, I don't disagree your suggestion on changes in 1.4. I welcome changes so other guilds can actually catch up rather than being bottlenecked. I like to see this game succeed rather than fail due to lost of players just because current raid system favors to dedicated guilds only but punishes casual guilds. However, the gap you are talking about is just temporarily, and I mean it, seriously. I can predict ZenGUILD or even your guild may eventually catch us up because Zen has many dedicated players. The only reason why we are in the lead is because we are one step ahead of everyone(We are hitting Lv8 by tonight), we started harder raids sooner than everyone. But once we all are able to do Fellmarsh raids, it is whoever finishes the raid fastest gains the most power and rank top and while decay continues on it's course at midnight everyday.
A better email system would be great. All you can do is one long winded paragraph. There's no paragraph reuters. No way to paste from another system. Not sure how you send to one person since you cannot look up people's names either from your guild or friends. Basically you don't know if mail even went through properly. Multiple users like regular email programs would be great.

SïlvërDüst

ModeratorFri Jul 13, 2012 5:25 pm
Can we as a group get pooled items that would pop all the bosses in a single raid have the pop item require all 60 members provide 1 of each raid item that would be a common drop from all raid ..... The reward for the super raid would be one piece of job specific gear non transferable gear ... That had auto stuff like vanish or interfocus or whatever or have gear with a matching full set bonus just a thought
Is there a possibility to have a different chat place for officers to talk privately away from the main guild chat page -like a meeting room which can be restricted to GM and officer(s) only and then possibly extend it to veterans if needed?

Also, it would be great if there's options to be able to send a mail to one person or more and/or cc options too. Copy, paste or forward options would be useful too.
Roll Call notification (support for the casual guild)

This is a notification ping by the Guild Master or Officer (with a cooldown of an hour or more) that allows them to send a non-raid notification asking members who are ready and willing to raid soon to get online so their numbers can be assessed. This is not the raid start, but a way to figure out if there are enough numbers to do a hard raid versus an easier raid.

Seems like there is a reluctance to start harder raids when it *seems* like there aren't going to be enough members, but the fact is, notification of a raid start draws members in (lots of people have notification turned on), and we end up burning energy on an easier raid than necessary.

Sure, we can cancel an easy raid and start a hard one instead, but sometimes it isn't clear we should do that until several members have burned through their energy.

Thoughts?