This has probably been dealt with before, but I have an idea that I think would improve the merc situation.
As it stands, there is very little reason not to use mercs and a distinct necessity for most guilds to use mercs. This results in a TON of spam messages to the global chat, which really detracts from the experience on global for those who participate in it. I have had to recruit mercs for my guild multiple times and I absolutely despise spamming anyone, anywhere, at any time.
Due to the fluid nature of player's participation, the various guilds with which I have been associated have ALWAYS needed mercs since I started playing. Players also have various life schedules and cannot always participate in each raid, leaving guilds understaffed for raids. In short, the need for mercs is not going to go away...
So EMBRACE IT!
Add a check box to the guild page that officers and above can tick to indicate that they are accepting mercs, leaving the autoaccept and might requirements the same.
Add a board at the Mucky Duck, the "Dark Smoky Corner" or "Dimly Lit Corner" or something, which is an area for potential mercs to find an assignment. When someone clicks into it, it shows a table with Guild Name, Empty Guild Slots, Raid Name, Phase, Time Remaining, Might Requirement (or not, but then only showing raids for which someone has enough might). Clicking on one of these asks the player to confirm if they want to join the guild for the raid. If so, they join right up.
If Venan wants to control the amount of mercenaries, I suppose they could put a premium on it by subtracting a percentage of the reward if the player was in a different guild the previous raid. I'm not fond of that idea, but doing so would likely limit the amount of mercing people are doing. On the other hand, it might force people to stay with a guild to avoid the penalty, but result in them being unable to run as many raids as they would like due to their availability to play. However, if the concern about mercs is the spam aspect of it, my proposal solves that.
Does anyone agree or disagree with my idea? I'd love some feedback!
As it stands, there is very little reason not to use mercs and a distinct necessity for most guilds to use mercs. This results in a TON of spam messages to the global chat, which really detracts from the experience on global for those who participate in it. I have had to recruit mercs for my guild multiple times and I absolutely despise spamming anyone, anywhere, at any time.
Due to the fluid nature of player's participation, the various guilds with which I have been associated have ALWAYS needed mercs since I started playing. Players also have various life schedules and cannot always participate in each raid, leaving guilds understaffed for raids. In short, the need for mercs is not going to go away...
So EMBRACE IT!
Add a check box to the guild page that officers and above can tick to indicate that they are accepting mercs, leaving the autoaccept and might requirements the same.
Add a board at the Mucky Duck, the "Dark Smoky Corner" or "Dimly Lit Corner" or something, which is an area for potential mercs to find an assignment. When someone clicks into it, it shows a table with Guild Name, Empty Guild Slots, Raid Name, Phase, Time Remaining, Might Requirement (or not, but then only showing raids for which someone has enough might). Clicking on one of these asks the player to confirm if they want to join the guild for the raid. If so, they join right up.
If Venan wants to control the amount of mercenaries, I suppose they could put a premium on it by subtracting a percentage of the reward if the player was in a different guild the previous raid. I'm not fond of that idea, but doing so would likely limit the amount of mercing people are doing. On the other hand, it might force people to stay with a guild to avoid the penalty, but result in them being unable to run as many raids as they would like due to their availability to play. However, if the concern about mercs is the spam aspect of it, my proposal solves that.
Does anyone agree or disagree with my idea? I'd love some feedback!