Book of Heroes

The Spoon Run Event! · page 2

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Mar 27, 2013 2:10 pm
Robespiere wrote:
Bimbo_sama wrote:
Arclord wrote:
Sadly it looks like u missed the whole point Arclord is trying to make. Yes people spend GS in portals and raids but in the end, you get something out of it. This, all you get is your name on a guild page that
Could splinter and disband anytime! ( not trying to put the guild down, just stating facts). And it's laughable that u think the best in the game will be decided on how many shields someone can throw at a raid. And really, we will bring people's Moms into issues......Sooooo 1990s dude.

Robespiere, it is yourself and arclord who are completely missing the point and actually do not understand the mechanics of a raid race.

The winner is not determined by who throws the most GS at the raid, but by who can throw it the fastest. :)

To win a speed raid, as a player your toon needs to have the best build, strategy and tapping skill to win.
Those who have none of these do not win these races and it has nothing to do with their inability to spend GS.

Example: Spoons ran the record GK and VG races. In the record GK race, top players completed 39-42 waves. Most mid-finishing players completed 18-29. Top players than starting with 42e probably spent between 1-2 epots or 4-8 GS at most (or combination of the two). That is not a lot of GS or epots. Big whoop. The mid-finishers barely spent 1 epots or 4 GS, even less.

So what determined the top finisher versus mid-finishers...was it that mid-finishers simply didn't want to spend the extra GS needed to win as your suggesting? Wrong..its because they couldn't spend the GS fast enough. They lacked the skill and speed and toon strategy to execute wave after wave of enemies to keep up...and when the time ran out....well that was it.

And your implication, that because these race winners wont get posted on a permanent "leaderboard" somewhere, but rather a guild board, is demonstrative that its a pointless enterprise; well that is a naive view at best...

Look at what is on the current leader-boards: Might and Hero Score...and yet these metrics are gamed and abused so easily that they mean nothing, and everyone knows it.

But to win this type of race... well only those individuals who know how to truly tune their toon build, understand the best strategies for each phase of the raid and have the tapping skill...they are the winners and it is a very clear metric of who can build and run the best toons in the game...that is why we have these races. Outside of these races...their is NO other metric to determine who can build a better toon.
Mithrid wrote:
Outside of these races...their is NO other metric to determine who can build a better toon.

Onslaught ;)

Though, no I understand why these are important. I'm not strong enough to take part this time guys, but one day ;)

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Mar 27, 2013 2:55 pm
Tennis,
There is no reason to not hold an Onslaught race for all the same reasons I mentioned.
And we all know that an Onslaught build is a very different strategy from a VG/GK race so it makes sense for all the CoC'ers out there to hold their own CoC race. But apart from a CoC race, how would you determine who has a better Onslaught tailored toon?

Though I think for Onslaught the best race is not actually a race but to limit E spent and see who gets the most RPP.
Since the point of onslaught is to maximize RPP per E, the best Onslaught competition would be to limit Hits to say 40e and see who wins the most RPP. (At least that is what we've done in Kingdom from time to time)

-Mith
@ Bimbo: Guess I shouldnt be surprised to get an immature reply from someone named Bimbo. Grow up, and no need to address anything you mentioned.

@ Mith: at least you tried to provide some rationale, and I think you talked yourself into the real solution. In order to have a true competition that would have results worth anything, a highest PP gain from an onslaught with no epots/shields/regen elixirs/buff pots/defense pots/etc allowed would be the only way to do it. Controlling cheating would be the hard part.

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Mar 27, 2013 8:41 pm
Arclord wrote:

@ Mith: at least you tried to provide some rationale, and I think you talked yourself into the real solution. In order to have a true competition that would have results worth anything, a highest PP gain from an onslaught with no epots/shields/regen elixirs/buff pots/defense pots/etc allowed would be the only way to do it. Controlling cheating would be the hard part.

Arclord,
Though I think an onslaught RPP contest is completely valid for determining the best, solid onslaught tuned toon, I would argue that it is no where near as comprehensive a meteric for determining toon excellence and strategy as a VG race.

My reasons are simple: one of my big complaints of the raid system is to master a raid, most stats and abilities are neglected, particularly resist, health, defense. The only real stats that matter in a VG raid race are crit, magic/melee, haste, crit power, and enchants, and player strategy/rotation.

Onslaughts are even more neglectful of game characteristics. A 10k toon can one hit nearly any wave in P1 and P2. In onslaughts, magic/melee, crit and crit power become as ignored as the resists are in normal raids. All that matters in onslaught then is haste and strategy. So it is nowhere near as comprehensive a meteric for overall toon excellence as regular raids.
That being said, until Venan comes out with a game system where resists and health are useful and require balance with all the other stats as part of a toons build and strategy. I still contend that VG and GK raids are the best metric for overall toon excellence.

However I am not discounting the fact that onslaught is still a worthwhile strategy worthy of competition, it's just not nearly as comprehensive in regards to overall toon excellence and strategy as a VG raid.

Also I'm not certain what you consider cheating? For example I think if a player has to decide when to use a haste pot or a power pot as part of their strategy, that's not cheating that reflects the skill of the player in how well they choose. So pots for example should be completely legitimate in raid races, they are a legitimate part of a toon and a players toon strategy demonstrating how well that player has mastered the game.
Looks like we are holding off until Saturday at 8pm to catch the double valor weekend, and maybe just doing one round after all to minimize the Shield spend. Post above edited.

japster

ModeratorThu Mar 28, 2013 1:47 pm
To be honest...Onslaught max rpp record per 4 energy would be the most fair competition, categorized by class. Admittedly it doesn't test "speed", but still, I can simply tell you why speed raids = unfair.

LAG.

After playing BoH in the USA last week when I flew there for a vacation, I realized players in America with a decent connection have a HUGE advantage over any Asian gamer, despite our superb connection. Your load times between waves are literally non-existent. Whereas in Asia, there'll always be a 1 to 2second load time.

There is simply no way players can compete fairly in a speed raid with the lag disadvantage. Just my 2 cents. But that said, good luck with organizing this and hope you get plenty of worthy competitors.
TCG_japster wrote:I realized players in America with a decent connection have a HUGE advantage over any Asian gamer, despite our superb connection. Your load times between waves are literally non-existent. Whereas in Asia, there'll always be a 1 to 2second load time.

You must have had a hell of a good connection. I'm used to 1 to 2 second load times in America (whether wifi or 3/4G). Still, the US should have a fraction of a second advantage just because the server is hosted here.

japster

ModeratorThu Mar 28, 2013 2:38 pm
Bbbb wrote:
TCG_japster wrote:I realized players in America with a decent connection have a HUGE advantage over any Asian gamer, despite our superb connection. Your load times between waves are literally non-existent. Whereas in Asia, there'll always be a 1 to 2second load time.

You must have had a hell of a good connection. I'm used to 1 to 2 second load times in America (whether wifi or 3/4G). Still, the US should have a fraction of a second advantage just because the server is hosted here.

I was just using college wifi in DC, as well as hotel complimentary wifi. And it was literally seamless between waves. Not too sure how accurate their connection would be as reflection of general connectivity in most parts of USA. But I am also aware that 3G/4G coverage can be crappy at some areas.

Anyway the point is, under optimal conditions in USA, Asian players will simply never match up.