Book of Heroes

Damage Calculation bug?- Stat Rating vs Bonus

hi,

i'm curious about how damage calculated in this game.
my char is SW at level 30, currently i'm farming Red Tier 4 shard at GK.

i'll be focusing on Melee damage only as that is my primary concern right now

the weapon i'm using is T12 sword from KV on my main hand and T10 sword from SV on my offhand
my Melee stat before i got Strength Gem 4 was 2040-ish. damage to Direhorn 1000+800 non crit, 1800+1300 when crit.
adding Strength Gem 4, melee+384 to 2400-ish. damage to Direhorn is still the same (or sometimes even worse 900+700 non crit)

anyone can explain this?
Thanks
two quick potential answers come to mind

1) Make sure Direhorn hasn't cast Defensive Stance.

2) Weapon Damage is not static, it has a range. For example, my basic attack damage range is 1531-1836 main hand. That's almost 300 damage. Sometimes i will hit for 1500, and sometimes for 1800, on the same enemy.

If you want to be more sure, get more data. No personal offense intended, but humans are unreliable observers. We tend to ignore things that are in line with what we expect or want, (normal/high damage) and focus on events that _seem_ to be out of place or unfavorable (low damage).

Remember also that stat curves have diminishing returns. Going from 1600 to 2000 melee score results in a bigger damage increase than 2000 to 2400. Check how much it actually increased your melee damage. It was probably by less than 100. Combined with the attack damage range, it is entirely possible to see numbers like the ones you were describing.
GC_Myainsel wrote:two quick potential answers come to mind

1) Make sure Direhorn hasn't cast Defensive Stance.

2) Weapon Damage is not static, it has a range. For example, my basic attack damage range is 1531-1836 main hand. That's almost 300 damage. Sometimes i will hit for 1500, and sometimes for 1800, on the same enemy.

If you want to be more sure, get more data. No personal offense intended, but humans are unreliable observers. We tend to ignore things that are in line with what we expect or want, (normal/high damage) and focus on events that _seem_ to be out of place or unfavorable (low damage).

Remember also that stat curves have diminishing returns. Going from 1600 to 2000 melee score results in a bigger damage increase than 2000 to 2400. Check how much it actually increased your melee damage. It was probably by less than 100. Combined with the attack damage range, it is entirely possible to see numbers like the ones you were describing.

yes, all damages i observe was when the first hit occurs (while Direhorn still "waiting")
but actually i didn't see the damage estimate when i click "attack".
i'll try to see it next time i fight him

thanks :)

EDIT: i tried looking the damage range when click Attack
the values didn't change depends on enemy, so i tried in other area/not Direhorn

Melee 2040ish : Main 1171-1300, Offhand 805-877
Melee 2400ish : Main 1195-1324, Offhand 825-897

Melee Rating increase ~20%
Melee Damage increase ~2%

should i expect Damage increase at ~20% too or this Rating-vs-Damage seems valid?
The most important question. What attack are you using to provide the numbers you gave?

If you are using one of the poison attacks, then melee gems won't help you. Those are magic attacks.
After about 1900 melee you go from getting 1 damage per 2.5 rating to 1 dmg per 12.5 rating.

Basically stop stacking melee so hard after 2000 melee rating because you're not gonna get much of anything back.
Well, the problem you're having is differentiating between your Melee Stat and your damage bonus.

For example, I have 3,322 melee stat, but the bonus to my physical damage is only 880.

If I remove a melee gem, my melee stat is now 2,762, but the bonus to my physical damage is still 835.

2,762 to 3,322 is a 20% stat increase but 835 to 880 is only a 5% damage increase. Thus is the issue with diminishing returns.