Book of Heroes

War Mage Questions · page 3

Jossaholic

ModeratorThu Jun 13, 2013 2:28 am
So, o sage mages, has your advice changed at all now that you've had some time to adjust to 1.6? Am in the process of buying my T5 gems for one of my mages and trying to decide how to build them. Thanks in advance!
In response to several posts here in favor of using Snap cast:

I did this analysis prior to the roll out of 2.0, but if anything, I am less inclined to use snap cast in 2.0 bc of the multitude of better places to allocate that precious point.

Should My War Mage put an ability point into the Snap Cast spell or not?

Sry for the sloppy analysis here, but to do it right would take a lot more time than I am willing to spend. I have taken damage values for best case snap cast vs worst case using that point for minimum damage gain. From those I interpolate my answer. Not a great analysis technique, but quick, dirty, and most likely accurate bc I am giving Snap every advantage and the non snap every disadvantage.

The damage numbers you see here will vary with your setup and thus this analysis could be inaccurate for your setup. For this analysis, I used my damage numbers. Bottom line, I won’t use snap, but it might be good based on your setup. How is that for a fairly useless analysis :lol:

OK Let’s look at the numbers

Snap Build
2333 1331 0323 2010

Snap Point moved to Fire Blast
2333 1331 0323 3000

Assuming best case for Snap: when snap fires, you can cast Ice Lance at level 3 Every time
Damage = % chance snap fires * average damage Ice Lance
Damage = .01*3045.32 = 30.45 points of damage for snap on average
Adding that point to fire blast instead = 1134.9-945.75 = 189.15 damage whenever I cast Fire Blast

This is not an exhaustive analysis or even very substantial. However if you only use fire blast 1% of the time [same as when snap cast fires] you get an extra 189.15 damage vs snap casts 30.45 and you get even more for putting that point into any other damage spell like Incinerate = 3026.4 -2648.1 = 378.3

Given these numbers, I just cannot justify putting that point into snap cast.

You can determine if snap helps your setup or not. Here is how:
If you take your numbers and plug them into the equations, you can determine for your setup if Snap gives you an edge or not. To get your numbers, when you are facing a set of monsters, click once on Ice Lance and write down the high and low damage values it shows you. Don’t cast it yet. Instead click on fire blast once and write the same high and low values down. Average your numbers (low dam + high dam)/2 and plug them into the equations instead of using my numbers. If Fire Blast gives you more damage than Snap it is best that you don’t waste a point in Snap Cast.

Do the math and decide for your self, yes?

Love, Sadie
The 2.0 and 1.x analysis of snapcast are two different things. For 1.x, I understand your point. For 2.0, it is much more useful because you can control when you use it.

Sadie, I know where you are might wise. At the point you are, you need to start focusing on onslaught raids over regular. SnapChat will get you extra kills for sure in onslaught. Also, it helps prevent getting your weapon stolen, warded, etc. Finally, in LoB p4, if it is available, it will save your life at times.

In your current guild (I am there too although a slightly different username - you can figure it out), ask for someone to give you the Jumper build. It is great at onslaught and tolerable at regular raids. I think it has one point in SnapCast. When we get more levels, I think I may allocate my next points to maxing it.

I have my second build geared around silver farming with p1/p2 CoC and I have snapcast maxed on that one.
Hello B4Play,

It might be useful in Lob P4. But generally I did not find that phase particularly tough. I died twice, but it was my first attempt and I made mistakes. The problem I have with snap cast is that in order for it to be useful at all, it must fire when you need it too. otherwise it is a waste of a point. I won't use it in coc, bc, I get more for my money by doing that extra damage that gives a better chance at a one hit kill than by hoping it fires when it is useful for me. I took a ton of empirical data in coc for 1.0. During that entire time I was using snap cast. However, for the data to be meaningful to use for a spell that fires so rarely, a lot more data would have been needed. In my data, which is admittedly not significant enough to be useful, over 70% of the time snap cast fired at a point in time where it did me no good whatsoever. The thing I do not see from snap cast proponents is any kind of analysis of it's usefulness. All I hear is, "It saves my butt" or "It gives me extra kills in onslaught." I apologize sweetie, but that is not enough for me. For you or anyone to convince me that it is useful, show me the money! to steal a line from a movie. I would like to see either enough data to form a statistically significant sample or a mathematical analysis of why it is of value. I don't think that is too much to ask.
I never put points into Snap Cast prior to 2.0. It seemed like a waste to put points into a skill that randomly fired vs. putting it into a skill I used every fight. When 2.0 came around and Snap Cast was able to be triggered manually, I put one point into it, and I've been happy with it ever since.

In CoC, I end up with a tiny sliver of time left at the end of a round- way too little to cast that Flaming Pyre. So I hit Snap Cast, hit Flaming Pyre, and viola! One more round of kills.

In any onslaught raid, if a Fire fracture is about to expire in a sliver of time, and there's no way a normal ice-spell casting will fire before the fracture expires, I click Snap Cast, hit Ice Lance (or some other ice spell), and viola! Fire fracture is restored.

In LoB P4, all my other options are on cooldown. The Ecnirp is .01 seconds away from dropping Twin Strike on me for instant death. I click Snap Cast, hit Incinerate, and viola! Dead Ecnirp (or more dead).

In any onslaught phase where the monster is .01 seconds away from disarming/freezing/warding/etc, if I cast Snap Cast, cast Ice Lance - poof - instant hit and knockback. Then I have time to do something else to stop him.

It's too useful not to have, at least in my opinion.

Nightcrawler
Sadie wrote:The problem I have with snap cast is that in order for it to be useful at all, it must fire when you need it too. otherwise it is a waste of a point.

You realize in 2.0 except for cooldown, it is totally under your control.

I won't use it in coc, bc, I get more for my money by doing that extra damage that gives a better chance at a one hit kill than by hoping it fires when it is useful for me.

At your might, you should be OHK CoC. Snapcast gives me 1-2 extra waves with no downside for that raid. There is nowhere else the points are useful in that build.
However, for the data to be meaningful to use for a spell that fires so rarely, a lot more data would have been needed. In my data, which is admittedly not significant enough to be useful, over 70% of the time snap cast fired at a point in time where it did me no good whatsoever. The thing I do not see from snap cast proponents is any kind of analysis of it's usefulness. All I hear is, "It saves my butt" or "It gives me extra kills in onslaught." I apologize sweetie, but that is not enough for me. For you or anyone to convince me that it is useful, show me the money! to steal a line from a movie. I would like to see either enough data to form a statistically significant sample or a mathematical analysis of why it is of value. I don't think that is too much to ask.

The problem is that your entire theory is based on the random 1.x snapcast. You have complete control over when 2.0 snapcast fires so it is an entirely different ballgame. Just look at Nightcrawler13's examples. Any high level mage PvE build without at least one point in snapcast is flat out bad.
Thanks, I will respec and give it a try. It is not real clear from the ability description that it is cast and not random. Now that I read it with that in mind, I can say OK, I get that, but without the fore knowledge, no. It does not speak to me. Wait! Now I can use snap cast you so I can throw a zinger at you! :lol: