InMyOffice wrote:
Option 1 - Global Server (non-hosted) Raids - If these raids are going to be "global" server-scheduled raids, then guilds that rely heavily on mercenary support to complete raids are going to suffer dramatically, because there will be nobody wanting to leave their guild/merc if they can just do a global raid.
Option 2 - Guild-hosted "Public" Raids - However if these raids are "public" guild raids (i.e. a guild can run a raid open to the public, so others can help their raid without leaving their guild), then guilds that rely heavily on mercs will be okay, because they can still run "public" raids.
-IMO|Dave
Option 1 makes more sense to cater to the mercing community while promoting guild loyalty. This is probably the way Venan will go, assuming your predictions are accurate. That way guilds can focus on creating a stable core of raiders (with an increased size of 100, the only excuse has to be lazy recruitment/management/planning of raid schedules) and gain loyalty, while players who simply cannot fit a guild-style system can still organize public raids on their own accord and band together temporarily, but with no energy, favor, or bonus valor/ht rewards.
Option 2 is just ridiculous if you think carefully about it. It will preserve the status quo that we have right now (rampant mercing/mercy mercing/whatever mercing you wanna call it mercing) and create no change except to give people crazily good bonuses after staying in a guild long enough. After all, if everybody can just join a guild-hosted public raid while staying in their own guild, not only will they build loyalty (since they don't need to quit their own guilds) and get perks when their own guilds host raids, they also get to merc free-style else where, and retain the non-raid related bonuses (favors, max energy) when farming portals/dungeons. Note that a 50 energy base is extremely important for farming portals and gives a pretty powerful bonus out of the raid context and you can be certain almost everyone will be scrambling for this perk.
I fail to see what good option 2 creates except to promote even MORE mercing. Nobody will be incentivized to run a true loyalty-based guild. In fact everyone will be scrambling to host such public raids so as to boost their loyalty within guild (assuming participation in a home guild-hosted raid boosts loyalty) to get perks when they do host their own raids, and then continue their mercenary life style as and when convenient. The loyalty rewards given in 1.6 will then become an utter farce to "promote loyalty", and instead be yet another "convenient bonus" that all players will feel entitled to get.
Also, on a point of technicality, since we know that you only get the loyalty perks when you're in your own guild, under option 2, one of two things may occur.
1. When you join a guild-hosted public raid (not your home guild), you retain your bonus 8 energy (max 50 energy!) because you never did quit your guild. You keep your favors, and bonus valor/ht rewards too. From the wording of the updates, it seems that you only lose your loyalty when you quit a home guild. If that is so, then if joining a guild-hosted public raid doesn't equate to quitting your home guild, the perks would remain. If this is the case, then 1.6 will be an utter failure to create any real change.
2. When you join a guild-hosted public raid (not your home guild), you lose all loyalty perks for that raid since it is in a foreign guild. If this is the case, then it creates a SMALL difference to raiders from the current v1.5, and this may or may not matter at the end of the day (we have yet to see all balance changes).
However this conception poses some problems. Immediately, I see a potential hassle/challenge with regard to coding, because that means player's max energy will be constantly increasing/decreasing. But this may not be a big issue since you would lose your max energy bonuses if you quit a home guild anyway. However it still becomes tricky, since it creates an interim status where you "kind-of" belong to two guilds at the same time, demarcated by a raid.
Also a lot of other problems potentially occur. Since it's entirely possible right now for one toon to participate in two raids simultaneously (yes, veteran BoH players will know guilds used to stack raids in the past to compete for power ranking, and members would actually DO TWO raids concurrently, e.g. dump 42energy in one, then burn gs in another), what would happen if your home guild is hosting a raid and you're in another guild's public-hosted raid?
How exactly will you obtain your energy bonuses in one and lose it in the other? How exactly will loyalty perks be tagged? To guild membership, to home guild-hosted raids, or to other guild-hosted public raids? This becomes increasingly complex, confusing, and difficult to code. Does it mean if I were to take part in a guild-hosted public raid, I cannot take part in a home-guild raid that is happening at the same time?
For all these reasons, your first option seems to be the much clearer and viable choice for v 1.6. It's cleaner, more effective, and creates real changes to the BoH community. It is more aligned with the view that the developers said on Facebook, to re-create the light competition that guilds used to have, and reduce the effect of mercs on guild loyalty by avoiding guilds from becoming mere raid hosts.
But of course we speak in the hypothetical. Your predictions could be completely wrong, and my reply would be completely wasted too
