Book of Heroes

Some BoH history and my views on v1.6 and mercing

japster

ModeratorSat Apr 13, 2013 3:33 pm
I posted this initially as a reply in another thread which was discussing about requesting for guild coalitions in v1.6, and someone commenting on how v1.6 will ruin the community spirit of BoH, and another asking what the point of clan tags was. I have now decided to air my views here as well, for wider discussion. Just to put my record out, I've been playing BoH since Novemeber 2011, and there are honestly very few other players in the game right now who have played this longer than me, so I pretty much have a good grasp of the history of BoH.

To be honest, I am looking forward to guild competition once more. Just fyi, some BoH history. Clan tags were created by my guild, The Crimson Guards, and shortly after a slew of other top guilds back then (CB, KGW, Zen etc) followed our example and started tagging. The reason why the tags were created were due to a symbol of guild pride and loyalty as we fiercely fought it out for rankings. The BoH game thrived despite the rivalry. Mercing was not popular and the aberrant behavior, not the norm.

Why and how did mercing rise? There was a long LONG dry spell of content and people started getting burnt out. There was no reason to compete (back then there was no weekly leader board, no elixir of commerce etc, and guilds were still fiercely fighting to be no.1; but without incentive eventually it became pointless) and Venan was terribly slow with updates (for example, weekly leaderboard rewards came a long time after the burn out had entered a serious stage). Also double valor weekend and bonus valor weekends happened too often, more too often than Venan would like to admit, leading to players maxing out or reaching max quickly with nothing to do. As players quit/took a break, guilds all started suffering and mercing began to rise. Venan has learnt their lesson from that crazy fall out of players, and I am confident they are now working round the clock to release content more quickly, and occupy us with more tasks/grinds, such as enchants and raising the hero training cap.

Eventually, the previously top guilds that worked on loyalty were overtaken by a new style of guilds that worked on mercs. And that's how the mercing trend ballooned and grew. Mercy mercing happened only because the loyalty-based guilds faltered. It was a genuine and helpful behavior. However it spawned an entirely different social and psychological phenomena. Players started to feel it was the "easy way" out. After all, why commit to one guild's raid schedule, strategize raid rosters, collect data of all guild members and their time zones, coordinate and ask when members are more free to raid etc just to develop the perfect raid plan? Just join someone else's guild as and when I like and ta-da! Job done!

Merc-ing, while it caters to players who certainly cannot find a guild that fits them, also slowly evolved into influencing the attitude of players in BoH so that they no longer bothered trying to manage a closed-door guild properly. "It takes too much effort, so just merc", would be the common mentality of today.

There isn't a right or wrong answer, but about how Venan wants to shape the game. They obviously think it's not desirable that so little emphasis is now placed on guild loyalty and management (which used to be the NORM and PREVALENT), and they want to restore some order to it.

Clan tags today are now used merely for identification, and IMO, the pride that was once associated with it has faded away. Ask any veteran players from the old top guilds and they would know what competition really meant. And BoH was just as fun. I mean I am still enjoying BoH now, just as I was enjoying it in the past.

Venan has promised us they would bring back light competition, and not ruin mercing. It's too premature to say 1.6 will ruin everything. Let's see how they handle the balance. But I would want to assure you BoH is not going to suddenly die or stop being unique because of v1.6.
As someone who started right when guilds started, I agree with your core points - I am even nothing in the preview that considers me as long as my reading between the lines about part 2 is correct. OTOH, I thought guild competition was the pits and still do. There was a certain level of nastiness and top level guilds treating players bad forcing them to prioritize game over RL. My guild in those days was second tier (15-25 range), but I heard enough stories from people who moved up in those days and later returned. I sure hope that doesn't come back.

One thing I absolutely don't miss from the old days is high level guilds constantly running recruitment ads. They were counterproductive. The more ads that were ran the less likely I was to consider your guild (I have switched guilds twice) and in fact I avoided such guilds once mercing took off.

Fortunately, at least right now a few top level guilds are prioritizing RL. But then again, I see some that are pushing their members IMHO.
Bbbb wrote:As someone who started right when guilds started, I agree with your core points - I am even nothing in the preview that considers me as long as my reading between the lines about part 2 is correct. OTOH, I thought guild competition was the pits and still do. There was a certain level of nastiness and top level guilds treating players bad forcing them to prioritize game over RL. My guild in those days was second tier (15-25 range), but I heard enough stories from people who moved up in those days and later returned. I sure hope that doesn't come back.

One thing I absolutely don't miss from the old days is high level guilds constantly running recruitment ads. They were counterproductive. The more ads that were ran the less likely I was to consider your guild (I have switched guilds twice) and in fact I avoided such guilds once mercing took off.

Fortunately, at least right now a few top level guilds are prioritizing RL. But then again, I see some that are pushing their members IMHO.

Well if rumors of 100 limit true along with nerfing mercs in name of rivalry then the recruiting will be back. So poor lower guilds will not only be screwed trying to cover the might spread in majority of guilds they are going to have their best players head hunted. I can not see how these changes can be benefit anyone but top 50 to 100 guilds. It will not promote loyalty as those players who can't rely on mercs to do raids at their might level will either be stuck doing raids at lowest might of guild or leaving to higher guild.
You can't wind back to past, the guild situation has evolved and trying to put genie back in bottle is going to hurt a lot of new players and guilds.
You are right the focus needs to be on new content keeping players interested....this is not new content that is going to help in this issue or is it going to stop captains valor guilds migrating into low valor guilds in guild events that killed competition in last guild events.

japster

ModeratorMon Apr 15, 2013 5:03 am
I just want to point out that if they don't actually change raid difficulties, and allow guild size to balloon to 100, it is not inconceivable for top guilds to run Kraken, Lockbolt, Zuur, Hellion raids etc along with GK and VG.

That way a guild need not be truly "exclusive" to a limited might range, and new players can easily find homes in well-established guilds as well. Training guilds can be "merged" into the main guilds without much of a hitch. Top players can help new players in the same guild, and everyone can benefit from loyalty.

And the option for players trying to start a guild from scratch still exists, as long as they work on proper management and recruitment.

What WOULD screw new players over would be a blanket increase in raid difficulty across all raids to match the increased guild size. New/medium-sized guilds would be hard-pressed to accomplish anything without more recruitment. It's going to be a difficult balance for the developers to reach, to ask themselves at which point in the spectrum of raids where difficulties should be raised fairly to accommodate the increased guild size.

I think we are all waiting with bated breath for part 2 of the updates. Hopefully there isn't a catch to the increased guild size, although that may be too good to be true.
Great post Japster, as another long time player, I don't recall the date but it was looong before guilds and gems and the like were ever thought of, I echo most of your sentiments.

I was a part of a mid tier guild for a while and then moved to CB back when we were raiding Helion and Zuur - to be a part of CB back in those days meant something. We, and the other top guilds (but mostly CB :-)) were fiercely contesting for top spot and competitions. It was awesome. Yet I recall the days of the mid tiered guild too and trying to build a successful guild and keep it together was not easy.

I'm pretty cranky at venan generally and so I kinda fear the worst, but with guild loyalty, I sincerely hope we get back to a more predominantly guild-centric platform.

japster

ModeratorMon Apr 15, 2013 9:04 am
Asandir wrote:Great post Japster, as another long time player, I don't recall the date but it was looong before guilds and gems and the like were ever thought of, I echo most of your sentiments.

I was a part of a mid tier guild for a while and then moved to CB back when we were raiding Helion and Zuur - to be a part of CB back in those days meant something. We, and the other top guilds (but mostly CB :-)) were fiercely contesting for top spot and competitions. It was awesome. Yet I recall the days of the mid tiered guild too and trying to build a successful guild and keep it together was not easy.

I'm pretty cranky at venan generally and so I kinda fear the worst, but with guild loyalty, I sincerely hope we get back to a more predominantly guild-centric platform.

Oh yea...do people still remember the CK -> Vallus jump? That literally tore guilds apart. It was a true test of guild management and teamwork just to surmount that barrier to get everyone growing their might together. There wasn't any other way to raise might besides argue whether to do more Zuur - CK - Zuur or Hellion - CK. Why you ask? Because Hellion was a freaking 6 hour raid! :P

Today? People just go to the Black Market :P Haha...ok I HAD to take a swipe at that, sorry to the newer guys lol
Asandir wrote: I sincerely hope we get back to a more predominantly guild-centric platform.

I don't. What seems to be whitewashed over from that era was the guilds (some not all) who treated their players poorly. Raid all day long whether you needed to work or not or get the boot. I'm afraid that some guilds might get back to that way.

I have been everything from full-time mercing toons to being a GM so I have seen the game from all angles. I'd prefer Venan just embrace that guild concept played out and are "raid rooms" and make that work better.

I think the "guild loyalty" as they are presenting it will tip the balance 5-10% more towards guilds (purely from player greed) but not fundamentally change anything.