Book of Heroes

Balancing 1h and 2h

I'm currently using sword and shield for my justicar and after 30 levels, I have some thoughts and suggestions.

The advantages and disadvantages for 1h I can see are

Advantages
- blocking 50% damage
- faster speed than 2h (not directly due to the shield)

Disadvantages
- needs 4 more gems to reach 2h levels
- unable to enchant shield/off hand weapon

As the game progressed, I find that hero training (leveling) and higher tier gems lessened the speed advantage and with enough damage done, and health potions, the damage mitigation advantage is also lessened. However, neither leveling nor gems take away the disadvantages.

The disadvantages perhaps were imposed to off set the advantages but they seem a bit over much to me in view of the fact that leveling already decreases the purported advantages of shields.

Suggestions
- removal of one of the disadvantages (gems with equal bonus on 1h or allow shield enchanting)
- increase block rate or mitigation amount (to maximize stagger or potion use)

On going through the forums, the general feel is that not many players would choose 1h over 2h these days so I think it could be a majority opinion that 1h is disadvantaged somehow.

Hope this suggestion can be taken into consideration.

japster

ModeratorMon Apr 15, 2013 3:31 am
I agree in principle 1handers are extremely weak compared to their 2h counterparts.

In fact the only reason why shadow walkers are so "fast" is because they are limited to 1h weapons. If they could use 2h weapons i bet you most of them would unless they are farming onslaught (in which case every class uses 1h weapons anyway if they want to be efficient right now).

Something has to be done about 1handers. IMO the best solution is to let 1hander weapons get x4 multiplier and the offhand x2, so you get more stats with a 1hander, but you trade-off with much weaker damage.

Honestly, the speed factor is pretty useless as a gamer unless I am farming onslaught (after all, the less button presses I take the faster I am in real time, e.g. a 2hit kill on LOB will be faster in real time than you taking 6 fast but separate actions to finish a boss). And that's only because right now might levels have progressed way beyond the current onslaught raid difficulties. I mean come on, the bulk of onslaught farmers today are all 3 to 4 times over the might requirement of that raid. If there was a comparative onslaught raid right now with monsters the toughness of VG/Portal level 4 (13-14k might min req), a 1hander will be pretty crappy as well unless the toon is literally maxxed out with elixirs and potions.

I raised this point long before when v1.4 was coming out but developers said "1handers are still strong" or along those lines because of their speed. Honestly, it's patently untrue. One GLANCE at the leaderboards tell you how unfavorable and useless 1handers are amongst mages and justicars.

Lastly, another method would be to raise mob difficulties to the point where they hit so hard and fast having a shield actually makes a difference (but then SW would cry). Because right now, damage is still unfortunately the name of the game in BoH, despite what developers tried to do in v1.5.

Initially some encounters were relatively tough, but due to all the increase in max might and enchants, as well as nerfing of the vile slugs and elite behemoth encounters, monsters are now mostly trivial once more after you hit a certain point, making shields obsolete in late game.