I'm currently using sword and shield for my justicar and after 30 levels, I have some thoughts and suggestions.
The advantages and disadvantages for 1h I can see are
Advantages
- blocking 50% damage
- faster speed than 2h (not directly due to the shield)
Disadvantages
- needs 4 more gems to reach 2h levels
- unable to enchant shield/off hand weapon
As the game progressed, I find that hero training (leveling) and higher tier gems lessened the speed advantage and with enough damage done, and health potions, the damage mitigation advantage is also lessened. However, neither leveling nor gems take away the disadvantages.
The disadvantages perhaps were imposed to off set the advantages but they seem a bit over much to me in view of the fact that leveling already decreases the purported advantages of shields.
Suggestions
- removal of one of the disadvantages (gems with equal bonus on 1h or allow shield enchanting)
- increase block rate or mitigation amount (to maximize stagger or potion use)
On going through the forums, the general feel is that not many players would choose 1h over 2h these days so I think it could be a majority opinion that 1h is disadvantaged somehow.
Hope this suggestion can be taken into consideration.
The advantages and disadvantages for 1h I can see are
Advantages
- blocking 50% damage
- faster speed than 2h (not directly due to the shield)
Disadvantages
- needs 4 more gems to reach 2h levels
- unable to enchant shield/off hand weapon
As the game progressed, I find that hero training (leveling) and higher tier gems lessened the speed advantage and with enough damage done, and health potions, the damage mitigation advantage is also lessened. However, neither leveling nor gems take away the disadvantages.
The disadvantages perhaps were imposed to off set the advantages but they seem a bit over much to me in view of the fact that leveling already decreases the purported advantages of shields.
Suggestions
- removal of one of the disadvantages (gems with equal bonus on 1h or allow shield enchanting)
- increase block rate or mitigation amount (to maximize stagger or potion use)
On going through the forums, the general feel is that not many players would choose 1h over 2h these days so I think it could be a majority opinion that 1h is disadvantaged somehow.
Hope this suggestion can be taken into consideration.