Book of Heroes

Shadow Walker Specialization

So I've been hearing a lot about two specs, the poison and the melee. I am interested in hearing how people are experiencing the two in with pros and cons to both so others like myself can better decide which works better for ourselves.

What's best for leveling? What's good for end game?
I have a 25K might Poison/Magic SW I play daily and a level 18 Melee SW that I play on rare occasions. At least to level 18, I think the melee was easier to level (however, my poison one leveled during 1.3 and there was no assassinate). As far as the end game, 6 of one, half dozen of the other from my sources who have both. Poison is better at mobs, Melee better at bosses. Poison is built around debuffs, DoT and constantly watching the word "poisoned" appear on your screen. Melee is built around trying to crit as much as possible.

Just keep in mind that Venan totally changed the SW when 1.5 hit. Previously, hybrid was the way to go. 1.6 won't change much if anything, but with 1.7 anything is possible.
I am currently leveling a Melee built SW, and he is up to lvl 28 atm. I tried the poison spec, and B is right, the poisons are good for mobs, though it can take a while for the DoT to tick enough to kill them, I was finding myself using Defend or Normal attack while things were on Cooldown. With Melee, I found Assassinate, Critical Eye, Piercing Strike, Reflexive Strike, and the Normal attack all more useful to my playstyle. Every move is boosted by Critical Eye (20% more chance to crit) and if I had to resort to a normal attack, it was still the same type of attack (physical) as the rest of my moves, so it benifited from the Melee gems and tomes. Melee does seem to fare better on single targets like a boss. I have started a new SW and will be trying out the Poison spec more and see how it goes toward the later levels, though.
I started as a melee SW and stuck to it through about 18k might. It works really nicely, and does quite well. However, I've recently switched to a slightly more hybrid build to take advantage of the poison (currently 60-40 melee/magic). Dropped maneuver, caltrops, riposte, and dodge altogether. So far it's working really nicely but time will tell.
Quoted from Crzy 'with SW you have yo sacrifice something,you need speed you sacrifice crit, you need crit power you sacrifice melee or magic etc... Hate that ****'

I agree with Crzy 100%. As a SW. We have to make a choice between our skill set and ability and gems choices.... Where justicar can go all melee, Mage is all magic without a single doubt.
I was a hybrid(40 melee 60 magic) until I was around 15k might I changed to (30 melee 70magic)
Later on I changed my SW to completely magic, becoz i use group attack so much that I barely use other physical attack.
I can one shot mob in VG with potions cloud. When I'm lucky, Acid spray can clear mob too (with assassinate to help clear the left over) but I suffer from the constant poison pop up.
For behemoth, takes me 2 hit to kill, I haven't had any chance to one hit behemoth so far.

I'm tempted to try a physical SW( tired of the poison pop up) but I only have 6 melee t5 gems atm :( I want to know if anyone try a physical SW too, since physical SW can only use basic weapon attack, piercing strike, reflexive strike and caltrops ( which doesn't do initial damage)
I'm 30%/70% melee/magic, and I''l keep it this way as I believe this build suits onslaught better (esp. SC).
For the purposes of regular raids / farming I would migrate to predominantly magic build.. but I really see no point as ANY build is OK for regular raiding..

Yellow gems = 10 haste + 6 crit
Red = 10 magic + 4 melee

Never bought or used a dodge gem and never cared about the blue ones (currently all blue should be crit pwr, but I never got the patience to swap these around)

I think physical build for SW is..uh..sustainable, but a bit bizarre. And definitely not too good in terms of crowd control later on.

FYI so far SC is the best build test grounds ever.
Grnm wrote:
FYI so far SC is the best build test grounds ever.

I disagree. You can optimize for CoC, optimize for SC or optimize for regular raids. Sure they overlap some, but all three have different needs for maximum performance. There is no best test ground - okay, if I was forced to pick one, I'd pick WoF. I will say that getting a good SC build is the most difficult of the three though.

Tiffy and Zaja took opposite routes to max might. Tiffy went heavy on onslaught. Zaja (ok, he is a Mage though) never ran one. You can pick your own path.
Tiffy wrote:
I'm tempted to try a physical SW( tired of the poison pop up) but I only have 6 melee t5 gems atm :( I want to know if anyone try a physical SW too, since physical SW can only use basic weapon attack, piercing strike, reflexive strike and caltrops ( which doesn't do initial damage)

DanceMonkey has two high might SWs (20K+) - one magic and one physical. I think he prefers the physical one. He's not on much anymore but if you see him on chat, ask him (I don't remember him posting on forum).
I have been playing BoH for 11 weeks so far.

First week when I play BoH. I focus on getting my might to GK might
2nd week I only GK and VG and got my full t14 gears in a week and some t5 gems
My third week of BoH. I started doing some CoC and still do VG and GK to get Cv( need the valor for haste gems)
When Venan nerfed Haste. I did CoC even more aggressive as I fear they will nerf haste further more.
Another reason I focus on hero token more than gems becoz I was waiting for double valor weekend, I got about 60-80k cv during double valor and got full t5 gems. ( I have been buying t5 gems in black market too)
Also when I raid, I'm a huge burner, I don't sit there and wait for energy Regen, I will keep hitting till raid ends, so CoC satisfy me a lot as I don't have to burn as much as I would need to in VG ( I used to burn 100-200gs in each Cv raid I do :cry: )

Nearly 3 months of BoH. Got me to 31k might so far, all I left is enchant which I'm very lazy when it comes to farming portal.

There is always another way to get hero token without doing any CoC ... Just buy it. I know a few players that max their hero training simply just buy all of them. ( one of them is about 15k might ? Didn't even unlock Dragonmoor yet...) you can tell from a player's HS if they buy their hero token or not too. Even if they didn't do any CoC. Assume a player do VG, get 109k CV which comes with 67k Hero token. And that would give about 128k hero score. If someone only do Cv raid to get max hero training. That's around 700k HS there.