Book of Heroes

40 player limit on raids

That number is for guild member only? Or does that include mercs?

Also anyone know if cool down times have been shortened. To me it seems the 40 man limit is quiet annoying esp when guild size is now 100.
10 for GG, 20 for other SqV raids and onslaught, 30 or 40 for the rest.

20 for onslaught seems really low for guilds that enjoy onslaught style.

The problem with man limits is that the pop-in/pop-out member of a guild may potentially displace an otherwise more committed but late raider. The pop-in player may feel guilty for taking a slot, or may be pressured into leaving or fighting more than able (leading casual players to leave the game).

Another issue is the helplessness of being present but unable to help a raid because it is full.
Worst crap every, guess gotta live with it. Since I can't make raid time exactly on the dot I guess I wont be raid again.

The only thing worse is if Venan made it so you can only raid once per 24hrs. And that is generous. Wtf went theough their heads when designing raid limits at 30 for gk when guild size is now 100?
Was looking forward to 1.6 and playin after a break. Long time player and done now. I show up late for guild raid and I cant get in cause I have a real life. Forget this, I wont be back
The limits are completely awful. Let me outline the issues:

1. Person shows up late and can't even get into the raid.
2. Person does 100 RPP, an emergency comes up and they having to leave eating up a slot. Meanwhile, the person above who can play is locked out.
3. If you open to mercs, you are libel to end up suffering from basically a denial of service attack on your raid. I guess you have to use the password but that's another level of headache.
4. Raid is failing and the raid is full. You are screwed. AFAIK there is no way for anyone to leave a raid (and lose their RPP) even if they wanted to.
5. Intra-guild bickering is going to start. Here are the topics:
A. Player gets locked out and gets pissed off.
B. Player does a small amount of RPP, raid fills but fails later. People are going to jump his case.
C. Expectations are going to start about people needing to be on raids from start to finish.
6. The CV players get 3 choices - 20, 30 or 40 raiders plus factor in cooldowns (which I think are bogus anyway). But then you have 100 members, you are going to have a hard time satisfying everybody. I think the 100 may turn out to be a huge disadvantage as people will get pissed off. Plus many of us are close to CV Max and have little interest in GK now that the other raids will drop essence/flux.

The short of it is that it undermines the drop in and play way of playing. I am rarely able to make a raid from start to finish. I do a lot of 3-5K RPP raids though.

Also, I have concerns about the wave counts, but want to see actual numbers before going there.

I'm extremely unhappy with this feature. I have been playing almost a year and I have to say it is the single worst thing you all have ever done by a long shot and the first time I saw something that could end my playing days. I've got games queued up and maybe it is time to start on those.
I agree the raid wave counts are way too high and I'm currently in a guild doing a raid that they can't finish as I sit here with my 42e and 2 pots waiting for them to fail so I can help the next raid if I make it in time. This update will kill mercing because people won't trust them to put in enough e. the best part about the game was crying out for help in a raid for gold and having a merc come in and save the day. The update just has 30 people raiding while the other 70 go off and help an other guild get a boost on the leader rankings
This needs to be tweaked for sure, but I don't see raid limits going away completely. Remember, now you can raid with other raids without leaving your own.

In 1.5 the raid limit was equal to the guild limit and it was common to be booted multiple times a day from your own guild just for not showing up to the raid.

Now the raid limit would be infinite without an enforced limit.

Not that there isn't a TON of issues that I think were possibly overlooked by the developers, but limits definitely have the purpose of allowing for the new streamlined system of merc'ing and keeping guilds together for longer than the duration of a raid and energy recharge time.

I also don't think having 100 raiders is ever going to be realistic. It seems that those are spots for alts and such or people catching up and doing lower end raids. It is very awkward, however, to have different player limits for different raids. You have to play favorites for raids that allow less people if all the guild's raiders show or just do "first come first show and everyone else can go farm a portal for all I care"
The caps are pretty harsh, especially for lower-level raids that don't typically attract much interest. Maybe removing the caps except for CV raids would work.
I totally agree with what has been expressed in this thread. The developers are making a big mistake and I seriously think they killed the things that made this game enjoyable.