Book of Heroes

Remove raid cap. · page 3

Getting back to the intention of this thread.

Venan does not understand the social network they've created. This game flourished because it was casual, fun, easy, and social. Raid caps is only part of the problem...it's understandable you would have raid caps when increasing size of the guild..you don't want 100 players playing thro raid after raid in minutes..fine. But by making raids longer (a lesson we thought you learned when you reduced the times in previous updates) then locking such tight numbers in to the raid. The social environment goes from a guild looking to help one another to 30 ppl feeling the pressure to commit and get it done. I don't care if gold is 15 minutes..have at it..but Venan is killing the casual social nature of this game and losing customers.

Guild loyalty is a great idea..but the implementation is a fail. Mainly because you've killed the merc system and "silo'd" guilds together. Instead of having a steady chance to go outside the guild and get to know your BoH community..now most of the time you're locked in. The point of this they say us to create guild competition..but eventually I won't know NBW from HJ, Spoons, we'll just be a number moving beyond another number!

In sum, upping the raid caps is the least you could do to salvage the casual social network you've created because I believe you have bigger problems on the horizon and that is how to keep your BoH community connected to one another.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun May 12, 2013 6:41 pm
I am going to back Fero on this, there are two serious issues at stake with the 1.6 additions (note you guys did a lot right...overall I think the effort is a success), and these two items need to be addressed:

1. Social aspects of the game. You guys did a great job making merc'ing a more specialized and streamlined task...but as Cerri and I have commented here: Visit Friends in other Guilds Feature
There is a major isolation that is happening between the different guilds, communities and players.
Fero just stated it clearly as well:
Ferocee wrote:
Mainly because you've killed the merc system and "silo'd" guilds together. Instead of having a steady chance to go outside the guild and get to know your BoH community..now most of the time you're locked in.
Personally I do not think you necessarily killed the merc system, though competitive guilds are no longer allowing mercs at all and its easier to do with the larger guild member cap, but you definitely killed the social aspect of the game brought about by merc'n. This is something I am missing now...I will not leave my current guild because of the loyalty benefits I like....but now I can't even visit other guilds I have had a strong friendship with. (Primarily because they generally aren't opening slots for mercs...and as much as Nikos suggestion makes sense in the other thread..its a hassle to implement..IMHO).

2. Raid commitment times etc.
Casual gaming is taking a beating. There is no easy answer but I would offer this idea.
You cant make Gold so hard as to require burning, but also there is no reason to make it easy..however the problem you have as I see it is is scale...If you lift the cap, gold will become easy again and nothing special...if you lower the raid wave req to lower time, well...same problem...however by making Gold challenging...you have also made silver and bronze very demanding as well...in that they now take a long time and still require a demanding player effort from each slot allow in the raid cap.

I do not know how easy it would be to do this, but I think a solution maybe dynamic raid caps.

Keep raid caps where they are: but once Gold time passes and silver time starts, lift the cap by 10-20 peeps, and maybe the merc cap by another 5 or some combination. Then again once Bronze time begins.
This way a Guild can decide how casual to play...if the guild knows ahead of time that they don't have the burners or full e members to hit gold, then casual people will drop in, take cap slots, dump e and leave causally knowing that once silver comes other players can show up and drop their e to help and that the cap will not be an issue.

That is one approach...the point is, in order to keep gold a challenge, but not make silver and bronze still as demanding of player commitment and allowing for casual guilds to still win raids and enjoy the game...allow dynamic cap adjustment based on gold/silver/bronze time frame.

Just throwing an idea out there.
I think some outside the box solutions needs to be looked at. Eliminate gold/silver/bronze and just make it a sliding function for payout. Or make the raids a fixed amount of time, uncap them, and make payout based on how much was done.

I'm not saying those are the best solutions, but I think either the change needs to be reverted or the system needs a fundamental overhaul. Just patching it isn't going to resolve the issues - just mitigate at best.