Here is what I don't understand; you want raids harder, and from what I can tell they are MUCH harder in terms of waves and time for gold. The addition of a raid cap really hurts casual players because they likely won't get in (they log on say 30 mins after start), and hurts the more dedicated players because only gold is acceptable.
What if there was an option to either do "in house" only raids (casual) that mercs cannot join and is for the guild only. This would be the current raids (possibly increased cap limit a little?). You could then make an option for raids to be in a "hardcore" mode; it would have increased rewards and a stricter timing limit, and mercs could join. Or maybe my idea is backwards and should be flipped lol.
I just think its really depressing for players to log on and be unable to raid because its full (and telling a guild to start another raid is BS, most of the top guilds run CV, and the cool downs usually don't expire til after the other raid is done anyway....and people who need CV don't want to run KV raids).
The raids should be reworked to where there is no cap limit and either the raid is longer or lower rewards, or have 2 tiers of raids guilds can start depending on whether they r hardcore or casual, or something else done so that people who show up late don't end up short changed.
Also, I did numbers on VG, and once players get to lvl5 loyalty the extra 8e will make gold require almost no GS/pot burning.
To summarize, issues with caps plus added raid wave totals are the following:
* Casual raiders are left out because (a) they do not want to use a valuable slot in the raid if they cannot raid long enough to reach the average RPP needed to complete the raid, or (b) they arrive to late for the raid and cannot get in because the raid is full.
* Moderate raiders liked shorter duration raids because they require less of a time commitment.
* With guild membership allowed to swell to 100, there may not be enough top raid slots to go around, and the new loyalty rules make switching guilds prohibitive.
I personally think it would be lots of fun to be involved in a VG raid with 80 members, that could be completed in an hour (or less). Or allowing a VG raid with 80 members so casual raiders know they can have a slot, only dump 3k RPP and know they are not hurting their guild. Neither of these options are very challenging, and probably should not earn an award higher than bronze level, but it would restore a casual and fun raiding style to the game that is lacking at the moment. Raids in 1.6 seem overly serious.
DnT_Eliel_ wrote:[*] Every 5 minutes that the raid progresses during which no new RPP were earned, 150 RPP is deducted from each merc's score (think of it as a 'disloyalty' marker--your guild is happy that you're helping other people, but if you're just over their chatting instead of raiding, then ...).
So you're saying everyone has to constantly remain online during the entire raid, even when they have no energy, to prevent being penalized? That's ridiculous, unless I'm misunderstanding something.
Mithrid wrote:CrackaG wrote:Lets do the math on this. Lets say a 1200 wave raid with 30 people at say 18 stam. That is 270 attacks. 45 min to refill. Another 270 attacks. Total at 540.
Another 45 min. Guild raid time at 1 hour and a half. 810 attacks. That time frame is way past gold. So silver is the norm now. Now say 30 people at 50 stam. Thats 750 attacks. About 2 hours to full. So 1 hour and thrity min for gold you would have to attack again with everyone again with 30stam. 15 attacks each person 450 attacks. Raid was at 1200 waves. No way get gold unless everyone spent gs. Oh and 30 stam is 1.25 hours. Well it will be close. Check my math on that.
Cracka,
I'm not certain which raid you are referring too, also the 18 stam is low for every toon to begin with, but here is a specific example:
VG currently has ~2010 waves (it could be a bit more but I have been unable to pin down the exact number--stop dying or leaving the raid people..especially when you do it in combinations that allow for 2 or 3 wave scenarios!!
)
40 Toons allowed
Gold is 2:20 minutes or 140 minutes
To Hit gold the Guild needs to burn 4020e in 140 minutes or roughly 28.71 e/min
There are several ways to do this, by e/unit time or by total E generated. Ill use total e as its conceptually easier.
(sorry guys, you all know how much I love equations)
E per toon: Etoon = Estart + Ereg where Ereg = 2* (140/5) : 140 minutes to gold / 5 minutes per 2e
Etoon = Estart + 56 (NOTE: ignoring E Regn enchant or elixirs...assuming all standard E regen rate)
Full 40 toons = 40*Estart + 2240 = 4020 e for gold in nick of time.
(Solve for Estart)
So the amount of E each of the full 40 toons needs at the beginning to hit Gold without burning:
Gold: Estart = 44.5e
Silver (40 minutes more): = 28.5e
To Hit Gold without burning, with no time margin, requires the Guild to fill all 40 spots with max e toons, with at least 26 of them Lvl 4 loyalty toons, who contribute e the whole time. Assuming a guild has 80 -100 members, and many Lvl4 or Lvl5 loyal members...this should be feasible.
Is it difficult: Hell yeah...impossible...nope, especially if you have 100 toons in a guild to choose from, to fill the raid.
Note Silver is quite reasonable.
Granted every Raid needs an analysis, but this is VG. Gold is feasible without burning, yes Gold is a challenge...I think its about right. (My opinion on this last statement)
How quickly does that change when 5 out of the 40 have something come up IRL and only burn their first 42e? Or how about the guilds that don't have 40 people waiting with their phones on their hands ready to go the second the raid opened? What about guilds who gets stuck with multiple mercs who do one hit and leave? Any one of these things happening makes gold impossible unless multiple people are burning GS.
Mike,
Thanks for the response...but you have ruined the game. I log on less now and so do most of my guild. No matter what your intentions were it still looks like all you are doing is trying to increase profit. Caps on raids remove the party atmosphere. It also keeps newer players from advancing.
No harm in putting it back...it wasn't broken...you didn't have to fix it.
Thad wrote:
How quickly does that change when 5 out of the 40 have something come up IRL and only burn their first 42e? Or how about the guilds that don't have 40 people waiting with their phones on their hands ready to go the second the raid opened? What about guilds who gets stuck with multiple mercs who do one hit and leave? Any one of these things happening makes gold impossible unless multiple people are burning GS.
Thad,
I understand as well as anyone that RL happens...for which case I think Gold shouldn't be feasible as a casual raid. So in this point we disagree...I think Gold should be reserved for those cases where everyone can fully work together and dedicate themselves to the raid...thats the Gold standard if you will.
I do think where we will agree on though, is that Silver and Bronze should NOT be too difficult considering RL. Currently they are...Silver still requires a great effort of constantly raiding toons..and it last a long time. Bronze should easily be doable with decent effort of the guild in a casual raiding style...and this is where I have issue..it currently is not.
Mith I think the problem is that let's say of the 40 members that originally commit to the raid only 5 get something come up RL after being 30 mins in the raid & so the raid is forced to be silver. The 35 remaining originally thought the raid is going to last say 2h20 and now it is going to last 3 hours because they already lost 5 people early in the raid, but after 2h30 of the remaining 35 that were still emptying maybe 3 or 5 (for example) have something else planned or RL & can't keep emptying. The silver starts to be endangered, the remaining 30 are feeling tired, annoyed & stressed & they have even other members of the guild coming up online & full that would be willing to help but they just can't. They have to keep going, use shields or cancel the raid because Venan decided no one else should be able to help them. Does this sound realistic? Does it really sound fair to you that because the raid is considered casual because 5 members had something come up RL in the beginning of the raid & 5 other had not planned to spend more than 2h30 in the raid or have other things coming up the other 30 are stuck there & helpless from people from their own guild? Like I said I don't need all my raids to be gold, by all means, please take gold away from me, set it to the speed raid event results & get rid off the caps.
So basically shorten raids. But if it's too short you'll find that you won't get very much for your efforts. It takes 10 hits to build up to 150 RPP per round. You want to end the raid before you get a chance to enjoy the benefit of building up? :p Personally I think dynamic caps based on your current level (G/S/B) is a good idea.
Looking at Devs responses to their reasons for the changes further proves they don't understand why their game became so popular. I'm tossing out the argument of gold/silver/bronze...it's understood Venan wanted to make it tougher deal with it. But by changing merc behavior, and therefore restricting casual gamers AND implementing raid caps, Venan has fundamentally changed what made them successful. No longer can the BoH community band together and help a failed raid...no longer can you just pop into a guild and say hi and help them out (without going thro a bunch of hoops first)...guilds have been quarantined off from a free flow of visitors and daily interactions that was a draw for a majority of its' players. Their response says a light sense of guild...but in essence they forced guilds together, killed casual guilds who had a few raids and Merc'd around (and don't tell me it can still happen in 1.6 because it isn't happening and I know of 2 such guilds that have since folded) the raid caps have turned it from a thanks for coming chit chat to you gotta perform to be in this raid---> that will quickly change the environment they've created. Why did they take a simple system and make it complex? If the official answer is you wanted gold harder to achieve and a sense of guild then you have failed..a vast majority of players knew what guild they belonged too. You get an A for gameplay in 1.6 but you have failed in so many other areas that I think you have a serious problem on your hands.
Agree with Fero's post but remove "I think" from the final line.
Pre-update I constantly Merced everywhere all the time and knew tons of people. Since the update, I Merced exactly twice. Earning guild loyalty is the priority for me now and there are hardly any raids even if I wanted to.
I am going to lose touch with many friends because I don't run across them. What are the odds I am going to make new ones? Almost zero. This does not bode well for the long term.
The problem is that Venan didn't intend to create the best aspect of this game and have never understood it. Katy and Beekeo mostly stayed in BL and didn't get out much or at all. Dave hid out in ARC but I am not sure I ever saw him talk in the months I was an officer there. And so. Darkhorse gets around but I suspect he came into the picture after the feature set was figured out. My point is that in the future fundamental changes need to be run by an advisory board or focus group of a few players. I think the players could have foreseen many of the issues that have come with the update.