Book of Heroes

Remove Raid Participation Cap · page 2

TCG_japster wrote:I'm starting to get the impression it isn't the raid cap people really have an issue with, but that they miss having their easy gold timings.

And your impression is wrong. Read the second paragraph of Niko's post right below yours - it sums up the anti-cap argument and does not mention gold.

Some people have do have an issue with the gold thing, but others don't. If you pay attention, many people (e.g. me and Mith) have either taken a pro or neutral stance on the gold issue yet are arguing against the cap.

japster

ModeratorFri May 10, 2013 4:43 pm
Bbbb wrote:
TCG_japster wrote:I'm starting to get the impression it isn't the raid cap people really have an issue with, but that they miss having their easy gold timings.

And your impression is wrong. Read the second paragraph of Niko's post right below yours - it sums up the anti-cap argument and does not mention gold.

Some people have do have an issue with the gold thing, but others don't. If you pay attention, many people (e.g. me and Mith) have either taken a pro or neutral stance on the gold issue yet are arguing against the cap.

Yea I read it, but my impression isn't wrong. By your own admission some people do have an issue with it. My impression is just inaccurate at worst. Anyway I made the reply in response to the 2nd and 3rd replies to the original TS's post, where both posters made references to gold timing and how they miss it. In that context, my impression was fairly justified.
I don't really care about the gold/silver/bronze issue. My biggest complaint is that it has killed casual raiding
I fully agree with Nipo. The current cap means if I have 1h to play in the morning before going to work, I will be harming the guild's chance in the raid. Dumping all one's energy and staying for a short time before real life calls is no longer a viable option. Also, it is no fun seeing your team members in a raid you want to join but can't due to the toon cap limit. Please increase the cap by 5 to 10. Thank you.
I too would like to echo the sentiments presented by others. I feel like these raid caps have killed casual raiding and as a casual raider, I do resent that.

But I would also like to bring up a point no one else has mentioned. That is the fact that the rewards for any given raid are constant. Bring 40 people? The rewards split 40 ways. Bring 100 people? The SAME reward now splits 100 ways. All other things being equal, that means in an uncapped raid with 100 you only get 40% of the valor that you would have got in the capped raid of 40. And the raid cooldown is still the same. That means that it will take longer for me to get the same amount of valor in uncapped raids. The longer I have to spend collecting valor for gear, the more likely that I will buy a few shields to speed up the process. Everybody wins.

I have no problem capping raids for speedruns, I even think it makes a lot of sense to. But enforcing the cap all the time, as many others have said, ruined the fun of casual raiding.

+1 for casual players!
Raid cap is ruining this game - people play this for fun, but now it's sooooo boring to have a raid take hours because of the ridiculous raid cap.
I'd have to agree that it isnt the timing people are upset with exactly, its the fact that they feel it is too hard to finish a raid with a limit on participants and how mercs can screw a raid. All it really takes is for your guild to be coordinated, dont start with raids having merc slots unless you see you need them. They just made raiding harder, not impossible, if you want casual raiding, merc into raids, dump your e, check back later to see if you need to dump more or if its done, if it fails then it shouldnt be an issue to a casual raider. Gold times should be for highly organized effort, top tier rewards etc, bronze is more of a fall back crutch where you didnt make par time so you get a small reward, maybe your guild isnt ready for that raid yet.
But if a casual raider mercs for another guild, that guild may get penalized with a lower payout. No honest merc wants to be a hindrance to the host guild's raid.
Venan

You said you implemented the raid caps to prevent abuse. What potential abuse were you thinking of?
Oda_Sadaar wrote:Venan

You said you implemented the raid caps to prevent abuse. What potential abuse were you thinking of?
Think about it, with the new raid finder, how easy would raids be if EVERYONE could participate in EVERY raid? Just spam in Global chat, everyone joins your guilds raid, 200+ participants, bam, easy gold time every time. The caps are there so that gold times are harder to get, it shouldnt be a given that every raid finishes with gold times, that would kinda make Gold less special to get... I like how it is now, especially since you can limit how many mercs are allowed in, and even set a PW for them. Helps make it more regulated on how good your guild is. I.E., if my guild wants to take on a new raid we havent done yet, we could say, "lets do it with no more than 10 mercs," if we cant do it, we put that one on hold till we can try again with more members and higher might.
I would like to see a place in the guild page, or officer/manage page so you can see the info about the guilds average might level.