Book of Heroes

A solution to the raid cap problem

It has been acknowledged that raid caps prevent casual players from dumping energy in raids, as these players would be taking up valuable raid places in a capped raid. (The old "limit" of 60 was high enough that these players didn't jeopardize raids) On the other hand, capped raids create more of a challenge to the dedicated player, many of whom were lamenting the lack of challenge in the game.

The solution (all right, one possible solution...)

At the time a raid is started, the raid can be set with a tight cap (cap value as it is now), a moderate cap (cap value * 1.5), or a loose cap (cap value * 2, or no cap at all). Raid lengths remain the same in any mode, however:
Raids completed at the moderate cap level can at best achieve silver rewards.
Raids completed at the loose cap level can only achieve bronze rewards.

Under this system, guilds can define themselves as guilds for dedicated players or guilds for casual players, or in some cases, 100-member guild caps could allow both to coexist...Ideal! As an example, a guild could start a tight-capped VG at a standard time, those dedicated players who arrive on time get in and go for gold. 30 minutes later, the same guild could start a moderately-capped or loosely-capped GK raid for the players who arrive late. When the dedicated players finish the VG raid, they can assist with the casual GK if they wish.

Why can't guilds do this now, you ask? If the most dedicated players fill the first VG raid, and casual players fill a tight-capped GK raid, the GK raid would be unlikely to finish. The casual player would still feel bad entering the GK raid as that place in the raid would still be at a premium. Loose caps allow casual players to enter raids without feeling like they are a drag on their guild.

Closing argument:

One of the strengths of Book of Heroes was that it had appeal to a wide variety of players and player styles. The current raid cap system narrows this scope. The above implementation should bring back the flexibility required to let this game appeal to a wider audience once again.
Excellent Suggestion!

I would just add one thing. Mid-raid you can increase the cap/lower the max payout if the raid is in trouble.

Darkhorse

Site AdminFri May 10, 2013 11:00 am
This is actually something we've already been considering, as is a sliding cap that can be chosen by guild officers that will change the reward output.

IF this is the route we decide to take, I will provide more information early next week.