Book of Heroes

Mercing - some suggestions on 1.6

1. Guild names in 'find raid' should be clickable - with a redirect to the guild page, so that if a low-lvl guild with low-might/lvl members starts a raid they cannot win - I won't waste my energy to get 'oh, damn, we've lost again' if their guild chat instead of valor points :D Right now you have to find a raid and then just join in and test your luck or go back, find a guild by its name and then check if it's capable of doing this raid.

2. Right now some guilds act somewhat irresponsible towards mercs: just got into a low-lvl raid to get some valor for low-lvl gems. The raid had 15 merc slots. Guild officer says one hour into the raid in guild chat: "Well guys, I've started this raid mostly for guild loyalty, so there's no problem if we won't finish it".

Question is why the hell did he start it with 15 merc slots and how do we protect mercs from wasting energy on such raids. Maybe mercs should be additionaly compensated in some way?

I don't know if it's a viable idea, but just as an option: one merc that joined should get himself something like 1.15 valor payout multiplayer, while guild members should get something like -0.01 per merc multiplier. So with 15 mercs that would be not 100% valor for guild members but 85%.

This can simulate what mercs really are: HIRED force, that are paid for by the guilds.

----

I appreciate the 'raid finder' that was implemented by 1.6 patch, but right now mercs are nothing special: for mercs it's just a way to get more raids if your guild is inactive and you have full energy bar to spend. Maybe my suggestion or something else would make being mercenary more interesting.
3. You should do something about inactive guilds, really. A guild starts CoC - you hop in - boom, they have 5 members in a raid, all with 1000-1500 RPP in the end. Why the hell people like that are even allowed to open merc slots?!

My proposal is as follows:

1) Guild should not be allowed to open merc slots if there are less than 15 guild members online AND less than 10 members in a raid. Even better if they could open those merc slots, but mercs couldn't join untill the numbers mentioned above are met.

2) Guilds that fail raids with open merc slots should be obviously punished: you decided to start a raid, you opened merc slots, mercs joined - you failed - no more merc slots for your guild for the next 24 hours.

Seems fair to me, ain't it?
Flameberg wrote:3. You should do something about inactive guilds, really. A guild starts CoC - you hop in - boom, they have 5 members in a raid, all with 1000-1500 RPP in the end. Why the hell people like that are even allowed to open merc slots?!

My proposal is as follows:

1) Guild should not be allowed to open merc slots if there are less than 15 guild members online AND less than 10 members in a raid. Even better if they could open those merc slots, but mercs couldn't join untill the numbers mentioned above are met.

2) Guilds that fail raids with open merc slots should be obviously punished: you decided to start a raid, you opened merc slots, mercs joined - you failed - no more merc slots for your guild for the next 24 hours.

Seems fair to me, ain't it?
Well,
A) A guilds progress is seen in the raid finder, along with number of participants, and time left. If you want a sure-fire win, find one that is almost complete and has plenty of time left and plenty of participants. I try to choose my raids more wisely so I can finish them, gaining 100-200 valor for joining an already nearly complete raid is far better than earning 300 valor you dont get cuz the raid wasnt moving when you joined it and threw all your energy at it.

B) Forbiding a guild to open merc slots wont help much, that guild simply wont raid for 24 hours and then do the exact same thing again. Not to mention it isnt their fault if 4 mercs join and dump 2e into the raid and then bail on it, taking up a slot they needed to complete the raid. Can't punish a guild for a merc's jerk-move.

Gotta see both sides of raiding, yes it is frustrating to push a lot of energy into a raid to find out they were never trying to finish (which is dumb cuz you still get the loyalty if you finish, plus you get valor and HT...) but there are some guilds and mercs that try hard to finish the raids they join.